πŸ“–Topic Explanations

🌐 Overview
Hello students! Welcome to Relative velocity in one dimension! Get ready to unlock a fundamental concept that simplifies how we perceive and analyze motion, making complex problems surprisingly straightforward.

Have you ever been in a car moving parallel to another car, and it feels like the other car is standing still, or even moving backward, even though both are clearly in motion? Or perhaps you've seen two athletes running on a track – how fast does one appear to be moving from the perspective of the other? These everyday observations are perfect examples of relative motion.

In this exciting section, we'll dive into the world of how motion is perceived from different reference frames. Specifically, we'll focus on relative velocity in one dimension, which means we're dealing with objects moving along a straight line – forward or backward, left or right. It's not just about how fast an object is moving by itself, but rather, how fast one object appears to be moving when observed from another moving object.

Understanding relative velocity is more than just an academic exercise; it’s a crucial tool in physics. It forms the bedrock for analyzing more advanced topics like projectile motion, collisions, and even the motion of celestial bodies. For your JEE Main and board exams, mastering this concept is non-negotiable. Problems involving trains crossing bridges, boats moving in rivers, or objects approaching each other are frequently tested, and a solid grasp of relative velocity will give you a significant edge.

What will you learn here? We'll begin by clarifying what a reference frame is and why it's so important. You'll then discover the simple yet powerful mathematical tools to calculate the relative velocity of one object with respect to another when they are moving in the same direction, or in opposite directions. We'll explore how simple vector addition and subtraction, keeping track of directions, can demystify seemingly complicated scenarios.

By the end of this module, you'll be able to:

  • Define relative velocity and understand its significance.

  • Calculate relative velocities for objects moving in one dimension.

  • Apply these concepts to solve a variety of numerical problems.

  • Gain an intuitive understanding of how motion changes based on the observer.



Prepare to change your perspective on motion! This fundamental concept will not only boost your problem-solving skills but also deepen your appreciation for the elegance of physics. Let's embark on this exciting journey to master relative velocity in one dimension!
πŸ“š Fundamentals
Hello, my dear students! Welcome to an exciting and super practical concept in Kinematics: Relative Velocity in One Dimension. This topic is incredibly important, not just for your exams like JEE Mains and Advanced, but also for understanding how the world around you truly works. Have you ever wondered why a car moving next to you on a highway appears to be barely moving, even if both cars are zooming at 100 km/h? Or why it feels like an oncoming train rushes past you much faster than a train going in the same direction? The answer lies in relative velocity!

Let's dive in and unlock this concept, starting from the very basics.

### The Foundation: What is Relative Velocity?

Imagine you're standing on a railway platform, watching a train go by. You'd say the train is moving at, say, 60 km/h. Now, imagine a person *inside* that train is walking towards the front of the train at 5 km/h. How fast is that person moving?

Well, it depends on who you ask!
* For you, standing on the platform, the person is moving at 60 km/h (speed of train) + 5 km/h (speed of person relative to train) = 65 km/h.
* For someone sitting on a seat *inside* the same train, that person is just walking at 5 km/h.

This simple example highlights a crucial point: motion is relative. The velocity of an object depends on the frame of reference from which it is observed.

Relative velocity is simply the velocity of an object as observed from another moving object (or frame of reference). It's all about how one object "sees" the motion of another.

### Understanding the Frame of Reference

Before we get into formulas, let's solidify the idea of a frame of reference. Think of it as your observation point, a place from which you are measuring positions, distances, and velocities.

* When you say a car is moving at 60 km/h, you implicitly mean 60 km/h *with respect to the ground* (or the road, or the Earth). Your frame of reference is the ground, which we usually consider stationary.
* When the person inside the train says they are walking at 5 km/h, they mean *with respect to the train*. Their frame of reference is the train itself.

For our study of relative velocity, it's vital to always clearly define what we mean by "with respect to what".

### Building Intuition: A Simple Scenario

Let's consider two friends, Car A and Car B, driving on a straight highway. We'll use a positive sign for velocities to the right and a negative sign for velocities to the left.









































Scenario Car A's Velocity (`v_A`) Car B's Velocity (`v_B`) How does A see B? (Velocity of B relative to A) How does B see A? (Velocity of A relative to B)
Both moving right, A faster +100 km/h +80 km/h B moves left relative to A at 20 km/h A moves right relative to B at 20 km/h
Both moving right, B faster +80 km/h +100 km/h B moves right relative to A at 20 km/h A moves left relative to B at 20 km/h
Moving in opposite directions +80 km/h -100 km/h B moves left relative to A at 180 km/h A moves right relative to B at 180 km/h
Both stationary 0 km/h 0 km/h B is stationary relative to A A is stationary relative to B

Notice how in the first two scenarios, when they are moving in the *same* direction, the relative speed is the *difference* in their speeds. When they are moving in *opposite* directions, the relative speed is the *sum* of their speeds. This intuition will be key!

