| Understanding Reflection | |
|---|---|
Example: Laser Pointer on a Mirror | Take a small plane mirror and a laser pointer. Shine the laser beam onto the mirror. You'll notice the reflected beam. If you measure the angle between the incoming laser beam and the normal (an imaginary line perpendicular to the mirror's surface where the laser hits), and then measure the angle between the reflected beam and the normal, you'll find they are equal. This demonstrates the first law of reflection perfectly! |
| Understanding Refraction | |
|---|---|
Example: Coin in a Glass of Water | Place a coin at the bottom of an opaque cup. Move back until you can no longer see the coin. Now, without moving your head, slowly pour water into the cup. Magically, the coin becomes visible again! Why? Light rays from the coin travel from water (denser) to air (rarer). As they exit the water, they bend *away* from the normal. When these bent rays reach your eyes, your brain traces them back in straight lines, making the coin appear to be at a shallower, 'apparent' depth than its actual 'real' depth. This is a classic example of refraction. |
Welcome, future physicists, to a deep dive into the fascinating world of Ray Optics! Today, we're going to unravel the mysteries of how light interacts with different surfaces β specifically, through the phenomena of reflection and refraction. This forms the bedrock of understanding how lenses, mirrors, and even our own eyes work. So, grab your virtual pen and paper, and let's illuminate this topic!
In Ray Optics (or Geometrical Optics), we treat light as traveling in straight lines called "rays." This approximation is valid when the wavelength of light is much smaller than the dimensions of the objects it interacts with. When light encounters a surface separating two media, it can either bounce back (reflection) or pass through, bending its path (refraction).
Reflection is the phenomenon where light, incident on a surface, returns into the same medium. A plane mirror is the simplest reflecting surface.
When you look into a plane mirror, you see an image. Let's understand its characteristics:
When a light ray strikes a plane mirror, its direction changes. The total deviation (angle through which the ray turns) is given by δ = 180° - 2i, where 'i' is the angle of incidence. If the mirror rotates by an angle θ, the reflected ray rotates by 2θ in the same direction, while the incident ray remains fixed.
JEE Focus: Questions on the number of images formed by two inclined mirrors ($N = frac{360^circ}{ heta} - 1$ if $frac{360^circ}{ heta}$ is even or integer; $N = frac{360^circ}{ heta}$ if $frac{360^circ}{ heta}$ is odd and object is asymmetric or not on bisector; $N = frac{360^circ}{ heta} - 1$ if $frac{360^circ}{ heta}$ is odd and object is on bisector) and the velocity of the image (relative to mirror/observer) are common.
Spherical mirrors are sections of a hollow sphere whose one side is polished. They can be concave (reflecting surface is curved inwards) or convex (reflecting surface is curved outwards).
This is crucial for accurate calculations:
| Parameter | Concave Mirror | Convex Mirror |
|---|---|---|
| Focal Length (f) | Negative (-) | Positive (+) |
| Radius of Curvature (R) | Negative (-) | Positive (+) |
The relationship between object distance (u), image distance (v), and focal length (f) for spherical mirrors is given by:
1/v + 1/u = 1/f
This formula is valid for both concave and convex mirrors, provided distances are used with the New Cartesian Sign Convention.
Consider an object AB placed beyond C for a concave mirror, forming a real, inverted image A'B'.
Let's use similar triangles:
This derivation confirms the mirror formula.
Linear magnification (m) describes how much larger or smaller the image is compared to the object:
m = Height of image (h') / Height of object (h) = -v/u
JEE Focus: Derivations for various positions of the object, understanding the nature of images (real/virtual, erect/inverted, magnified/diminished) for both concave and convex mirrors, and solving numerical problems using the mirror formula and magnification formula with correct sign conventions are essential. Questions involving object/image velocity components (axial and transverse) are also common.
Refraction is the phenomenon of bending of light as it passes from one transparent medium to another.
n1 sin i = n2 sin r
It's a dimensionless quantity that describes how fast light travels through a medium.
Light bends towards the normal when going from a rarer to a denser medium (n1 < n2, so i > r).
Light bends away from the normal when going from a denser to a rarer medium (n1 > n2, so i < r).
