Hello everyone! Welcome to our foundational journey into the fascinating world of organic chemistry. Today, we're going to demystify some incredibly important, yet often misunderstood, species called reactive intermediates. Think of these as the 'middle managers' of a chemical reaction – they don't stick around for long, but they play a crucial role in deciding what the final product will be.

Our focus today is on three key players: carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals. We'll learn what they are, how they're formed, and most importantly, what makes some of them more stable than others. Understanding their stability is like having a superpower in organic chemistry – it helps us predict how reactions will proceed!

Let's dive in!

---

### 1. The Carbocation: A Carbon Atom Feeling Positive!

Imagine a carbon atom that has lost one of its electrons during a chemical "fight" (bond breaking). It's now missing an electron, making it feel a bit "electron-deficient" and sporting a positive charge. This positively charged carbon species is what we call a carbocation.







* A carbocation has a carbon atom that's positively charged.
* It's bonded to three other atoms/groups.
* It has only 6 valence electrons around the carbon, not the usual 8 (octet rule violation!). This makes it hungry for electrons.
* The positively charged carbon is typically sp² hybridized, which means its geometry is trigonal planar (flat, like a peace sign).

How are Carbocations formed?
They are usually formed by a process called heterolytic cleavage, where a bond breaks, and *both* electrons go to one of the atoms, leaving the other atom (carbon, in this case) with a positive charge.

Analogy: Think of a carbocation as a person who just lost their wallet. They're feeling "positive" (optimistic they'll find it!) but are short on cash (electrons). They're looking for someone to lend them some money (donate electrons).

#### What Makes a Carbocation Stable?

A carbocation is unstable by nature because it lacks a full octet of electrons. So, anything that helps it get more electrons, or spread out its positive charge, will make it more stable. Let's look at the key factors:

##### a) Inductive Effect: The Electron-Pushers!

Imagine you're trying to share your snacks with a hungry friend (the positive carbon). If you have friends next to you who are also sharing *their* snacks, it helps your hungry friend even more, right? That's kind of what the inductive effect does.

* Alkyl groups (like -CH₃, -CH₂CH₃) are known as electron-donating groups (EDG). They have a slight tendency to push electron density through sigma bonds.
* When an alkyl group is attached to a carbocation, it *donates* some electron density towards the positive carbon, helping to neutralize its charge a bit.
* More alkyl groups = more electron donation = more stable carbocation!

Let's see the order of stability based on the number of alkyl groups:

Type of Carbocation	Structure Example	Number of Alkyl Groups	Stability
Methyl Carbocation	CH₃⁺	0	Least Stable
Primary (1°) Carbocation	R-CH₂⁺	1	More Stable than Methyl
Secondary (2°) Carbocation	R₂-CH⁺	2	More Stable than 1°
Tertiary (3°) Carbocation	R₃-C⁺	3	Most Stable

So, based on the inductive effect alone, a tertiary carbocation (3°) is the most stable because it has three alkyl groups donating electrons to the positive carbon.

##### b) Hyperconjugation: The "No-Bond Resonance"

This is a super cool concept! Imagine our hungry friend (carbocation) not only getting snacks from direct neighbors but also from their friends in the next room who are subtly passing some over.

* Hyperconjugation involves the overlap of a filled sigma (σ) bond orbital (specifically, a C-H bond on an adjacent carbon) with an adjacent empty p-orbital (the one on our positively charged carbon).
* This overlap allows electron density from the C-H bond to delocalize into the empty p-orbital, effectively spreading out the positive charge without forming a full pi bond. It's often called "no-bond resonance" because it looks like a resonance structure where a bond has disappeared.
* The carbons adjacent to the carbocation are called alpha-carbons, and the hydrogens attached to them are alpha-hydrogens.
* More alpha-hydrogens = more hyperconjugation = more stable carbocation!

Let's reconsider the stability order with hyperconjugation:

* Methyl Carbocation (CH₃⁺): 0 alpha-hydrogens. Very unstable.
* Primary (1°) Carbocation (e.g., CH₃CH₂⁺): Has 3 alpha-hydrogens (from the methyl group).
* Secondary (2°) Carbocation (e.g., (CH₃)₂CH⁺): Has 6 alpha-hydrogens (3 from each methyl group).
* Tertiary (3°) Carbocation (e.g., (CH₃)₃C⁺): Has 9 alpha-hydrogens (3 from each methyl group).

JEE Focus: Both inductive effect and hyperconjugation contribute to the 3° > 2° > 1° > methyl stability order for carbocations. Hyperconjugation is generally considered a more significant stabilizing factor than the inductive effect for simple alkyl carbocations.

##### c) Resonance Effect (Mesomeric Effect): Sharing is Caring!

This is the ultimate electron-sharing mechanism! If our hungry friend (carbocation) is part of a big party where everyone is passing snacks around freely (delocalizing electrons), they'll feel much better.

* When a carbocation can be drawn with multiple valid resonance structures, it means its positive charge (or electron deficiency) is spread out over several atoms.
* This delocalization of charge makes the carbocation much more stable.
* Allylic Carbocations (C=C-C⁺) and Benzylic Carbocations (Ph-C⁺) are excellent examples of resonance-stabilized carbocations.

* Allylic Carbocation: CH₂=CH-CH₂⁺
Here, the positive charge can be shared between the two end carbons via resonance with the pi bond.
CH₂=CH-CH₂⁺ ↔ ⁺CH₂-CH=CH₂
This makes it much more stable than a simple primary carbocation.

* Benzylic Carbocation: A carbon adjacent to a benzene ring carrying a positive charge. The benzene ring can delocalize the positive charge through its pi electron system.
A benzylic carbocation can be even more stable than a tertiary alkyl carbocation due to extensive resonance delocalization!

---

### 2. The Carbanion: A Carbon Atom Feeling Negative!

Now, let's flip the script. What if during that chemical "fight," our carbon atom gained an extra electron, or held onto *both* electrons from a broken bond? It would now have an extra electron, making it "electron-rich" and sporting a negative charge. This negatively charged carbon species is a carbanion.







* A carbanion has a carbon atom that's negatively charged.
* It's bonded to three other atoms/groups and has one lone pair of electrons.
* It has 8 valence electrons around the carbon (a full octet!).
* The negatively charged carbon is typically sp³ hybridized, giving it a pyramidal geometry (like ammonia, NH₃).

How are Carbanions formed?
Like carbocations, they are formed by heterolytic cleavage, but this time, the carbon atom gets *both* electrons from the broken bond.

Analogy: Think of a carbanion as a person who just got paid double for their work. They're feeling "negative" (they have too much cash, maybe worried about carrying it all!). They're looking for someone to give some money to (electron acceptors).

#### What Makes a Carbanion Stable?

A carbanion is unstable because of the localized negative charge and its electron-rich nature. So, anything that helps it *spread out* or *remove* some of its excess electron density will make it more stable.

##### a) Inductive Effect: The Electron-Withdrawing Saviors!

If our friend (the negative carbon) has too much cash, and their neighbors (attached groups) are also trying to give them *more* cash, that's not going to help, right? But if the neighbors are instead *taking* some cash, that would be helpful!

* Alkyl groups are electron-donating groups (EDG). They *donate* electron density.
* When an alkyl group is attached to a carbanion, it *adds* electron density to an already electron-rich carbon, intensifying the negative charge. This is destabilizing.
* More alkyl groups = more electron donation = less stable carbanion!

So, the stability order for carbanions is the exact opposite of carbocations based on the inductive effect:

Type of Carbanion	Structure Example	Number of Alkyl Groups	Stability
Methyl Carbanion	CH₃⁻	0	Most Stable
Primary (1°) Carbanion	R-CH₂⁻	1	Less Stable than Methyl
Secondary (2°) Carbanion	R₂-CH⁻	2	Less Stable than 1°
Tertiary (3°) Carbanion	R₃-C⁻	3	Least Stable

##### b) Resonance Effect (Mesomeric Effect): Sharing the Burden!

Just like with carbocations, if the negative charge can be delocalized over multiple atoms through resonance, it becomes much more stable.

* When the lone pair on the carbanion can participate in resonance with adjacent pi bonds or electron-withdrawing groups (like C=O, C≡N, or another benzene ring), the negative charge is spread out.
* Allylic Carbanions (C=C-C⁻) and Benzylic Carbanions (Ph-C⁻) are stabilized by resonance.

* Allylic Carbanion: CH₂=CH-CH₂⁻
The negative charge can be delocalized onto the other end of the pi system.
CH₂=CH-CH₂⁻ ↔ ⁻CH₂-CH=CH₂
This makes it more stable than a simple primary carbanion.

* Benzylic Carbanion: Similar to benzylic carbocations, the benzene ring can delocalize the negative charge.

##### c) Hybridization: Holding onto Electrons Tightly!

This factor is unique to carbanions and helps explain their stability.

* Think about how tightly an atom holds onto its electrons. This is related to its electronegativity.
* In terms of orbitals, an electron in an s-orbital is held closer to the nucleus than an electron in a p-orbital.
* Therefore, a carbon atom with more "s-character" in its hybrid orbital (e.g., sp hybridized) will be more electronegative and better able to accommodate a negative charge.

Order of s-character: sp (50%) > sp² (33%) > sp³ (25%)
More s-character = more electronegative carbon = more stable carbanion!

Stability order due to hybridization:
sp carbanion (e.g., HC≡C⁻) > sp² carbanion (e.g., H₂C=CH⁻) > sp³ carbanion (e.g., CH₃⁻)
This means acetylide anions (like RC≡C⁻) are surprisingly stable!

---

### 3. The Free Radical: A Carbon Atom with an Odd Friend!

Finally, let's talk about free radicals. What if, during our chemical "fight," a bond breaks in such a way that *each* atom gets one electron from the broken bond? This symmetrical breaking is called homolytic cleavage.