### Formalizing Relative Velocity in One Dimension

Let's denote the velocity of object A with respect to the ground (or a stationary observer) as `v_A`, and the velocity of object B with respect to the ground as `v_B`. Remember, in one dimension, these are essentially scalar values but carry a sign (+ or -) to indicate direction.

The velocity of object A with respect to object B, denoted as `v_AB`, is given by:

`v_AB = v_A - v_B`

Similarly, the velocity of object B with respect to object A, denoted as `v_BA`, is given by:

`v_BA = v_B - v_A`

From these definitions, you can clearly see that `v_AB = -v_BA`. This makes perfect sense: if you see a friend walking forward at 5 km/h relative to you, then your friend sees you walking backward at 5 km/h relative to them!

#### Derivation (A quick look)

Imagine the positions of two objects A and B at any time `t` are `x_A(t)` and `x_B(t)` with respect to a common origin on the ground.
The position of A with respect to B, let's call it `x_AB(t)`, is given by:
`x_AB(t) = x_A(t) - x_B(t)`

Now, velocity is the rate of change of position with respect to time. So, if we differentiate this equation with respect to time:
`d(x_AB)/dt = d(x_A)/dt - d(x_B)/dt`

Which gives us:
`v_AB = v_A - v_B`

This derivation confirms our formula!

### Cases to Remember for 1D Relative Velocity

Let's re-examine our car scenarios with the formula:

1. Objects Moving in the Same Direction (e.g., both right)
* Let `v_A = +100 km/h` and `v_B = +80 km/h`.
* Velocity of A relative to B: `v_AB = v_A - v_B = (+100) - (+80) = +20 km/h`. (B sees A moving ahead at 20 km/h)
* Velocity of B relative to A: `v_BA = v_B - v_A = (+80) - (+100) = -20 km/h`. (A sees B falling behind at 20 km/h)


Key takeaway: When objects move in the same direction, their relative speed is the absolute difference of their individual speeds.

2. Objects Moving in Opposite Directions (e.g., A right, B left)
* Let `v_A = +80 km/h` and `v_B = -100 km/h` (negative because B is moving left).
* Velocity of A relative to B: `v_AB = v_A - v_B = (+80) - (-100) = +80 + 100 = +180 km/h`. (B sees A approaching/moving right at 180 km/h)
* Velocity of B relative to A: `v_BA = v_B - v_A = (-100) - (+80) = -100 - 80 = -180 km/h`. (A sees B approaching/moving left at 180 km/h)


Key takeaway: When objects move in opposite directions, their relative speed is the sum of their individual speeds.

### Important Notes for JEE & Competitive Exams

* Always define your positive direction: This is crucial. Stick to a convention (e.g., right is positive, left is negative; up is positive, down is negative).
* Specify the observer: Clearly identify who is observing whom. "Velocity of A with respect to B" is `v_A - v_B`, not `v_B - v_A`.
* The 'ground' frame: Unless specified, `v_A` and `v_B` usually refer to velocities with respect to a stationary ground frame.
* Relative Acceleration: Just like relative velocity, relative acceleration follows the same rule: `a_AB = a_A - a_B`. This becomes important in problems involving changing velocities.
* Relative Displacement/Position: `x_AB = x_A - x_B` and `Ξ”x_AB = Ξ”x_A - Ξ”x_B`. This means the relative displacement is simply the difference in individual displacements.

### Practical Applications and Examples

Relative velocity simplifies many complex problems. For instance, if two trains are approaching each other, instead of calculating when they meet by considering both moving, you can fix one train and consider the other train approaching it with the *relative velocity*. This drastically simplifies the calculation to a simple `distance = relative speed Γ— time` problem.

Let's work through a few examples to solidify your understanding.

Example 1: Cars on a Highway

Two cars, Car P and Car Q, are moving on a straight highway. Car P is moving at 70 km/h towards the East, and Car Q is moving at 50 km/h towards the East.
(a) What is the velocity of Car P with respect to Car Q?
(b) What is the velocity of Car Q with respect to Car P?

Solution:
Let's define East as the positive direction.
Velocity of Car P, `v_P = +70 km/h`
Velocity of Car Q, `v_Q = +50 km/h`

(a) Velocity of Car P with respect to Car Q (`v_PQ`):
`v_PQ = v_P - v_Q`
`v_PQ = (+70) - (+50) = +20 km/h`
This means Car Q observes Car P moving East (forward) at 20 km/h.

(b) Velocity of Car Q with respect to Car P (`v_QP`):
`v_QP = v_Q - v_P`
`v_QP = (+50) - (+70) = -20 km/h`
This means Car P observes Car Q moving West (backward) at 20 km/h. Car P sees Car Q falling behind.