When an object is placed in a denser medium and viewed from a rarer medium (e.g., a coin at the bottom of a pool), it appears shallower than it actually is.
Apparent Depth (h') = Real Depth (h) / nrelative
Here, nrelative is the refractive index of the denser medium with respect to the rarer medium (ndenser/nrarer).
The Normal Shift = h - h' = h (1 - 1/nrelative).
When light travels from a denser medium to a rarer medium, if the angle of incidence in the denser medium exceeds a certain angle called the critical angle (C), the light is entirely reflected back into the denser medium. This phenomenon is called Total Internal Reflection.
Conditions for TIR:
The critical angle is given by sin C = nrarer / ndenser.
Applications of TIR: Optical fibers, sparkling of diamonds, mirages, totally reflecting prisms.
JEE Focus: Apparent depth for multiple layers, specific applications of TIR (e.g., light propagating through optical fiber, periscope design), and problems involving finding the critical angle or range of incidence angles for TIR.
This is a crucial concept as it forms the basis for understanding lenses.
Consider a spherical surface separating two media with refractive indices n1 (where the object is) and n2. Let R be the radius of curvature of the spherical surface.
The relationship between object distance (u), image distance (v), radius of curvature (R), and refractive indices (n1, n2) is given by:
n2/v - n1/u = (n2 - n1)/R
Let an object O be in medium n1 and an image I be formed in medium n2. The ray from O travels to point A on the surface, making an angle of incidence α with the principal axis, β with the normal passing through C, and γ with the image principal axis.
From Snell's Law: n1 sin i = n2 sin r. For small angles (paraxial rays), sin i ≈ i and sin r ≈ r.
So, n1 i = n2 r (1)
In ΔOAC, the exterior angle i = α + β (2)
In ΔIAC, the exterior angle β = r + γ &implies; r = β - γ (3)
Substitute (2) and (3) into (1):
n1 (α + β) = n2 (β - γ)
n1 α + n1 β = n2 β - n2 γ
n1 α + n2 γ = (n2 - n1) β
For small angles, α ≈ tan α = AM/MO, β ≈ tan β = AM/MC, γ ≈ tan γ = AM/MI. (where M is point of intersection of ray with axis, and A is point on spherical surface, assuming M approx P for paraxial rays).
n1 (AM/MO) + n2 (AM/MI) = (n2 - n1) (AM/MC)
Divide by AM:
n1/MO + n2/MI = (n2 - n1)/MC
Using New Cartesian Sign Convention:
MO = -u (object distance)
MI = +v (image distance)
MC = +R (radius of curvature)
Substituting these values:
n1/(-u) + n2/v = (n2 - n1)/R
Rearranging, we get:
n2/v - n1/u = (n2 - n1)/R
This formula is universally applicable for all spherical refracting surfaces (concave/convex, real/virtual images, object in denser/rarer medium), provided you strictly follow the New Cartesian Sign Convention.
JEE Focus: This formula is fundamental for lenses and optical instruments. Problems often involve finding the image formed by a single spherical surface, or a combination of surfaces (like a glass sphere with an air bubble inside). Correct application of the sign convention and understanding the sequence of refraction events are key.
The transverse magnification for a single spherical refracting surface is given by:
m = h'/h = (n1v) / (n2u)
This comprehensive understanding of reflection and refraction at plane and spherical surfaces is absolutely vital. Master these concepts, and you'll build a strong foundation for tackling more complex topics like lenses, prisms, and optical instruments in Ray Optics!
Mastering reflection and refraction requires not just understanding the concepts but also quickly recalling formulas and applying sign conventions accurately. Here are some effective mnemonics and shortcuts to help you ace this topic in your JEE and CBSE exams.
One of the most common confusions is remembering the sign between 1/v and 1/u.
Accurate sign convention is crucial for correct answers.
The sign of magnification tells you about the nature and orientation of the image.
This formula relates focal length to refractive index and radii of curvature.
By consistently applying these mnemonics and shortcuts, you can reduce errors and save valuable time during exams. Practice them regularly to solidify your recall!