* A free radical has a carbon atom with an unpaired electron.
* It's bonded to three other atoms/groups.
* It has 7 valence electrons around the carbon (an odd number, not a full octet!). This makes it highly reactive.
* The carbon with the unpaired electron is typically sp² hybridized, with a trigonal planar geometry, and the unpaired electron resides in an unhybridized p-orbital.

Analogy: Imagine a free radical as a person who lost one glove in the winter. They're not completely naked (like a carbocation) and not overloaded (like a carbanion), but they're still unbalanced and looking for another glove (another electron) to pair up.

#### What Makes a Free Radical Stable?

Like carbocations, free radicals are electron-deficient (they want to complete their octet) and highly reactive. Factors that help delocalize the unpaired electron will stabilize it.

##### a) Inductive Effect: The Electron-Pushers (Again)!

Similar to carbocations, alkyl groups can help stabilize a free radical.

* Alkyl groups, being electron-donating, can push some electron density towards the carbon with the unpaired electron. This helps to reduce the "unpaired" nature and spread out the electron density.
* More alkyl groups = more electron donation = more stable free radical!

The stability order for free radicals, based on inductive effect (and also hyperconjugation), is the same as carbocations:

Type of Free Radical	Structure Example	Number of Alkyl Groups	Stability
Methyl Radical	CH₃•	0	Least Stable
Primary (1°) Radical	R-CH₂•	1	More Stable than Methyl
Secondary (2°) Radical	R₂-CH•	2	More Stable than 1°
Tertiary (3°) Radical	R₃-C•	3	Most Stable

##### b) Hyperconjugation: The "No-Bond Resonance" (Again)!

Just like carbocations, free radicals are stabilized by hyperconjugation.

* The unpaired electron in the p-orbital can interact with the adjacent C-H sigma bonds (alpha-hydrogens).
* This delocalization helps spread out the unpaired electron density.
* More alpha-hydrogens = more hyperconjugation = more stable free radical!

This is why the stability order 3° > 2° > 1° > methyl holds true for free radicals, just as it does for carbocations.

##### c) Resonance Effect (Mesomeric Effect): Sharing the Unpaired Electron!

When the unpaired electron can be delocalized over multiple atoms through resonance, the free radical becomes significantly more stable.

* Allylic Free Radicals (C=C-C•) and Benzylic Free Radicals (Ph-C•) are strongly stabilized by resonance, much like their carbocation counterparts.

* Allylic Radical: CH₂=CH-CH₂•
The unpaired electron can be delocalized across the pi system.
CH₂=CH-CH₂• ↔ •CH₂-CH=CH₂

* Benzylic Radical: The unpaired electron can be delocalized into the benzene ring.
Benzylic radicals are typically very stable, often more stable than tertiary alkyl radicals.

---

### Key Takeaway Summary

Let's put it all together in a neat table:

Feature	Carbocation	Carbanion	Free Radical
Charge/Electron Nature	Positive charge, electron-deficient (6e⁻)	Negative charge, electron-rich (8e⁻ + lone pair)	Unpaired electron, electron-deficient (7e⁻)
Hybridization	sp² (trigonal planar)	sp³ (pyramidal)	sp² (trigonal planar)
Formation	Heterolytic cleavage	Heterolytic cleavage	Homolytic cleavage
Stability by Inductive Effect (Alkyl Groups)	Alkyl EDGs stabilize. 3° > 2° > 1° > Methyl	Alkyl EDGs destabilize. Methyl > 1° > 2° > 3°	Alkyl EDGs stabilize. 3° > 2° > 1° > Methyl
Stability by Hyperconjugation	Stabilizes. More α-H = more stable.	N/A (no empty p-orbital for overlap)	Stabilizes. More α-H = more stable.
Stability by Resonance	Stabilizes (delocalizes positive charge). Allylic, Benzylic are very stable.	Stabilizes (delocalizes negative charge). Allylic, Benzylic are very stable.	Stabilizes (delocalizes unpaired electron). Allylic, Benzylic are very stable.
Stability by Hybridization	N/A (sp² preferred)	More s-character = more stable. sp > sp² > sp³	N/A (sp² preferred)

CBSE vs. JEE Focus: For both CBSE and JEE, understanding these fundamental stability orders and the reasons behind them (inductive effect, hyperconjugation, resonance, hybridization) is absolutely crucial. JEE might present more complex examples involving a combination of these effects, but the basic principles remain the same.

And that's our deep dive into the fundamentals of carbocation, carbanion, and free radical stability! Keep practicing, and these concepts will become second nature, giving you a powerful tool to understand and predict organic reactions. Good luck!

Alright, class! Today, we're going to dive deep into the fascinating world of reactive intermediates. These are highly energetic, short-lived species that play a crucial role in almost every organic reaction you'll encounter. Understanding their stability is paramount to predicting reaction mechanisms and outcomes, which is a core skill for both your board exams and the mighty JEE!

Think of reactive intermediates as the "pit stops" in a race – they're transient, but what happens at these pit stops (how stable they are) dictates how fast and how smoothly the race (reaction) proceeds. We'll focus on three main types: carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals.

### 1. The Electron-Deficient Warrior: Carbocations

Let's kick things off with carbocations. The name itself tells you a lot: "carbo" refers to carbon, and "cation" means it carries a positive charge. So, a carbocation is an organic species where a carbon atom bears a formal positive charge and has only six valence electrons.

#### What does a Carbocation look like?
Imagine a carbon atom that's lost one of its bonds' electrons. It now has only three bonds and a positive charge.
* Hybridization: This carbon is typically sp² hybridized.
* Geometry: Due to sp² hybridization and three bonding pairs, its geometry is trigonal planar, with bond angles of approximately 120°.
* Empty Orbital: Crucially, the positive charge resides in an empty, unhybridized p-orbital perpendicular to the plane of the three sp² hybrid orbitals. This empty orbital makes it highly electron-deficient and eager to accept electrons – it's a strong Lewis acid!

#### How are Carbocations Formed?
Carbocations often form via heterolytic bond cleavage, where a bond breaks, and both electrons go to one atom, leaving the other atom (carbon) with a positive charge. For example, when a good leaving group (like a halide ion or water molecule) departs from an alkyl halide or alcohol.

#### Factors Governing Carbocation Stability: The Electron Donors

A carbocation is "unhappy" because it's electron-deficient. So, anything that can donate electron density to this positive center will make it more stable. We'll primarily look at three effects:

##### a) Inductive Effect (+I Effect)
Alkyl groups (like methyl, ethyl, propyl, etc.) are electron-donating groups by a phenomenon called the +I (positive inductive) effect. They push a small amount of electron density through sigma bonds.
* The more alkyl groups attached to the positively charged carbon, the more electron density is pushed towards it, effectively dispersing the positive charge and stabilizing the carbocation.
* Order of stability by Inductive Effect:
3° (tertiary) carbocation > 2° (secondary) carbocation > 1° (primary) carbocation > Methyl carbocation
* 3° carbocation: Positively charged carbon attached to three alkyl groups.
* 2° carbocation: Positively charged carbon attached to two alkyl groups.
* 1° carbocation: Positively charged carbon attached to one alkyl group.
* Methyl carbocation: Positively charged carbon attached to three hydrogen atoms.

Example:

    CH₃

      |

    CH₃—C⊕  (Tertiary, most stable due to +I)

      |

    CH₃



    CH₃

      |

    CH₃—C⊕H  (Secondary)



    CH₃—C⊕H₂  (Primary)



    C⊕H₃   (Methyl, least stable due to +I)

    

##### b) Hyperconjugation (No-Bond Resonance)
This is a more powerful stabilizing effect than the simple inductive effect. Hyperconjugation involves the delocalization of electrons from a C-H (or C-C) sigma bond into an adjacent empty p-orbital (in carbocations) or a p-orbital containing an unpaired electron (in free radicals).
* For carbocations, we look at the C-H sigma bonds on the alpha-carbons (carbons directly attached to the positively charged carbon). These are called alpha-hydrogens.
* The electrons in these C-H sigma bonds can "overlap" with the empty p-orbital of the carbocation, effectively spreading out the positive charge.
* The greater the number of alpha-hydrogens, the greater the hyperconjugation, and thus, the greater the stability of the carbocation.

Example: Consider a secondary carbocation like sec-butyl carbocation.

    CH₃ — C⊕H — CH₂CH₃

          |

    Alpha-H on left C: 3

    Alpha-H on right C: 2

    Total Alpha-H = 3 + 2 = 5

    

Compare this to a tertiary carbocation, say, tert-butyl carbocation:

    CH₃

      |

    CH₃—C⊕

      |

    CH₃

    Total Alpha-H = 3 + 3 + 3 = 9

    

Since tert-butyl carbocation has 9 alpha-hydrogens compared to 5 for sec-butyl, tert-butyl is more stable. This reinforces the 3° > 2° > 1° order.

JEE Focus: Hyperconjugation is often the *dominant* effect when comparing alkyl carbocations. Remember to count all alpha-hydrogens!

##### c) Resonance Effect (Mesomeric Effect, +M or +R Effect)
This is the most potent stabilizing effect for carbocations. Resonance involves the delocalization of the positive charge through conjugated pi-electron systems or lone pairs of electrons from adjacent atoms.
* If the carbocation is adjacent to a double bond (like in an allylic carbocation) or an aromatic ring (like in a benzylic carbocation), the empty p-orbital can overlap with the pi-system, spreading the positive charge over multiple atoms. This delocalization significantly lowers the energy and increases stability.
* If the carbocation is adjacent to an atom with a lone pair (e.g., oxygen in an ether, nitrogen in an amine), that lone pair can be donated to form a new pi-bond, completely satisfying the octet of the positively charged carbon. This is an extremely powerful stabilization.