Example 2: Meeting Trains

A train A is moving East at 90 km/h. Another train B is moving West at 72 km/h. They are initially 300 km apart.
(a) What is the velocity of train B with respect to train A?
(b) How much time will it take for them to meet?

Solution:
Let East be the positive direction.
Velocity of train A, `v_A = +90 km/h`
Velocity of train B, `v_B = -72 km/h` (since it's moving West)

(a) Velocity of train B with respect to train A (`v_BA`):
`v_BA = v_B - v_A`
`v_BA = (-72) - (+90) = -72 - 90 = -162 km/h`
This means train A observes train B approaching it from the West (moving in the negative direction) at a speed of 162 km/h. The relative speed of approach is 162 km/h.

(b) Time to meet:
The initial distance between them is `d = 300 km`.
The relative speed at which they are approaching each other is `|v_BA| = 162 km/h`.
Using the formula `time = distance / speed`:
`Time = d / |v_BA| = 300 km / 162 km/h`
`Time β‰ˆ 1.85 hours`

Example 3: Person on a Moving Walkway

A long moving walkway (like at an airport) moves at 3 m/s. A person walks on the walkway at a speed of 1 m/s relative to the walkway.
(a) What is the person's speed relative to the ground if they walk in the same direction as the walkway?
(b) What is the person's speed relative to the ground if they walk opposite to the direction of the walkway?

Solution:
Let the direction of the walkway be positive.
Velocity of walkway with respect to ground, `v_W = +3 m/s`
Velocity of person with respect to walkway, `v_PW = +1 m/s` (walking in same direction) or `-1 m/s` (walking opposite direction).

We need to find the velocity of the person with respect to the ground, `v_P`.
We know `v_PW = v_P - v_W`.
Rearranging, `v_P = v_PW + v_W`. This is a very common scenario - the absolute velocity is the sum of the velocity relative to the moving frame and the velocity of the moving frame itself.

(a) Person walks in the same direction as the walkway:
`v_PW = +1 m/s`
`v_P = (+1) + (+3) = +4 m/s`
The person's speed relative to the ground is 4 m/s in the direction of the walkway.

(b) Person walks opposite to the direction of the walkway:
`v_PW = -1 m/s`
`v_P = (-1) + (+3) = +2 m/s`
The person's speed relative to the ground is 2 m/s in the direction of the walkway (they are still moving forward, but slower). If `v_PW` was greater than `v_W`, they would move backward relative to the ground. For example, if they walked at 4 m/s opposite to the walkway, `v_P = (-4) + (+3) = -1 m/s` (moving backward at 1 m/s relative to ground).

### Conclusion for Fundamentals

You've now grasped the fundamental principles of relative velocity in one dimension! Remember, it all boils down to understanding:
1. Frame of Reference: Who is observing?
2. Vector Nature: Direction matters – use positive and negative signs consistently.
3. The Formula: `v_AB = v_A - v_B` is your best friend.

This simple concept is a powerful tool for analyzing motion and will be extended to two and three dimensions, which you'll encounter soon. For JEE, problems often involve scenarios like these, sometimes combined with constant acceleration, so make sure your conceptual foundation here is rock solid!
πŸ”¬ Deep Dive

Hello, aspiring physicists! Welcome to a truly fundamental and incredibly useful concept in Kinematics: Relative Velocity. This is one of those topics that will profoundly change how you look at motion, and it's absolutely crucial for cracking not just JEE but also building a strong intuition for real-world scenarios. We'll start from the very basics and then build our way up to the kind of complex problems you'll face in competitive exams.



Think about it: Is anything truly at rest? You might be sitting on a chair, feeling still, but you're on a planet that's spinning, orbiting a star, which itself is moving within a galaxy that's also hurtling through space! This simple thought experiment highlights a core principle: all motion is relative. There's no absolute rest or absolute motion; motion is always described with respect to something else, which we call a Frame of Reference.



1. Understanding the Frame of Reference



Before we dive into relative velocity, let's firmly grasp what a Frame of Reference (FoR) is. Imagine you're watching a cricket match. You, standing on the ground, are observing the ball flying. Your position on the ground, combined with a stopwatch, constitutes your frame of reference. If you were sitting inside a moving car watching the same match, your car would be your frame of reference.




  • A frame of reference is essentially a coordinate system (like an X-Y-Z axis) with a clock attached to it. It's the viewpoint from which an observer measures position, displacement, velocity, and acceleration.

  • When we say "velocity of an object," it implicitly means "velocity of that object with respect to the ground" (which is usually considered stationary for most common problems).



For JEE, it's important to differentiate between Inertial and Non-Inertial Frames. An inertial frame is one where Newton's Laws of Motion hold true without the need for 'fictitious forces'. A frame moving with constant velocity (or at rest) relative to another inertial frame is also inertial. A frame that is accelerating (like a car speeding up or turning) is non-inertial. For 1D relative velocity problems, we primarily deal with inertial frames, unless specified.