Mastering reflection and refraction is fundamental for Ray Optics. These quick tips will help you tackle problems efficiently and avoid common pitfalls in both JEE Main and board exams.
Keep practicing problems with consistent sign conventions, and you'll master these topics for JEE and board exams!
Welcome to the intuitive understanding of reflection and refraction! This section aims to build a strong conceptual foundation, helping you grasp *why* light behaves the way it does, rather than just memorizing formulas. A clear intuition will significantly aid you in applying formulas correctly and solving complex problems in both JEE and board exams.
Imagine throwing a ball against a wall. It bounces back! Light behaves similarly when it encounters a surface. This bouncing back of light into the same medium is called reflection.
Now, imagine a car moving from a smooth road onto a muddy patch at an angle. The wheels entering the mud first slow down, causing the car to change its direction of motion. Light behaves similarly when it passes from one transparent medium to another (e.g., from air to water). This bending of light is called refraction.
Understanding these fundamental interactions of light with surfaces is crucial for comprehending more advanced topics in optics. Keep visualizing the light rays and their paths!
The principles of reflection and refraction, occurring at both plane and spherical surfaces, are fundamental to numerous technologies and natural phenomena we encounter daily. Understanding these applications not only deepens conceptual understanding but also helps in connecting physics to the real world, often forming the basis for conceptual questions in exams like JEE Main and CBSE boards.
Reflection from various surfaces plays a crucial role in imaging, illumination, and safety.
Refraction, the bending of light as it passes from one medium to another, is at the heart of vision correction, optical instruments, and various natural phenomena.
These applications highlight the immense practical utility of the fundamental principles of reflection and refraction, forming the backbone of modern optics and technology.
Analogies are powerful tools to simplify complex physics concepts, making them more intuitive and easier to grasp. While they are not substitutes for rigorous mathematical understanding, they provide a conceptual framework that aids in problem-solving and deeper comprehension. For JEE and CBSE, these analogies help build intuition, especially for qualitative questions.
Exam Tip: While analogies aid understanding, always ensure you can back up your conceptual understanding with the precise laws of reflection (angle of incidence = angle of reflection) and refraction (Snell's Law: nβsinΞΈβ = nβsinΞΈβ). For JEE, quantitative application is key; for CBSE, clear conceptual explanations using diagrams are essential.
To effectively grasp the concepts of Reflection and Refraction at plane and spherical surfaces, a strong foundation in certain fundamental mathematical and physics principles is essential. These prerequisites will enable you to understand derivations, draw accurate ray diagrams, and solve numerical problems with confidence.
Mastering these foundational concepts will not only make the study of reflection and refraction smoother but also build a strong analytical base for more advanced topics in optics.
Navigating the topic of reflection and refraction requires precision. Many students fall into predictable traps that can cost valuable marks. Being aware of these common pitfalls is the first step towards avoiding them.
1/f = (nlens/nmedium - 1)(1/R1 - 1/R2).d' = d / (nrelative) where nrelative is ndenser/nrarer if seen from rarer to denser.Shift = t(1 - 1/nrelative), where 't' is the thickness of the medium and nrelative is the refractive index of the slab material with respect to the medium in which it is placed. Always clarify the perspective of the observer.Stay Sharp! A thorough understanding of these traps, combined with diligent practice, will significantly improve your accuracy in optics problems.
Mastering reflection and refraction is fundamental for success in Optics. These key takeaways summarize the essential concepts and formulas you must remember for JEE and board exams. Pay close attention to sign conventions, as they are a frequent source of errors.
Keep practicing problems with careful application of sign conventions to solidify your understanding!
Solving problems in Ray Optics, particularly those involving reflection and refraction at plane and spherical surfaces, requires a systematic and disciplined approach. Mastering sign conventions and formula applications is key to success in both board exams and competitive exams like JEE Main.
This is arguably the most critical step. Inconsistency leads to incorrect results.
Stay focused, practice regularly, and build confidence in your approach!
For students preparing for the CBSE Board Examinations, the topic "Reflection and refraction at plane and spherical surfaces" is exceptionally important. It frequently appears in both conceptual questions and numerical problems, often involving derivations. A strong understanding of sign conventions and ray diagrams is crucial.