Examples:
1. Allylic Carbocation (CH₂=CH-C⊕H₂):

        CH₂=CH-C⊕H₂  ↔  ⊕CH₂-CH=CH₂

        

The positive charge is delocalized over two carbon atoms.
2. Benzylic Carbocation:

            CH₂⊕

           /  \n          C    C

         //    \

        HC      CH

         \    //

          C----C

             /

            CH₂⊕    ↔   (delocalization around the ring)

        

The positive charge is delocalized over the benzylic carbon and ortho/para positions of the benzene ring.
3. Carbocation adjacent to a heteroatom (e.g., oxygen):

        R-Ö-C⊕H₂  ↔  R-O⊕=CH₂

        

Here, the oxygen's lone pair forms a pi bond, giving the carbon a complete octet. This structure is highly stable.

Order of stability by Resonance Effect (general):
Carbocation with lone pair donation > Benzylic (3° > 2° > 1°) ~ Allylic (3° > 2° > 1°) > Alkyl (3° > 2° > 1°) > Vinyl > Phenyl

* Vinyl Carbocation (CH₂=C⊕H): The positive charge is directly on an sp² hybridized carbon within a double bond. This is highly unstable because the sp² carbon is more electronegative (due to higher s-character) and less able to accommodate a positive charge compared to an sp³ carbon.
* Phenyl Carbocation: Similar to vinyl, the positive charge is directly on a carbon that is part of the aromatic ring, which is sp² hybridized. Highly unstable.

#### General Stability Order for Carbocations:
Putting it all together, the general order of stability for common carbocations is:

Resonance Stabilized (especially by lone pair) > Benzylic (3° > 2° > 1°) ≈ Allylic (3° > 2° > 1°) > Alkyl (3° > 2° > 1° > Methyl) > Vinyl > Phenyl

Important Nuance (JEE Advanced): Sometimes, the relative stability between highly resonance-stabilized primary benzylic/allylic and highly hyperconjugation-stabilized tertiary alkyl carbocations can be subtle. Generally, resonance is more potent. For instance, a 1° benzylic carbocation (stabilized by resonance) is more stable than a 3° alkyl carbocation (stabilized by hyperconjugation).

Example Comparison:
1. C₆H₅-C⊕H₂ (Benzyl carbocation): Stabilized by resonance with the benzene ring.
2. (CH₃)₃C⊕ (tert-Butyl carbocation): Stabilized by 9 alpha-hydrogens via hyperconjugation and +I effect.

Benzyl Carbocation > tert-Butyl Carbocation

This highlights that extensive resonance stabilization often trumps hyperconjugation.

JEE Special Case: Carbocation Rearrangements
Because carbocations can rearrange to form more stable carbocations (e.g., from 2° to 3°, or to a resonance-stabilized one) via hydride (H⁻) shifts or alkyl (R⁻) shifts, these rearrangements are frequently tested in JEE. A less stable carbocation will spontaneously rearrange to a more stable one if possible.

### 2. The Electron-Rich Rebel: Carbanions

Now, let's flip the script and talk about carbanions. A carbanion is an organic species where a carbon atom bears a formal negative charge and has eight valence electrons (a lone pair plus three bonds).

#### What does a Carbanion look like?
* Hybridization: Typically sp³ hybridized, resembling an amine or ammonia, with the lone pair residing in one of the sp³ hybrid orbitals.
* Geometry: This results in a pyramidal geometry.
* Exception: If the carbanion is resonance-stabilized (e.g., an enolate), the carbanionic carbon can be sp² hybridized to allow the lone pair to participate in resonance with an adjacent pi-system.

#### How are Carbanions Formed?
Carbanions are usually formed by the deprotonation of an acidic C-H bond (e.g., by a strong base like NaNH₂ or an organometallic reagent like Grignard reagent).

#### Factors Governing Carbanion Stability: The Electron Acceptors

A carbanion is "unhappy" because it has excess electron density (a negative charge and an octet). So, anything that can withdraw electron density from this negative center will make it more stable.

##### a) Inductive Effect (-I Effect)
Alkyl groups are electron-donating (+I effect). Therefore, they will destabilize a carbanion by intensifying the negative charge. Conversely, electron-withdrawing groups (-I effect) like halogens (F, Cl, Br, I) or nitro groups (-NO₂) will stabilize a carbanion.
* The more alkyl groups attached to the negatively charged carbon, the more destabilized it will be.
* Order of stability by Inductive Effect (opposite to carbocations):
Methyl carbanion > 1° carbanion > 2° carbanion > 3° carbanion

Example:

    C⁻H₃   (Methyl, most stable due to +I effect being minimal)



    CH₃—C⁻H₂  (Primary)



    CH₃

      |

    CH₃—C⁻H  (Secondary)



    CH₃

      |

    CH₃—C⁻  (Tertiary, least stable due to +I)

      |

    CH₃

    

##### b) Resonance Effect (-R or -M Effect)
This is the most significant stabilizing factor for carbanions. If the negative charge can be delocalized into an adjacent pi-system or by an adjacent electron-withdrawing group, the carbanion's stability drastically increases.
* The lone pair on the carbanionic carbon can participate in resonance if it's adjacent to a C=C, C=O, C≡N, or an aromatic ring.
* Especially powerful stabilization occurs when the negative charge is delocalized onto an electronegative atom like oxygen (as in enolates) or nitrogen (as in nitriles).

Examples:
1. Allylic Carbanion (CH₂=CH-C⁻H₂):

        CH₂=CH-C⁻H₂  ↔  ⁻CH₂-CH=CH₂

        

Negative charge is delocalized over two carbon atoms.
2. Benzylic Carbanion: The negative charge is delocalized into the benzene ring.
3. Enolate Carbanion (α-carbon of a carbonyl compound):

        R-C(O)-C⁻H₂  ↔  R-C(O⁻)=CH₂

        

Here, the negative charge is delocalized onto the highly electronegative oxygen atom, which is very stabilizing. This is why alpha-hydrogens of carbonyl compounds are acidic.
4. Carbanion adjacent to a nitro group (-NO₂): Nitro groups are powerful electron-withdrawing groups by resonance.

Order of stability by Resonance Effect (general):
Enolate/Nitro-stabilized > Benzylic > Allylic > Alkyl

##### c) Effect of Hybridization (s-character)
This is a crucial factor for carbanion stability. The more s-character the orbital holding the lone pair has, the closer the electrons are to the nucleus, and thus, the more stable the negative charge.
* sp hybridized carbon: Has 50% s-character.
* sp² hybridized carbon: Has 33% s-character.
* sp³ hybridized carbon: Has 25% s-character.
* Since s-orbitals are closer to the nucleus, a negative charge is better accommodated in an orbital with higher s-character.
* Order of stability due to hybridization:
sp Carbanion (e.g., acetylide anion RC≡C⁻) > sp² Carbanion (e.g., vinyl anion CH₂=CH⁻) > sp³ Carbanion (e.g., alkyl anion)

This explains why terminal alkynes are much more acidic than alkenes or alkanes.

#### General Stability Order for Carbanions:
Combining these factors, the general order of stability for carbanions is:

Resonance stabilized (especially by EWG like -NO₂ or C=O) > sp hybridized > Benzylic > Allylic > Methyl > 1° > 2° > 3°

JEE Focus: Acidity of protons often correlates directly with the stability of the conjugate base (carbanion). The more stable the carbanion formed, the more acidic the proton. This concept is vital for understanding reactions like aldol condensations, Claisen condensations, and various deprotonation steps.

### 3. The Unpaired Wanderer: Free Radicals

Finally, let's explore free radicals. A free radical is an organic species that contains at least one unpaired electron. This unpaired electron makes them highly reactive and paramagnetic.

#### What does a Free Radical look like?
* Hybridization: The carbon bearing the unpaired electron is typically sp² hybridized.
* Geometry: Like carbocations, it usually adopts a trigonal planar geometry, with the unpaired electron residing in an unhybridized p-orbital (or sometimes an sp³ orbital, but p-orbital is more common for stability reasons).
* Electron Count: It has seven valence electrons on the carbon (three bonds + one unpaired electron). It's electron-deficient but not formally charged.

#### How are Free Radicals Formed?
Free radicals are formed by homolytic bond cleavage, where a bond breaks, and each atom gets one electron from the shared pair. This is often initiated by heat or light.

#### Factors Governing Free Radical Stability: The Electron Dispersers

Like carbocations, free radicals are stabilized by anything that can disperse the unpaired electron density or provide electron density to the electron-deficient center.

##### a) Inductive Effect (+I Effect)
Similar to carbocations, alkyl groups donate electron density through the +I effect, stabilizing the radical center.
* Order of stability by Inductive Effect:
3° free radical > 2° free radical > 1° free radical > Methyl free radical

Example:

    CH₃

      |

    CH₃—C•   (Tertiary, most stable due to +I)

      |

    CH₃



    CH₃

      |

    CH₃—C•H  (Secondary)



    CH₃—C•H₂  (Primary)



    C•H₃    (Methyl, least stable due to +I)

    

##### b) Hyperconjugation
This is a very important stabilizing factor for free radicals, similar to carbocations. The C-H sigma bonds on the alpha-carbons can overlap with the p-orbital containing the unpaired electron, delocalizing it.
* The greater the number of alpha-hydrogens, the greater the hyperconjugation, and thus, the greater the stability of the free radical.

Example:
* tert-Butyl radical has 9 alpha-hydrogens.
* sec-Butyl radical has 5 alpha-hydrogens.
* tert-Butyl radical is more stable due to more hyperconjugation.