Motivational Note: Mastering these core concepts and derivations will ensure you score well in this significant unit. Consistent practice, especially with ray diagrams and numericals using correct sign conventions, is your key to success!
This section on Reflection and Refraction at plane and spherical surfaces is a fundamental and high-scoring topic in JEE Main. Mastery of sign conventions, formulas, and conceptual variations is crucial.
(v_image)normal = 2(v_mirror)normal - (v_object)normal. Tangential components are unaffected by mirror motion.nβsinΞΈβ = nβsinΞΈβ and Apparent Depth = Real Depth / Refractive Index (n_relative).Shift = t(1 - 1/n).1/f = 1/v + 1/u and m = -v/u = h_i/h_o. Remember f = R/2.dv/dt.f is constant for a given mirror.(nβ/v) - (nβ/u) = (nβ - nβ)/R.1/f = (n_lens/n_medium - 1)(1/Rβ - 1/Rβ).n_medium = 1. If placed in water, n_medium = 4/3, and focal length changes.1/f = 1/v - 1/u and m = v/u = h_i/h_o.P_eq = Pβ + Pβ and 1/F_eq = 1/fβ + 1/fβ. If separated by distance 'd', P_eq = Pβ + Pβ - dPβPβ.
Remember: Practice numerical problems extensively, paying close attention to sign conventions. Many JEE problems involve combinations of mirrors and lenses, requiring sequential application of formulas.
No videos available yet.
No images available yet.
n2/v - n1/u = (n2-n1)/R without realizing that n1 is specifically the refractive index of the medium from which light rays are incident, and n2 is the medium into which they are refracted. Ignoring the context of the surrounding media for each interface is a common pitfall. A lens (n=1.5) is immersed in water (n=4/3). An object is placed in air. Incorrect approach: When calculating for the first lens surface, using n1=4/3 (water) instead of n1=1 (air), as the rays from the object originate in air.
Consider an object in air, viewed through a glass slab (n=1.5) that is floating on water (n=4/3).
Each interface requires specific n1 and n2 values based on the actual media involved at that particular step.
n1 (incident medium) and n2 (refracted/reflected medium) for each optical interface.A student solving a problem for a concave mirror might incorrectly take its focal length (f) as positive, or for a convex lens, might take 'f' as negative. Similarly, for a real object placed to the left, they might take object distance (u) as positive.
Consider a concave mirror with light incident from the left. According to the Cartesian sign convention:
JEE Tip: For spherical mirrors, f = R/2. So if R is negative, f must also be negative.
A common error students make is failing to maintain unit consistency throughout their calculations in reflection and refraction problems. They might use some quantities in centimeters (cm) and others in meters (m) within the same formula without proper conversion, leading to incorrect numerical answers. This is particularly prevalent with focal length, object distance, image distance, and radii of curvature.
Before attempting to solve any problem, always convert all given quantities to a single, consistent unit system. For optics problems in JEE Main, it's often convenient to convert everything to centimeters (cm) or meters (m), based on the units of the options provided or the convenience of calculation. If a focal length is given in cm and object distance in m, convert one to match the other before applying any formula.
Problem: A convex mirror has a focal length (f) = 15 cm. An object is placed at a distance (u) = 0.3 m from the mirror.
Incorrect approach: Directly substituting f = 15 and u = 0.3 into the mirror formula (1/f = 1/v + 1/u) without unit conversion. This would lead to 1/15 = 1/v + 1/(-0.3), which is dimensionally inconsistent and will yield a wrong value for 'v'.
Problem: A convex mirror has a focal length (f) = 15 cm. An object is placed at a distance (u) = 0.3 m from the mirror.
Correct approach:
The image is formed at +10 cm, which is behind the mirror, consistent with a convex mirror.
Based on this:
Problem: A concave mirror has a radius of curvature of 30 cm. Find the image position if an object is placed 20 cm in front of it.
Incorrect Application: Student takes R = +30 cm, so f = +15 cm. Applying mirror formula: 1/v + 1/u = 1/f → 1/v + 1/(-20) = 1/(+15). This would lead to a virtual image at -60 cm.
Correct Application: For a concave mirror, R = -30 cm. Therefore, focal length f = R/2 = -15 cm.
Object distance u = -20 cm (real object, opposite to incident light).
Using the mirror formula: $frac{1}{v} + frac{1}{u} = frac{1}{f}$
$frac{1}{v} + frac{1}{-20} = frac{1}{-15}$
$frac{1}{v} = frac{1}{-15} + frac{1}{20} = frac{-4 + 3}{60} = frac{-1}{60}$
So, v = -60 cm. This indicates a real, inverted image formed 60 cm in front of the mirror, which is the correct result (image formed beyond C).
Students sometimes apply small angle approximations (e.g., sin θ ≈ θ, tan θ ≈ θ) for angles that are not actually small, or when the problem demands exact trigonometric calculation. This leads to minor inaccuracies in results, especially when dealing with angles of incidence or refraction that are moderately large.
sin θ ≈ θ, tan θ ≈ θ, cos θ ≈ 1) only when explicitly stated in the problem (e.g., "for paraxial rays," "small aperture," "angle is small") or when the context clearly implies it (e.g., ray very close to the principal axis, or derivation of standard formulas).n1 sin i = n2 sin r).1/v + 1/u = 1/f) are derived using paraxial approximations. The mistake is more about *intermediate steps* in some problems or misinterpreting given angles.Problem: A ray of light is incident from air (n=1) to glass (n=1.5) at an angle of incidence 30Β°. Calculate the angle of refraction (r).
Student's Mistake: Incorrectly applies small angle approximation for 30Β°:
n1 i ≈ n2 r (assuming i and r are in radians and small)1 * (30 × π/180) ≈ 1.5 * rr ≈ (1 * 0.5236) / 1.5 ≈ 0.349 radians ≈ 20Β°(This is inaccurate because 30Β° is not a small angle for this approximation.)
Problem: A ray of light is incident from air (n=1) to glass (n=1.5) at an angle of incidence 30Β°. Calculate the angle of refraction (r).
Correct Approach: Use the exact Snell's Law:
n1 sin i = n2 sin r1 * sin 30Β° = 1.5 * sin r1 * 0.5 = 1.5 * sin rsin r = 0.5 / 1.5 = 1/3r = sin-1(1/3) ≈ 19.47Β°(This is the accurate result for the given angle.)
θ in sin θ ≈ θ must be in radians if you're directly replacing `sin ΞΈ` with `ΞΈ`. If given in degrees, convert first, or use the `sin` function directly.| Parameter | Concave Mirror / Convex Lens | Convex Mirror / Concave Lens | General u |
|---|---|---|---|
| Focal Length (f) | Negative | Positive | - |
| Real Object (u) | Negative | Negative | Negative (by convention, object usually on left) |
| Real Image (v) | Positive (for lenses) / Negative (for mirrors) | - | - |
A student uses the mirror formula to solve a problem involving a concave mirror with a focal length of 20 cm, incorrectly writing: f = +20 cm
For a concave mirror, the focus lies in front of the mirror, meaning the distance is measured opposite to the direction of incident light. Therefore, the correct sign for its focal length is: f = -20 cm
For standard Cartesian sign conventions (light travels left to right):
JEE Tip: Always default to the definitions of ray convergence/divergence first, and then apply sign conventions consistently.
For focal length (f) and radius of curvature (R), assuming light is incident from the left:
Problem: A convex lens has a focal length of +25 cm. Calculate its power.
Incorrect Solution:
P = 1/f = 1/25 = 0.04 D (Incorrect: Focal length not in metres)
Problem: A convex lens has a focal length of +25 cm. Calculate its power.
Correct Solution:
Given f = +25 cm.
Convert f to metres: f = 25 cm / 100 = 0.25 m.
P = 1/f = 1/0.25 D = +4 D (Correct)
1/f = 1/v + 1/u) or the lens formula (1/f = 1/v - 1/u) yield the reciprocal of the required distance. The crucial final step is to take the reciprocal of the calculated value to obtain the actual focal length, object distance, or image distance. Problem: A concave mirror has a focal length of -15 cm. An object is placed at -30 cm from the mirror. Find the image distance (v).