##### c) Resonance Effect
Resonance is the most powerful stabilizing effect for free radicals. When the carbon bearing the unpaired electron is adjacent to a pi-system, the unpaired electron can delocalize into that system.
* Allylic free radical (CH₂=CH-C•H₂): The unpaired electron can delocalize over two carbon atoms.
* Benzylic free radical: The unpaired electron can delocalize into the benzene ring.

Example: Allylic Free Radical

    CH₂=CH-C•H₂  ↔  •CH₂-CH=CH₂

    

#### General Stability Order for Free Radicals:
The general order of stability for free radicals is strikingly similar to carbocations, as both are electron-deficient species seeking electron density.

Resonance stabilized (Benzylic > Allylic) > Alkyl (3° > 2° > 1° > Methyl) > Vinyl > Phenyl

JEE Focus: Free radical stability is critical for understanding reactions like radical halogenation of alkanes, polymerization, and certain anti-Markovnikov additions.

### Comparative Summary: Stability Orders

To wrap it up, here's a quick comparison of the general stability orders for our three intermediates:

Intermediate	Most Stable	Intermediate Stability	Least Stable	Key Stabilizing Factors
Carbocation (C⊕)	Resonance (lone pair donation, benzylic/allylic)	3° > 2° > 1° > Methyl	Vinyl / Phenyl	Resonance > Hyperconjugation > +I Effect
Carbanion (C⁻)	Resonance (onto EWG, sp-hybridized)	Methyl > 1° > 2° > 3°	3° Alkyl	Resonance (onto EWG) > Hybridization (sp > sp² > sp³) > -I Effect
Free Radical (C•)	Resonance (benzylic/allylic)	3° > 2° > 1° > Methyl	Vinyl / Phenyl	Resonance > Hyperconjugation > +I Effect

### JEE Advanced Insights & Common Pitfalls:

1. Anti-aromaticity: While aromaticity (like the tropylium cation) can greatly stabilize carbocations, anti-aromaticity (like cyclopropenyl anion or cyclobutadienyl dication) will drastically *destabilize* these intermediates. Always check for Hückel's Rule (4n+2 for aromatic, 4n for anti-aromatic) when cyclic, conjugated systems are involved.
2. Bredt's Rule: This rule states that a double bond cannot be placed at a bridgehead position in a bicyclic system if the rings are small. This also extends to carbocations and free radicals; bridgehead carbocations and radicals are highly unstable because they cannot achieve the necessary planar geometry for sp² hybridization without extreme ring strain.
3. Steric Inhibition of Resonance: In some cases, bulky groups might hinder the coplanarity required for effective resonance, thereby reducing stability. This is a subtle effect but can be tested in advanced problems.

Understanding the stability of these intermediates is not just about memorizing orders, but about grasping the underlying electronic effects that govern their behavior. Keep practicing with examples, and you'll master this crucial concept for your JEE journey!

Understanding the stability of carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals is fundamental to predicting reaction mechanisms in organic chemistry. While the underlying principles (resonance, inductive effect, hyperconjugation) are crucial, mnemonics and short-cuts can significantly aid in quickly recalling their stability orders, especially under exam pressure.

General Rule (Supersedes Alkyl Order)

• Resonance Stabilization: If resonance is possible (e.g., allylic, benzylic species), it almost always provides significantly greater stability than inductive or hyperconjugative effects alone. Always check for resonance first!

1. Carbocation Stability (C⁺)

Carbocations are electron-deficient species (positively charged) and are stabilized by electron-donating groups. The primary stabilizing effects are hyperconjugation and the +I (positive inductive) effect of alkyl groups.

• Stability Order (Alkyl Groups): 3° > 2° > 1° > Methyl (CH₃⁺)

Mnemonic/Short-cut: "Positive Charges Love More Friends"

• Positive Charges: Refers to Carbocations.


• Love More Friends: More alkyl groups (friends) mean more electron donation via hyperconjugation and +I effect, leading to greater stability. Hence, 3 friends (3°) > 2 friends (2°) > 1 friend (1°) > no friends (Methyl).

JEE Tip: Remember that allyl and benzyl carbocations are highly stable due to resonance (e.g., Allyl > 3° alkyl).

2. Carbanion Stability (C^-)

Carbanions are electron-rich species (negatively charged) and are stabilized by electron-withdrawing groups. The primary destabilizing effects are the +I (positive inductive) effect of alkyl groups.

• Stability Order (Alkyl Groups): Methyl (CH₃⁻) > 1° > 2° > 3°

Mnemonic/Short-cut: "Negative Charges Hate More Debt"

• Negative Charges: Refers to Carbanions.


• Hate More Debt: Alkyl groups are electron-donating, which adds "debt" (more electron density) to an already electron-rich species, thus destabilizing it. So, more alkyl groups = less stable. Hence, no debt (Methyl) > little debt (1°) > more debt (2°) > lots of debt (3°).

JEE Tip: Carbanions are strongly stabilized by electron-withdrawing groups (e.g., -NO₂, -CN, -COOR) and resonance. For example, if the negative charge is on an sp-hybridized carbon (like in alkynes), it's more stable than on sp² or sp³ because of higher s-character and electron-withdrawing nature.

3. Free Radical Stability (C^•)

Free radicals are neutral species with an unpaired electron. They are also electron-deficient (though not charged) and behave similarly to carbocations in terms of stabilization by electron-donating groups via hyperconjugation and the +I effect of alkyl groups.

• Stability Order (Alkyl Groups): 3° > 2° > 1° > Methyl (CH₃•)

Mnemonic/Short-cut: "Free Radicals are Free to Mimic Cations"

• Free Radicals: Refers to radicals.


• Mimic Cations: Their stability order with respect to alkyl groups is the same as carbocations. Therefore, they also prefer more electron-donating alkyl groups. Hence, 3° > 2° > 1° > Methyl.

JEE Tip: Similar to carbocations, allylic and benzylic free radicals are highly stable due to resonance (e.g., Allyl > 3° alkyl).

Species	Stabilizing/Destabilizing Factors	Alkyl Stability Order	Mnemonic/Short-cut
Carbocation (C⁺)	Electron-donating groups (+I, Hyperconjugation)	3° > 2° > 1° > CH₃⁺	"Positive Charges Love More Friends"
Carbanion (C⁻)	Electron-withdrawing groups (Alkyls destabilize via +I)	CH₃⁻ > 1° > 2° > 3°	"Negative Charges Hate More Debt"
Free Radical (C•)	Electron-donating groups (+I, Hyperconjugation)	3° > 2° > 1° > CH₃•	"Free Radicals are Free to Mimic Cations"

By employing these mnemonics, you can quickly recall the basic stability trends. However, always remember to combine this with a strong understanding of resonance, inductive effects, and hyperconjugation for a complete conceptual grasp, which is essential for solving complex JEE problems.

Mastering the relative stability of reactive intermediates like carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals is crucial for understanding reaction mechanisms in organic chemistry. These quick tips will help you quickly determine stability in exams.

● Carbocation Stability Quick Tips

Carbocations are electron-deficient species (positive charge). Their stability is enhanced by electron-donating effects.

• Primary Order of Effects: Resonance > Hyperconjugation > Inductive Effect (+I).


• Resonance Stabilization:
  
  
  
  • Look for conjugation with pi bonds (double/triple bonds) or lone pairs.
  
  
  • More resonating structures = More stable.
  
  
  • Examples: Allylic (R-CH=CH-CH₂⁺), Benzylic (Ph-CH₂⁺) carbocations are highly stabilized.
  
  
  • Adjacent atoms with lone pairs (e.g., O, N) can significantly stabilize carbocations via back-donation (e.g., R-O-CH₂⁺ is more stable than R-CH₂⁺).
  
  
  
  


• Hyperconjugation (α-H Effect):
  
  
  
  • Count the number of α-hydrogens (hydrogens on carbon atoms adjacent to the carbocationic carbon).
  
  
  • More α-hydrogens = More stable.
  
  
  • Stability Order: 3° > 2° > 1° > Methyl Carbocation (due to increasing α-H count).
  
  
  
  


• Inductive Effect (+I):
  
  
  
  • Alkyl groups (e.g., -CH₃, -C₂H₅) are electron-donating (+I effect).
  
  
  • More alkyl groups attached to the carbocationic carbon = More stable. This effect is secondary to hyperconjugation.
  
  
  • Electron-withdrawing groups (-I effect) like -NO₂, -CN, -F destabilize carbocations.
  
  
  
  

● Carbanion Stability Quick Tips

Carbanions are electron-rich species (negative charge). Their stability is enhanced by electron-withdrawing effects.

• Primary Order of Effects: Resonance > Inductive Effect (-I) > Hybridization.


• Resonance Stabilization:
  
  
  
  • Look for conjugation with pi bonds or adjacent empty d-orbitals.
  
  
  • More resonating structures = More stable.
  
  
  • Examples: Allylic (R-CH=CH-CH₂⁻), Benzylic (Ph-CH₂⁻) carbanions are highly stabilized.
  
  
  • Stabilization is particularly strong when the negative charge is delocalized onto an electronegative atom (e.g., carbonyl compounds: R-CO-CH₂⁻).
  
  
  
  


• Inductive Effect (-I):
  
  
  
  • Electron-withdrawing groups (-NO₂, -CN, -F, -Cl) stabilize carbanions by dispersing the negative charge.
  
  
  • Stronger/closer electron-withdrawing groups = More stable.
  
  
  • Alkyl groups are electron-donating (+I effect) and destabilize carbanions.
  
  
  • Stability Order (based on +I): Methyl > 1° > 2° > 3° Carbanion.
  