Mirror formula: 1/f = 1/v + 1/u
1/(-15) = 1/v + 1/(-30)
-1/15 = 1/v - 1/30
1/v = -1/15 + 1/30
1/v = -2/30 + 1/30
1/v = -1/30
Incorrect Answer: v = -1/30 cm (Student forgot to invert 1/v)
Problem: A concave mirror has a focal length of -15 cm. An object is placed at -30 cm from the mirror. Find the image distance (v).
Mirror formula: 1/f = 1/v + 1/u
1/(-15) = 1/v + 1/(-30)
-1/15 = 1/v - 1/30
1/v = -1/15 + 1/30
1/v = -2/30 + 1/30
1/v = -1/30
Correct Answer: v = -30 cm (Inverting the value of 1/v to get v)
v = 1/(calculated value of 1/v).-1/30 cm, the unit immediately indicates a mistake.Always adhere to the Cartesian sign convention consistently for all optical elements:
Consider a concave mirror with focal length 20 cm (magnitude). An object is placed 30 cm from the mirror.
Incorrect: A student might write 1/+20 = 1/v + 1/+30, taking 'f' as positive (misinterpreting concave) or 'u' as positive (thinking object distance is always positive), ignoring the direction of incident light and the nature of the mirror.
For the same scenario (concave mirror, focal length magnitude 20 cm, object at 30 cm):
1/(-20) = 1/v + 1/(-30)1/v = 1/(-20) - 1/(-30)1/v = -1/20 + 1/30 = (-3 + 2)/60 = -1/60v = -60 cm (A real image formed 60 cm in front of the mirror).1/f = 1/v + 1/u and magnification (m = -v/u = h'/h), ensure all distances (f, u, v, h, h') are in the same unit throughout the calculation.P = 1/f = 1/20 = 0.05 D.f = +20 cm = +0.20 m.P = 1/f (in meters) = 1/0.20 = +5 D.u = -15 cm and f = +20 cm, for 1/f = 1/v + 1/u, both u and f are consistently in cm. If u was given as -0.15 m, it should be converted to -15 cm before using with f = +20 cm.1 meter (m) = 100 centimeters (cm).1/f = 1/v + 1/u), lens formula (1/f = 1/v - 1/u), and magnification formulae. These errors typically arise from an inconsistent or incorrect application of the chosen sign convention, primarily the Cartesian sign convention. Such mistakes lead to incorrect magnitudes and, more critically, incorrect determination of the nature of images (real/virtual, inverted/erect), which can significantly impact the final answer in JEE Advanced problems. Key Applications:
f = +20 cm (as it's a 'magnitude') and u = +30 cm (assuming 'in front' means positive), leading to an incorrect image distance calculation.1/(+20) = 1/v + 1/(+30) => 1/v = 1/20 - 1/30 = 1/60 => v = +60 cm (Incorrect, as it implies a virtual image behind the mirror).1/f = 1/v + 1/u):1/(-20) = 1/v + 1/(-30)-1/20 = 1/v - 1/301/v = 1/30 - 1/20 = (2 - 3)/60 = -1/60v = -60 cmThe negative sign for 'v' correctly indicates a real image formed 60 cm in front of the mirror (on the same side as the object).
f = -20 cm, u = -30 cm).
Incorrect Calculation:
Given: f = +20 cm
u = -0.5 m (assuming converging lens and real object)
Substituting directly without unit conversion:
1/v - 1/(-0.5) = 1/20
1/v + 2 = 0.05
1/v = 0.05 - 2 = -1.95
v = -1/1.95 (Incorrect result as 1/v implies meters if 1/u is meters and 1/f implies cm if 1/f is cm, leading to an inconsistent equation).
Given: f = +20 cm = +0.20 m (for a converging lens)
u = -0.5 m
Using the lens formula: 1/v - 1/u = 1/f
1/v - 1/(-0.5) = 1/0.20
1/v + 2 = 5
1/v = 5 - 2 = 3
v = +1/3 m β +0.333 m
Given: f = +20 cm
u = -0.5 m = -50 cm
Using the lens formula: 1/v - 1/u = 1/f
1/v - 1/(-50) = 1/20
1/v + 1/50 = 1/20
1/v = 1/20 - 1/50
1/v = (5 - 2)/100 = 3/100
v = +100/3 cm β +33.33 cm
Always use the Cartesian Sign Convention for JEE Advanced problems. Assume incident light travels from left to right. The Pole (for mirrors) or Optical Centre (for lenses) is the origin (0,0).
Specific Signs for Focal Length (f):
A student uses a convex mirror (diverging) and takes its focal length as f = -20 cm. This is incorrect according to the Cartesian convention where f for a convex mirror is positive.
For a convex mirror with a focal length magnitude of 20 cm, the correct focal length in the Cartesian convention is f = +20 cm. If an object is placed 30 cm in front (left) of the mirror, the object distance u = -30 cm.
Question: A very wide beam of parallel light rays is incident on a concave spherical mirror. Where will all the reflected rays converge?
❌ Wrong Answer: All reflected rays will converge exactly at the mirror's principal focal point (F).
Question: A very wide beam of parallel light rays is incident on a concave spherical mirror. Where will all the reflected rays converge?
✅ Correct Answer: No, not all reflected rays will converge at a single point. Only the paraxial rays (those close to the principal axis) will converge approximately at the focal point (F). The marginal rays (those far from the principal axis) will converge at points closer to the mirror, leading to spherical aberration. The mirror formula (1/f = 1/v + 1/u) is based on the paraxial approximation.
Always adhere strictly to the Cartesian Sign Convention:
f as positive (+ve) in calculations, even though its real focus is in front of the mirror, implying a negative value.f of a concave mirror must always be taken as negative (-ve). Conversely, for a convex mirror, the focus is behind the mirror, so f is positive (+ve).f < 0, convex mirror f > 0, converging lens f > 0, diverging lens f < 0).Applying this, if incident light is from left:
| Parameter | Concave Mirror / Converging Lens | Convex Mirror / Diverging Lens |
|---|---|---|
| Focal Length (f) | Negative | Positive |
| Real Object (u) | Negative (always placed left) | Negative (always placed left) |
| Real Image (v) | Negative (formed left) | Negative (formed left) |
| Virtual Image (v) | Positive (formed right) | Positive (formed right) |
1/v + 1/30 = 1/201/v = 1/20 - 1/30 = (3-2)/60 = 1/60, so v = +60 cm. This suggests a virtual image formed 60 cm behind the mirror, which is incorrect for a concave mirror when the object is between C and F.u = -30 cm (object placed to the left, opposite to incident light).f = -20 cm (focus is to the left, opposite to incident light).1/v + 1/u = 1/f1/v + 1/(-30) = 1/(-20)1/v - 1/30 = -1/201/v = 1/30 - 1/20 = (2-3)/60 = -1/60v = -60 cm. This correctly indicates a real image formed 60 cm in front of the concave mirror, consistent with ray diagrams (when object is between F and C, image forms beyond C).Problem: A convex lens has a focal length of +25 cm. Calculate its power.
Wrong Approach: A student directly substitutes f = 25 into the power formula:
P = 1/f = 1/25 D = 0.04 D
This is incorrect because 'f' must be in meters for 'P' to be in Dioptres.
Problem: A convex lens has a focal length of +25 cm. Calculate its power.
Correct Approach:
This ensures the unit of power is correctly in Dioptres.
1/v + 1/(-15) = 1/101/v = 1/10 + 1/15 = (3+2)/30 = 5/30 = 1/6v = +6 cm (Incorrect result, as it assumes reflection properties.)1/v - 1/u = 1/f1/v - 1/(-15) = 1/101/v + 1/15 = 1/101/v = 1/10 - 1/15 = (3-2)/30 = 1/30v = +30 cm (Correct image position, indicating a real, inverted image formed on the right side of the lens.)Students frequently make errors in assigning positive or negative signs to object distance (u), image distance (v), focal length (f), and radius of curvature (R) for mirrors and lenses. This fundamental conceptual error leads to incorrect calculations for image position, size, and nature in almost all numerical problems related to reflection and refraction.