  
  
  


• Hybridization:
  
  
  
  • Higher s-character of the carbon bearing the negative charge leads to greater electronegativity and better accommodation of the negative charge.
  
  
  • Stability Order: sp > sp² > sp³ (e.g., Acetylide anion > Vinylic anion > Alkyl anion).
  
  
  
  

● Free Radical Stability Quick Tips

Free radicals are species with an unpaired electron. Their stability is enhanced by effects that can delocalize or spread out the unpaired electron.

• Primary Order of Effects: Resonance > Hyperconjugation > Inductive Effect (+I). (Similar to Carbocations)


• Resonance Stabilization:
  
  
  
  • Look for conjugation with pi bonds.
  
  
  • More resonating structures = More stable.
  
  
  • Examples: Allylic (R-CH=CH-CH₂•), Benzylic (Ph-CH₂•) free radicals are highly stabilized.
  
  
  
  


• Hyperconjugation (α-H Effect):
  
  
  
  • Count the number of α-hydrogens (hydrogens on carbon atoms adjacent to the radical carbon).
  
  
  • More α-hydrogens = More stable.
  
  
  • Stability Order: 3° > 2° > 1° > Methyl Free Radical.
  
  
  
  


• Inductive Effect (+I):
  
  
  
  • Alkyl groups (+I effect) slightly stabilize free radicals by pushing electron density towards the radical center, helping to disperse the unpaired electron. This effect is generally less significant than resonance or hyperconjugation.
  
  
  • Electron-withdrawing groups (-I effect) generally destabilize free radicals.
  
  
  
  

● JEE & CBSE Exam Focus

• Comparative Questions: Expect questions asking you to rank the stability of given sets of carbocations, carbanions, or free radicals.


• Mechanism Questions: Stability directly dictates the feasibility of reaction pathways. Understanding stability is key to predicting major products.


• Prioritize: Always look for resonance first. If resonance is present, it usually dominates over hyperconjugation and inductive effects.


• Don't Confuse: Be careful not to apply carbocation rules to carbanions or vice versa. They have opposite needs for electron density.

Keep practicing and you'll quickly master these stability comparisons!

Intuitive Understanding of Carbocation, Carbanion, and Free Radical Stability

Understanding the stability of reactive intermediates like carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals is fundamental to predicting reaction pathways in organic chemistry. At its core, stability in these species is about achieving a more balanced distribution of charge or electron density. Unstable species are those with localized, concentrated charges or unpaired electrons, while stable species manage to delocalize or disperse these.

1. Carbocations: The "Electron-Hungry" Carbon

A carbocation features a carbon atom with a positive charge and only six valence electrons, making it electron-deficient. Think of it as a carbon atom that's "hungry" for electrons.

* Intuitive Idea: Anything that can donate electron density to this electron-hungry carbon will stabilize it.
* Stabilizing Factors:
* Inductive Effect (+I groups): Alkyl groups (like -CH₃, -CH₂CH₃) are slightly electron-donating. They "push" electron density towards the positive carbon, helping to neutralize its charge. More alkyl groups mean more electron donation, leading to greater stability.
* Hyperconjugation: This involves the slight overlap of adjacent C-H or C-C sigma bonds with the empty p-orbital of the carbocation. It's like the neighboring hydrogens (or carbons) "sharing" a bit of their electron density with the positive carbon. More alpha-hydrogens (hydrogens on carbons adjacent to the carbocation) lead to more hyperconjugative structures and thus greater stability.
* Resonance: If the positive charge can be delocalized over multiple atoms through pi-bonds, the stability dramatically increases. This is the most powerful stabilizing effect.
* Stability Order: Tertiary (3°) > Secondary (2°) > Primary (1°) > Methyl. This order directly reflects the increasing number of alkyl groups and alpha-hydrogens, providing more inductive and hyperconjugative stabilization.

2. Carbanions: The "Electron-Rich" Carbon

A carbanion has a carbon atom with a negative charge and an unshared pair of electrons, making it electron-rich. Think of it as a carbon atom that has "too many" electrons concentrated in one place.

* Intuitive Idea: Anything that can pull electron density away from this electron-rich carbon will stabilize it by dispersing the negative charge.
* Stabilizing Factors:
* Inductive Effect (-I groups): Electron-withdrawing groups (like halogens, -NO₂, -CN) pull electron density away from the negative carbon, helping to spread out the charge.
* Resonance: If the negative charge can be delocalized over multiple atoms through pi-bonds, the stability increases significantly. This is again a powerful stabilizing effect.
* Destabilizing Factor: Alkyl groups, being electron-donating, intensify the negative charge on the carbanion, making it less stable.
* Stability Order (without resonance): Methyl > Primary (1°) > Secondary (2°) > Tertiary (3°). This is the exact opposite of carbocations because electron-donating alkyl groups destabilize a negative charge.

3. Free Radicals: The "Single-Electron" Carbon

A free radical has a carbon atom with a single, unpaired electron. It's not a full charge, but an unusual electron configuration that seeks pairing or delocalization. Think of it as an atom that wants to "share" its single electron or "spread it out" to minimize its unique character.

* Intuitive Idea: Anything that can help delocalize or "spread out" this unpaired electron will stabilize the radical.
* Stabilizing Factors:
* Hyperconjugation: Similar to carbocations, adjacent C-H sigma bonds can overlap with the p-orbital containing the unpaired electron, helping to delocalize it. More alpha-hydrogens mean more stable free radicals.
* Resonance: If the unpaired electron can be delocalized over multiple atoms through pi-bonds, the stability dramatically increases. This is the most powerful stabilizing effect.
* Stability Order: Tertiary (3°) > Secondary (2°) > Primary (1°) > Methyl. This order is similar to carbocations because hyperconjugation is the primary stabilizing effect (in the absence of resonance), and more alkyl groups provide more alpha-hydrogens.

JEE/CBSE Focus: While CBSE expects you to know the stability orders based on inductive and hyperconjugation effects, JEE often presents more complex scenarios involving resonance, which is a far more powerful stabilizing factor than inductive or hyperconjugative effects alone. Always prioritize resonance when comparing stability.

Understanding the stability of reactive intermediates like carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals can be challenging. Analogies can provide intuitive ways to grasp why certain factors influence their stability. The core idea is always about distributing or delocalizing a charge or an unpaired electron.

Common Analogies for Stability

• 
  

  Carbocation Stability (Positive Charge: Electron Deficient)

  
  

  Imagine a person who is financially in debt (the positive charge, or lack of electrons). This person is in an unstable situation and needs help.

  
  
  
  
  • 
    Stabilization: If a few friends or family members (electron-donating groups like alkyl groups, through inductive effect or hyperconjugation) decide to chip in and give them some money, the burden on the indebted person is lessened. The more people who help, and the more effectively they help, the more stable (less stressed) the person becomes.
    
  
  
  • 
    Resonance: If this person has multiple income streams or assets they can leverage (resonance structures), they can spread out their financial burden across different sources, making the debt less critical at any one point. The "debt" is delocalized.
    
  
  
  • 
    Outcome: Just like a person with more financial support and diverse assets is more stable, a carbocation with more electron-donating groups and effective resonance stabilization is more stable.
    
  
  
  
  


• 
  

  Carbanion Stability (Negative Charge: Electron Rich)

  
  

  Consider a person carrying a heavy, overloaded backpack (the negative charge, or excess of electrons). They are unbalanced and unstable due to the excess weight.

  
  
  
  
  • 
    Stabilization: If a few friends (electron-withdrawing groups, through inductive effect) help by taking some items out of the backpack, the load becomes lighter and the person becomes more stable. The more effectively these friends can "pull" the excess away, the better.
    
  
  
  • 
    Resonance: If the person can distribute the contents of the heavy backpack into multiple smaller bags or lockers (resonance structures), the excessive load is spread out, making it easier to carry and the person more balanced. The "excess" is delocalized.
    
  
  
  • 
    Outcome: A carbanion is more stable when electron-withdrawing groups can reduce the electron density and when resonance can delocalize the negative charge.
    
  
  
  
  


• 
  

  Free Radical Stability (Unpaired Electron: Lonely & Reactive)

  
  

  Think of an unmarried person at a party where everyone else is in couples (the unpaired electron). This person feels "alone" and might be actively looking for a partner, making them reactive and a bit uncomfortable.

  
  
  
  
  • 
    Stabilization: If there are other friendly people or groups nearby who can engage them in conversation or activity (electron-donating groups, hyperconjugation), the "lonely" feeling is shared or diffused. It's not about finding a partner, but about making the unpaired state less isolated and reactive.
    
  
  
  • 
    Resonance: If the party is large and the person can move freely between different groups of people and conversations (resonance structures), their "loneliness" is never focused on one spot; it's spread out, making them feel less isolated and more comfortable (less reactive). The "unpairedness" is delocalized.
    
  
  
  • 
    Outcome: A free radical is stabilized when its unpaired electron can be shared or delocalized over a larger area through hyperconjugation or resonance, making it less concentrated and less reactive.
    
  
  
  
  


• 
  

  The "Hot Potato" Analogy (General Principle)

  
  

  Imagine any charge (positive, negative, or unpaired electron) as a "hot potato." Holding a hot potato in one hand for too long is uncomfortable and unstable. The best way to deal with it is to pass it around quickly among as many people as possible, or to have many hands to hold it simultaneously.

  
  
  
  
  • 
    More Hands (Resonance): If you have many people (atoms capable of resonance) to pass the hot potato to, it spends less time in any single hand, making the overall situation more stable.
    
  
  
  • 
    Sharing the Burden (Inductive/Hyperconjugation): If your friends (neighboring groups) can help you hold the hot potato, even without taking it completely, the burden on your hand is reduced, making it more stable.
    