Always apply the Cartesian Sign Convention consistently:
For a concave mirror, if an object is placed 30 cm from the pole (so u = -30 cm) and its focal length is 15 cm (so f = -15 cm), a common mistake is to write u = +30 cm or f = +15 cm, leading to an incorrect image distance calculation.
Applying the Cartesian Sign Convention correctly:
| Quantity | Concave Mirror | Convex Mirror | Convex Lens | Concave Lens |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Object Distance (u) | Negative | Negative | Negative | Negative |
| Focal Length (f) | Negative | Positive | Positive | Negative |
| Radius of Curvature (R) | Negative | Positive | (Depends on surface) | (Depends on surface) |
For example, if an object is 20 cm from a convex mirror (f = +15 cm), then u = -20 cm, f = +15 cm.
A common error in a two-element system (e.g., lens followed by a mirror) is to always assume u (object distance) is negative, regardless of whether the intermediate image (acting as an object for the second element) is real or virtual relative to the second element. For example, if an intermediate image I1 forms 30 cm to the right of a lens, and a mirror is placed 20 cm to the right of the lens, I1 is 10 cm to the right of the mirror. A student might incorrectly assign u = -10 cm for the mirror, misinterpreting I1 as a real object for the mirror and getting the sign wrong based on incident light direction.
Problem: An object is placed 15 cm to the left of a convex lens (f = +10 cm). A concave mirror (f = -20 cm) is placed 20 cm to the right of the lens.
A student encounters a problem involving a wide beam of parallel light incident on a concave mirror. They directly state that all rays will converge at the principal focus 'f' (R/2), thus assuming a perfectly sharp image point. This is incorrect for marginal rays.
Consider a marginal ray (far from the principal axis) incident parallel to the principal axis on a concave mirror. Due to the breakdown of the paraxial approximation, this ray will reflect and intersect the principal axis at a point closer to the pole than the principal focus 'F'. To find its exact intersection point, one must use the Law of Reflection and geometry/trigonometry, not the mirror formula directly. This phenomenon is known as spherical aberration.
A convex lens has a focal length of 25 cm. A student calculates its power as:
P = 1/f = 1/25 = 0.04 D.
A convex lens has a focal length of 25 cm. To find its power in Diopters, first convert focal length to meters:
f = 25 cm = 0.25 m.
Now, calculate power:
P = 1/f = 1/0.25 = 4 D.
1/f = 1/v + 1/u
1/(-20) = 1/v + 1/(30) // Incorrect: object distance (u) should be -30 cm
1/v = -1/20 - 1/30 = -5/60 => v = -12 cm
This incorrectly suggests a real image at 12 cm.1/(-20) = 1/v + 1/(-30)
1/v = -1/20 - (-1/30) = -1/20 + 1/30
1/v = (-3 + 2)/60 = -1/60
v = -60 cm
Interpretation: The image is formed 60 cm in front of the mirror, which is a real and inverted image, consistent with a concave mirror forming a real image beyond C when the object is between F and C.1/f = 1/v + 1/u) with the Lens Formula (1/f = 1/v - 1/u). This fundamental confusion, coupled with inconsistent application of Cartesian Sign Conventions for object distance (u), image distance (v), and focal length (f), invariably leads to incorrect solutions in optical problems. 1/f = 1/v + 1/u. Magnification: m = -v/u.1/f = 1/v - 1/u. Magnification: m = v/u.Remember that for a concave mirror/convex lens (converging), 'f' is typically positive if light comes from left and focus is real, and negative for a convex mirror/concave lens (diverging).
1/f = 1/v - 1/u1/(-20) = 1/v - 1/(-30)-1/20 = 1/v + 1/301/v = -1/20 - 1/30 = -5/60v = -12 cm(Incorrect, as the lens formula was used for a mirror.)
1/f = 1/v + 1/u1/(-20) = 1/v + 1/(-30)-1/20 = 1/v - 1/301/v = -1/20 + 1/30 = -1/60v = -60 cm(Correct, image is real and inverted, formed 60 cm in front of the mirror.)
No summary available yet.
No educational resource available yet.