  
  
  • 
    Key Insight: Any factor that helps delocalize or distribute the "hot potato" (charge or unpaired electron) makes the intermediate more stable. This applies universally to carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals.
    
  
  
  
  

JEE/CBSE Tip: Analogies are excellent for building conceptual understanding. However, for exams, always explain stability using proper chemical terms like "inductive effect," "hyperconjugation," "resonance," and "delocalization of charge/electron density."

Keep practicing and these concepts will become second nature!

To effectively understand the stability of carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals, a solid grasp of certain fundamental organic chemistry principles is essential. These concepts lay the groundwork for analyzing electron distribution and delocalization, which are key determinants of intermediate stability.

Here are the crucial prerequisites:

• 
  Basic Organic Chemistry Terminology:
  
  
  
  • Understanding the terms like primary (1°), secondary (2°), and tertiary (3°) carbon atoms.
  
  
  • Familiarity with functional groups and common organic compounds.
  
  
  
  


• 
  Chemical Bonding and Molecular Structure:
  
  
  
  • Covalent Bonds: Knowledge of sigma (σ) and pi (π) bonds.
  
  
  • Hybridization: A clear understanding of sp³, sp², and sp hybridization, as it dictates the geometry and orbital structure of these intermediates. For instance, carbocations are typically sp² hybridized and trigonal planar.
  
  
  • Lewis Structures and Formal Charge: Ability to draw accurate Lewis structures and calculate formal charges on atoms. This helps in visualizing electron deficiencies (carbocations) or excesses (carbanions).
  
  
  
  


• 
  Electronegativity:
  
  
  
  • Understanding the concept of electronegativity and how differences in electronegativity between atoms affect bond polarity and electron distribution within a molecule.
  
  
  
  


• 
  Fundamental Electronic Effects: This is perhaps the most critical prerequisite.
  
  
  
  • Inductive Effect (I-effect): Basic understanding of electron donation (+I) and electron withdrawal (-I) through sigma bonds. Knowing common groups exhibiting these effects is vital.
  
  
  • Resonance Effect (Mesomeric Effect, R-effect/M-effect): A thorough understanding of resonance structures, delocalization of π electrons, and identifying groups that show +R or -R effects. This is paramount for explaining the stability of most conjugated carbocations and carbanions. (JEE Main/Advanced often tests complex resonance scenarios.)
  
  
  • Hyperconjugation (No-Bond Resonance): Basic concept of electron delocalization involving σ bonds of alkyl groups adjacent to an sp² hybridized carbon (as in alkenes, carbocations, and free radicals). This is particularly important for explaining the stability order of carbocations and free radicals.
  
  
  
  


• 
  Acid-Base Concepts (Brief):
  
  
  
  • A general idea of Brønsted-Lowry and Lewis acid-base definitions can be helpful. Understanding how electron-pair donation/acceptance relates to stability can provide a conceptual bridge to intermediate stability.
  
  
  
  

Motivation: Mastering these foundational concepts will make the study of carbocation, carbanion, and free radical stability not only easier but also much more intuitive, helping you to confidently tackle reaction mechanisms in future topics.

Understanding the stability of carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals is a cornerstone of organic chemistry. To master this topic, it's essential to have a firm grasp of several foundational concepts. These related topics provide the theoretical framework necessary to explain and predict the behavior of these reactive intermediates.

Key Related Topics:

• Electronic Displacement Effects (GOC-I):
  
  
  
  • Inductive Effect (+I and -I): This permanent effect involves the displacement of sigma electrons along a carbon chain due to the presence of an electronegative or electropositive group. It plays a crucial role in stabilizing or destabilizing charge/radical density. For instance, alkyl groups exhibit a +I effect, which stabilizes carbocations and free radicals by donating electron density, but destabilizes carbanions.
  
  
  • Resonance Effect (Mesomeric Effect, +R and -R): This effect involves the delocalization of pi electrons or lone pair electrons through conjugated systems. It is often the most significant stabilizing factor for carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals by spreading the charge or unpaired electron over multiple atoms. Compounds like allyl and benzyl systems exemplify resonance stabilization.
  
  
  • Hyperconjugation Effect: This "no-bond resonance" effect involves the delocalization of sigma electrons of C-H bonds adjacent to a pi system or an atom with an unhybridized p-orbital (like in carbocations or free radicals). It is a significant stabilizing factor for carbocations and free radicals, particularly for alkyl-substituted species (e.g., tertiary carbocations are more stable than secondary due to more alpha-hydrogens).
  
  
  • Aromaticity: The concept of aromaticity (Hückel's Rule) provides exceptional stability to certain cyclic, planar, conjugated systems. Aromatic carbocations (e.g., tropylium cation) and carbanions (e.g., cyclopentadienyl anion) exhibit unusual stability due to delocalization consistent with aromatic character.
  
  
  
  


• Bonding and Hybridization:
  
  
  
  • Types of Covalent Bonds (sigma and pi): A basic understanding of single, double, and triple bonds is necessary to comprehend electron delocalization.
  
  
  • Hybridization (sp, sp², sp³): The hybridization state of the carbon atom bearing the charge or unpaired electron directly influences its stability. For carbanions, higher s-character (e.g., sp > sp² > sp³) implies greater stability due to the closer proximity of the lone pair to the more electronegative nucleus. For carbocations, sp² hybridization allows for a planar structure conducive to resonance and hyperconjugation.
  
  
  
  


• Acid-Base Concepts:
  
  
  
  • Brønsted-Lowry and Lewis Acid-Base Definitions: These concepts are directly related to carbanion stability. A more stable carbanion is typically formed from a stronger acid. Understanding pKa values and trends in acidity is crucial for comparing carbanion stabilities.
  
  
  
  


• Reaction Intermediates and Mechanisms:
  
  
  
  • While this topic focuses on stability, these intermediates are central to understanding various organic reaction mechanisms (e.g., S_N1, E1, Electrophilic Addition, Free Radical Substitution). A solid grasp of their stability helps predict reaction pathways and major products, which is a common area for JEE Main questions.
  
  
  
  

JEE Main Tip: These fundamental principles (especially electronic effects) are interconnected and frequently tested. A strong understanding of GOC-I is indispensable for predicting the stability of all types of reactive intermediates, which in turn helps in understanding reaction mechanisms.

Common Exam Traps: Carbocations, Carbanions, and Free Radical Stability

Understanding the relative stability of carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals is fundamental to organic chemistry. However, exams often set up tricky scenarios designed to test your conceptual clarity. Be vigilant against these common pitfalls:

1. 
   Miscounting Alpha-Hydrogens for Hyperconjugation:
   
   
   
   • The Trap: A very frequent error, especially under time pressure, is incorrectly identifying or counting alpha-hydrogens. Remember, alpha-hydrogens are hydrogens on the carbon atom(s) directly adjacent to the carbon bearing the positive charge (carbocation), the radical electron (free radical), or the lone pair (carbanion).
   
   
   • Why it's Tricky: Students sometimes include hydrogens on the charged/radical carbon itself or on carbons further down the chain.
   
   
   • Exam Tip (JEE Main & CBSE): Always draw the structure clearly and systematically identify alpha-carbons first, then count the hydrogens on *those* carbons. More alpha-hydrogens generally mean greater stability for carbocations and free radicals due to hyperconjugation. For carbanions, hyperconjugation is generally destabilizing (unless it's with an electron-withdrawing group via resonance).
   
   
   • Example: For (CH₃)₃C⁺ (tert-butyl carbocation), there are 3 alpha-carbons, each with 3 hydrogens, totaling 9 alpha-hydrogens. For (CH₃)₂CH⁺ (isopropyl carbocation), there are 2 alpha-carbons, each with 3 hydrogens, totaling 6 alpha-hydrogens.
   
   
   
   


2. 
   Incorrect Priority of Stabilizing Effects:
   
   
   
   • The Trap: When multiple stabilizing/destabilizing effects (resonance, hyperconjugation, inductive) are present, students often misjudge their relative importance.
   
   
   • Why it's Tricky: It's easy to get fixated on one effect and ignore a more dominant one.
   
   
   • Exam Tip (JEE Main & CBSE): The general order of stability contribution is:
     
     Resonance > Hyperconjugation > Inductive Effect
     
     Always check for resonance first. If resonance is present, it almost always dominates over hyperconjugation and inductive effects. Only when resonance is absent, compare hyperconjugation, and then inductive effects.
   
   
   • Example: An allyl carbocation (CH₂=CH-CH₂⁺) is more stable than a tertiary alkyl carbocation, even though the tertiary carbocation might have more alpha-hydrogens. This is because the allyl carbocation is stabilized by resonance, which is a stronger effect.
   
   
   
   


3. 
   Errors in Resonance Structure Drawing and Identification:
   
   
   
   • The Trap: Failing to draw all valid contributing resonance structures or drawing invalid ones (e.g., exceeding octet for second-row elements, breaking single bonds). Also, sometimes students miss recognizing potential resonance in a given structure.
   
   
   • Why it's Tricky: Resonance requires careful electron movement and adherence to valence rules.
   
   
   • Exam Tip (JEE Main & CBSE): Practice drawing resonance structures extensively. Remember the rules:
     
     
     
     • Only pi electrons and lone pairs move.
     
     
     • Atoms must maintain their valence (e.g., carbon cannot have 5 bonds).
     
     
     • Resonance structures are not real, but their hybrid is.
     
     
     
     Look for allylic (C=C-C⁺/C^-/C•) and benzylic systems, or systems with adjacent lone pairs/double bonds to a charge.
   
   
   
   


4. 
   Misapplication of Electronegativity and Hybridization:
   
   
   
   • The Trap: Incorrectly correlating electronegativity and hybridization (s-character) with stability, especially when comparing carbocations and carbanions.
   
   
   • Why it's Tricky: The effect of electronegativity is opposite for positive and negative charges.
   
   
   • Exam Tip (JEE Main & CBSE):
     
     
     
     • Carbanions: More stable when the negative charge is on a more electronegative atom, or an atom with higher s-character (e.g., sp > sp² > sp³ carbon). This is because higher s-character means electrons are held closer to the nucleus, stabilizing the negative charge.
     
     
     • Carbocations: More stable when the positive charge is on a less electronegative atom, or an atom with lower s-character (e.g., sp³ > sp² > sp carbon). A positive charge on an electronegative atom (or one with high s-character) is highly destabilized.
     
     
     
     
   
   
   
   


5. 
   Overlooking Aromatic/Anti-aromatic Stability in Cyclic Systems (JEE Advanced Focus):
   
   
   
   • The Trap: For cyclic carbocations, carbanions, or free radicals, students sometimes ignore the profound impact of aromaticity or anti-aromaticity on stability.
   
   
   • Why it's Tricky: This adds another layer of complexity that can override all other effects.
   
   
   • Exam Tip (JEE Advanced): Always check if a cyclic intermediate meets Hückel's rules for aromaticity (planar, cyclic, fully conjugated, 4n+2 pi electrons) or anti-aromaticity (planar, cyclic, fully conjugated, 4n pi electrons). Aromatic systems are exceptionally stable; anti-aromatic systems are exceptionally unstable. This effect usually trumps inductive and hyperconjugation effects.
   
   
   
   

Stay sharp and practice systematically. Identifying these traps will help you avoid making common mistakes and maximize your scores!

Understanding the stability of reactive intermediates like carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals is fundamental to predicting reaction mechanisms and products in organic chemistry. This is a high-yield area for both JEE Main and CBSE board exams.

Key Takeaways on Stability of Reactive Intermediates

The stability of these species is primarily governed by the ability to disperse charge (for ions) or odd electron density (for radicals) through various electronic effects.

1. Carbocation Stability (Positive Charge)

• Definition: Carbon atom with a positive charge and three bonds, having only six valence electrons.


• Stabilizing Effects:
  
  
  
  • Hyperconjugation: Greater the number of alpha-hydrogens, greater the hyperconjugative stabilization. This is the primary reason for the stability order of alkyl carbocations.
  
  
  • Inductive Effect (+I): Electron-donating groups (like alkyl groups) disperse the positive charge, stabilizing the carbocation.
  
  
  • Resonance: Delocalization of the positive charge over multiple atoms through pi-bonds or lone pairs significantly stabilizes carbocations (e.g., allylic, benzylic, carbocations adjacent to -OR, -NR₂ groups).
  
  
  
  


• Order of Stability (Alkyl): 3° Carbocation > 2° Carbocation > 1° Carbocation > Methyl Carbocation


• Special Cases:
  
  
  
  • Allylic and Benzylic carbocations are highly stabilized by resonance.
  
  
  • Carbocations adjacent to lone pair bearing atoms (e.g., -O-, -N-) are exceptionally stable due to resonance involving lone pairs.
  
  
  
  

2. Carbanion Stability (Negative Charge)

• Definition: Carbon atom with a negative charge, three bonds, and an unshared pair of electrons (eight valence electrons).


• Stabilizing Effects:
  
  
  
  • Inductive Effect (-I): Electron-withdrawing groups (like -NO₂, -CN, halogens) disperse the negative charge, stabilizing the carbanion.
  
  
  • Resonance: Delocalization of the negative charge over multiple atoms (e.g., in enolates, allylic, benzylic carbanions) significantly stabilizes them.
  
  
  • Electronegativity/Hybridization: A negative charge is more stable on a more electronegative atom or in an orbital with higher 's' character (e.g., sp > sp² > sp³ hybridized carbon).
  
  
  
  


• Destabilizing Effects: Electron-donating groups (+I effect) intensify the negative charge, destabilizing the carbanion.


• Order of Stability (Alkyl): Methyl Carbanion > 1° Carbanion > 2° Carbanion > 3° Carbanion (Opposite to carbocations)

3. Free Radical Stability (Unpaired Electron)

• Definition: Species with an unpaired electron, usually on a carbon atom.


• Stabilizing Effects:
  
  
  
  • Hyperconjugation: Similar to carbocations, hyperconjugation with alpha-hydrogens stabilizes free radicals. More alpha-hydrogens lead to greater stability.
  
  
  • Resonance: Delocalization of the unpaired electron through pi-bonds (e.g., allylic, benzylic free radicals) significantly stabilizes them.
  
  
  
  


• Order of Stability (Alkyl): 3° Free Radical > 2° Free Radical > 1° Free Radical > Methyl Free Radical (Similar to carbocations)

JEE/CBSE Tip: Always look for resonance and hyperconjugation as the primary stabilizing factors. When comparing structures, count the number of contributing resonance structures or alpha-hydrogens to determine relative stability. Understanding these stability orders is crucial for predicting the feasibility and regioselectivity of many organic reactions.

Understanding the stability of carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals is fundamental to predicting reaction pathways and major products in organic chemistry. This section outlines a systematic approach to tackle stability-related problems, a frequently tested concept in JEE Main and other competitive exams.

General Problem-Solving Approach

When asked to compare the stability of different reactive intermediates, follow these steps:

1. Identify the Intermediate Type: Determine if it's a carbocation (positive charge), carbanion (negative charge), or a free radical (unpaired electron).


2. Locate the Reactive Site: Pinpoint the carbon atom carrying the charge or the unpaired electron.


3. Analyze Stabilizing/Destabilizing Effects: Systematically look for factors that can stabilize or destabilize the specific intermediate.


4. Apply Hierarchy of Effects: Prioritize the stabilizing/destabilizing factors.


5. Compare and Rank: Based on the combined analysis, compare the intermediates and rank them in order of stability.

Specific Approaches for Each Intermediate

1. Carbocations (Electron-Deficient Species)

Carbocations are stabilized by factors that donate electron density to the positively charged carbon.

• Resonance Effect (+R): If the positive charge can be delocalized over multiple atoms through conjugation (e.g., adjacent double bonds, lone pairs on heteroatoms), it significantly stabilizes the carbocation. This is the most dominant effect.


• Hyperconjugation (no-bond resonance): Look for alpha-hydrogens (hydrogens on carbons adjacent to the positively charged carbon). More alpha-hydrogens lead to greater hyperconjugative stabilization.
  
  
  
  • Primary (1°) < Secondary (2°) < Tertiary (3°) for simple alkyl carbocations due to increasing alpha-hydrogens.
  
  
  
  


• Inductive Effect (+I): Electron-donating alkyl groups attached to the carbocation carbon will stabilize it. The more alkyl groups, the stronger the +I effect. (Less significant than resonance or hyperconjugation).


• Electronegativity: A carbocation on a more electronegative atom is less stable.

Order of Stability: Resonance > Hyperconjugation > Inductive Effect.

2. Carbanions (Electron-Rich Species)

Carbanions are stabilized by factors that withdraw electron density from the negatively charged carbon or delocalize the negative charge.

• Resonance Effect (-R): If the negative charge can be delocalized into an adjacent pi system (e.g., carbonyl group, nitro group), it significantly stabilizes the carbanion. This is the most dominant effect.


• Inductive Effect (-I): Electron-withdrawing groups (e.g., halogens, -NO2, -CN) attached to the carbanion carbon will stabilize it. The closer and stronger the EWG, the greater the stabilization.


• Hybridization: Increased s-character in the orbital holding the negative charge makes the carbanion more stable, as s-orbitals are closer to the nucleus and can better accommodate negative charge.
  
  
  
  • sp (alkynyl) > sp2 (alkenyl) > sp3 (alkyl)
  
  
  
  


• Electronegativity: A carbanion on a more electronegative atom is more stable.

Order of Stability: Resonance > Hybridization > Inductive Effect. (Note: Hybridization is particularly strong for carbanions on different carbon types).

3. Free Radicals (Species with Unpaired Electron)

Free radicals are stabilized by factors that delocalize the unpaired electron density.

• Resonance Effect: If the unpaired electron can be delocalized over multiple atoms through conjugation (e.g., adjacent double bonds, aromatic rings), it significantly stabilizes the free radical. This is the most dominant effect.


• Hyperconjugation: Similar to carbocations, more alpha-hydrogens lead to greater hyperconjugative stabilization.
  
  
  
  • Primary (1°) < Secondary (2°) < Tertiary (3°) for simple alkyl free radicals.
  
  
  
  


• Inductive Effect (+I): Alkyl groups attached to the free radical carbon offer slight stabilization via +I effect (less significant).

Order of Stability: Resonance > Hyperconjugation > Inductive Effect.

Example: Ranking Carbocation Stability

Rank the following carbocations in order of increasing stability:

1. CH₃⁺


2. (CH₃)₂CH⁺


3. CH₃CH₂⁺


4. (CH₃)₃C⁺

Solution Approach:

• All are simple alkyl carbocations; therefore, resonance is not a factor.


• Focus on hyperconjugation (number of alpha-hydrogens).


• 
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  

  Carbocation	Type	Alpha-Hydrogens	Stabilizing Effect
  CH3+	Methyl	0	No hyperconjugation, only very weak +I from H (negligible)
  CH3CH2+	Primary (1°)	3	Hyperconjugation from 3 alpha-H, +I from one alkyl group
  (CH3)2CH+	Secondary (2°)	6	Hyperconjugation from 6 alpha-H, +I from two alkyl groups
  (CH3)3C+	Tertiary (3°)	9	Hyperconjugation from 9 alpha-H, +I from three alkyl groups

  
  

Conclusion: Increasing number of alpha-hydrogens leads to greater stability.

Order of stability: CH₃⁺ < CH₃CH₂⁺ < (CH₃)₂CH⁺ < (CH₃)₃C⁺

JEE Tip: Always prioritize resonance over hyperconjugation, and hyperconjugation over inductive effects when comparing the stability of these intermediates. This hierarchy is crucial for accurate ranking.

Welcome to the CBSE Focus Areas for Reactive Intermediates! This section highlights the core concepts and applications of carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals that are most frequently tested in the CBSE Class 11 and 12 examinations.

Understanding Reactive Intermediates for CBSE Exams

Reactive intermediates like carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals are crucial to understanding reaction mechanisms in organic chemistry. For CBSE, the emphasis is on their definitions, formation, and, most importantly, their relative stability based on various electronic effects.

• Definition & Formation: Be prepared to define each intermediate and explain how they are formed (heterolytic vs. homolytic cleavage).


• Hybridization & Geometry: Basic understanding of their hybridization (e.g., sp² for carbocation, sp³ for carbanion) and geometry (e.g., trigonal planar for carbocation).


• Stability: This is the most critical aspect for CBSE. You must understand the factors influencing stability for each intermediate and be able to compare their relative stabilities.

1. Carbocations (Carbonium Ions)

• Definition: Species containing a carbon atom bearing a positive charge and six electrons in its valence shell. It is electron-deficient.


• Formation: Formed by heterolytic fission, typically when a leaving group departs with the bonding pair of electrons.


• Hybridization & Geometry: The positively charged carbon is sp² hybridized and has a trigonal planar geometry.


• CBSE Focus on Stability:
  
  
  
  • Stability of carbocations increases with the number of alkyl groups attached to the positively charged carbon. Alkyl groups are electron-donating (+I effect).
  
  
  • Hyperconjugation: Adjacent C-H bonds stabilize the carbocation by donating electron density into the empty p-orbital. More α-hydrogens mean more hyperconjugative structures and greater stability.
  
  
  • Resonance: Carbocations like allylic (CH₂=CH-CH₂⁺) and benzylic (C₆H₅-CH₂⁺) are significantly stabilized by resonance. You must be able to draw their resonance structures.
  
  
  
  


• Stability Order (General):
  

  Allyl/Benzyl > 3° (Tertiary) > 2° (Secondary) > 1° (Primary) > Methyl

  
  

2. Carbanions

• Definition: Species containing a carbon atom bearing a negative charge and an unshared pair of electrons (eight electrons in its valence shell). It is electron-rich.


• Formation: Formed by heterolytic fission when the carbon atom retains the bonding pair of electrons.


• Hybridization & Geometry: The negatively charged carbon is generally sp³ hybridized and has a pyramidal geometry, similar to ammonia. Resonance stabilized carbanions can be sp².


• CBSE Focus on Stability:
  
  
  
  • Stability of carbanions is inversely proportional to the number of alkyl groups attached. Alkyl groups are electron-donating (+I effect), which destabilizes the already electron-rich carbanion.
  
  
  • Electron-Withdrawing Groups (-I, -R): Carbanions are stabilized by adjacent electron-withdrawing groups (e.g., -NO₂, -C≡N, -COOH, halogens) which disperse the negative charge.
  
  
  • Resonance: Carbanions like allylic and benzylic are stabilized by resonance, spreading the negative charge over multiple atoms. Drawing resonance structures is important here too.
  
  
  
  


• Stability Order (General, based on alkyl substitution):
  

  Methyl > 1° (Primary) > 2° (Secondary) > 3° (Tertiary)

  
  

  However, carbanions stabilized by resonance (Allyl, Benzyl) or strong EWGs are significantly more stable.

  
  

3. Free Radicals

• Definition: Species containing a carbon atom with an unpaired electron. They are highly reactive.


• Formation: Formed by homolytic fission of a covalent bond, where each atom takes one electron from the shared pair.


• Hybridization & Geometry: The carbon with the unpaired electron is often sp² hybridized and trigonal planar, though some can be sp³.


• CBSE Focus on Stability:
  
  
  
  • Free radicals are stabilized by the same factors as carbocations: electron-donating groups (+I effect), hyperconjugation, and resonance.
  
  
  • More alkyl groups mean more hyperconjugative structures and greater stability.
  
  
  • Resonance in allylic and benzylic free radicals disperses the unpaired electron, leading to significant stabilization.
  
  
  
  


• Stability Order (General):
  

  Allyl/Benzyl > 3° (Tertiary) > 2° (Secondary) > 1° (Primary) > Methyl

  
  

CBSE Exam Perspective & Practice Tips:

• Conceptual Understanding: Focus on 'why' certain intermediates are more stable than others, linking it to electronic effects like Inductive effect, Hyperconjugation, and Resonance.


• Drawing Resonance Structures: This is a frequently tested skill, especially for allylic and benzylic species. Practice drawing correct curved arrows for electron movement.


• Comparative Stability Questions: Expect questions asking you to arrange given sets of carbocations/carbanions/free radicals in increasing or decreasing order of stability, with proper justification.


• Distinguishing Factors: Understand that electron-donating groups stabilize carbocations and free radicals, but destabilize carbanions. Conversely, electron-withdrawing groups stabilize carbanions.

Mastering these concepts will provide a strong foundation for understanding reaction mechanisms, a key part of organic chemistry in your CBSE exams!

Understanding the stability of carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals is fundamental for mastering organic reaction mechanisms in JEE Main. This section highlights the key factors and common question patterns you can expect.

JEE Focus: Stability of Reaction Intermediates

The stability of carbocations, carbanions, and free radicals dictates the feasibility and outcome of numerous organic reactions. JEE questions frequently test your ability to compare the relative stability of different intermediates.

1. Carbocation Stability (C⁺)

Carbocations are electron-deficient species (sp² hybridized, vacant p-orbital). Their stability is enhanced by factors that disperse the positive charge.

• Electron-Donating Groups (+I Effect): Alkyl groups stabilize carbocations through the inductive effect (+I) by donating electron density to the positively charged carbon.
  
  
  
  • Order: 3° > 2° > 1° > Methyl
  
  
  
  


• Hyperconjugation (no-bond resonance): This is a significant stabilizing factor for carbocations. The more α-hydrogens (hydrogens on carbons adjacent to the positively charged carbon), the greater the hyperconjugation and stability.
  
  
  
  • Example: (CH₃)₃C⁺ (9 α-H) > (CH₃)₂CH⁺ (6 α-H) > CH₃CH₂⁺ (3 α-H).
  
  
  
  


• Resonance Stabilization: Delocalization of the positive charge through resonance significantly increases stability.
  
  
  
  • Highly stable: Allylic, Benzylic, Tropylium carbocations.
  
  
  • Comparisons: Benzyl carbocation is more stable than 3° alkyl carbocation due to extensive resonance.
  
  
  
  


• Rearrangements: Carbocations often undergo rearrangements (hydride or alkyl shifts) to form more stable carbocations, especially in S_N1 and E1 reactions. JEE frequently asks questions involving rearrangement.

2. Carbanion Stability (C^-)

Carbanions are electron-rich species with a lone pair of electrons (sp³ hybridized for simple alkyl carbanions). Their stability is enhanced by factors that disperse the negative charge.

• Electron-Withdrawing Groups (-I Effect): Electron-withdrawing groups (like -NO₂, -CN, halogens) stabilize carbanions by dispersing the negative charge through the inductive effect. Alkyl groups destabilize carbanions due to their +I effect.
  
  
  
  • Order: Methyl > 1° > 2° > 3° (opposite of carbocations).
  
  
  
  


• Resonance Stabilization: Delocalization of the negative charge through resonance significantly stabilizes carbanions.
  
  
  
  • Highly stable: Allylic, Benzylic, and carbanions adjacent to carbonyl groups (enolates).
  
  
  • Example: Carbanion of acetonitrile (CH₂^-CN) is more stable than simple alkyl carbanions due to the -I and resonance effect of -CN.
  
  
  
  


• Hybridization: Increased s-character of the carbon bearing the negative charge makes the carbanion more stable, as electrons are held closer to the nucleus.
  
  
  
  • Order: sp (alkynyl) > sp² (alkenyl) > sp³ (alkyl).
  
  
  
  

3. Free Radical Stability (C^•)

Free radicals are species with an unpaired electron (typically sp² hybridized with the unpaired electron in a p-orbital). Their stability is enhanced by factors that delocalize or accommodate the unpaired electron.

• Hyperconjugation (α-H): Similar to carbocations, hyperconjugation is a key stabilizing factor. More α-hydrogens lead to greater stability.
  
  
  
  • Order: 3° > 2° > 1° > Methyl. (Same order as carbocations).
  
  
  
  


• Resonance Stabilization: Delocalization of the unpaired electron through resonance significantly increases stability.
  
  
  
  • Highly stable: Allylic, Benzylic free radicals.
  
  
  
  


• Factors affecting: Both +I effect and hyperconjugation contribute to the stability. Electron-donating groups generally stabilize free radicals.

JEE Main Special Points:

• Relative Stability: Be prepared to compare stability when multiple factors (e.g., resonance vs. hyperconjugation vs. inductive effect) are at play. Resonance generally dominates over hyperconjugation and inductive effects.


• Reaction Mechanisms: Stability concepts are directly applied to predict the favored pathways in reactions like S_N1, E1, Electrophilic Addition, and Free Radical Substitution/Addition.


• Rearrangements: For carbocations, always consider the possibility of rearrangement to a more stable intermediate before forming the final product. This is a common trick in JEE problems.

Focus on understanding the underlying principles for each intermediate's stability rather than just memorizing orders. Practice a variety of problems involving different structural features to solidify your understanding.