2. Relative Position in One Dimension



Let's consider two objects, A and B, moving along a straight line. We place our origin (O) at some point on this line.
Let $x_A$ be the position of object A with respect to the origin O.
Let $x_B$ be the position of object B with respect to the origin O.



What does it mean to find the "position of B with respect to A"? It means, if an observer were sitting on object A, what would they measure as the position of B?
This is given by:


$x_{BA} = x_B - x_A$


Here, $x_{BA}$ is the relative position of B with respect to A.
Similarly, the position of A with respect to B would be $x_{AB} = x_A - x_B$.
Notice that $x_{AB} = -x_{BA}$.



3. Derivation of Relative Velocity in One Dimension



Now, let's extend this idea to velocity. Velocity is the rate of change of position with respect to time. So, if we want the relative velocity, we simply differentiate the relative position with respect to time.



Consider objects A and B moving along the X-axis.
Their positions at time $t$ are $x_A(t)$ and $x_B(t)$ respectively, with respect to a common origin O.



The position of B relative to A is:
$x_{BA}(t) = x_B(t) - x_A(t)$



To find the velocity of B relative to A, we differentiate $x_{BA}(t)$ with respect to time:


$mathbf{v_{BA} = frac{d}{dt}(x_{BA}(t)) = frac{d}{dt}(x_B(t) - x_A(t))}$


Using the linearity of differentiation:


$mathbf{v_{BA} = frac{dx_B(t)}{dt} - frac{dx_A(t)}{dt}}$



We know that $frac{dx_B(t)}{dt}$ is the velocity of B with respect to the origin (ground), $v_B$.
And $frac{dx_A(t)}{dt}$ is the velocity of A with respect to the origin (ground), $v_A$.



Therefore, the fundamental formula for relative velocity in one dimension is:


$v_{BA} = v_B - v_A$


This means the velocity of B as observed from A (or with respect to A) is the velocity of B minus the velocity of A (both measured with respect to the same common frame, usually the ground).



Similarly, the velocity of A with respect to B would be:


$v_{AB} = v_A - v_B$


Notice that $v_{AB} = -v_{BA}$. This makes intuitive sense: if you see a car moving away from you at 20 km/h, someone in that car sees you moving away from them at -20 km/h (i.e., in the opposite direction at 20 km/h).



Key Interpretation:



  • To find the velocity of object A as seen by object B, subtract the velocity of B from the velocity of A.

  • Always establish a positive direction. Velocities in that direction are positive, and velocities in the opposite direction are negative. This is critical for 1D relative motion problems.



4. Relative Acceleration in One Dimension



Just as velocity is the rate of change of position, acceleration is the rate of change of velocity. So, following the same logic:


$mathbf{a_{BA} = frac{d}{dt}(v_{BA}) = frac{d}{dt}(v_B - v_A) = frac{dv_B}{dt} - frac{dv_A}{dt}}$


Therefore, the relative acceleration of B with respect to A is:


$a_{BA} = a_B - a_A$


This formula is particularly useful in problems where objects are accelerating, like a police car chasing a speeder who is also accelerating or decelerating.



5. Different Scenarios in One Dimension



Let's look at how the formula $v_{BA} = v_B - v_A$ applies in various 1D scenarios:

Scenario 1: Objects Moving in the Same Direction


Suppose car A is moving east at $v_A = +50 ext{ km/h}$ and car B is moving east at $v_B = +70 ext{ km/h}$. (Let east be the positive direction).



  • Velocity of B with respect to A ($v_{BA}$):
    $v_{BA} = v_B - v_A = (+70) - (+50) = +20 ext{ km/h}$
    This means that from car A's perspective, car B is moving away from it (east) at 20 km/h. Car B is "overtaking" car A at this relative speed.

  • Velocity of A with respect to B ($v_{AB}$):
    $v_{AB} = v_A - v_B = (+50) - (+70) = -20 ext{ km/h}$
    From car B's perspective, car A is moving backwards (west) at 20 km/h.



Scenario 2: Objects Moving Towards Each Other (Opposite Directions)


Suppose car A is moving east at $v_A = +50 ext{ km/h}$ and car B is moving west at $v_B = -70 ext{ km/h}$. (East is positive, so west is negative).



  • Velocity of B with respect to A ($v_{BA}$):
    $v_{BA} = v_B - v_A = (-70) - (+50) = -120 ext{ km/h}$
    From car A's perspective, car B is approaching it from the west at a very high speed of 120 km/h. The magnitude of relative velocity is the sum of their speeds.

  • Velocity of A with respect to B ($v_{AB}$):
    $v_{AB} = v_A - v_B = (+50) - (-70) = +120 ext{ km/h}$
    From car B's perspective, car A is approaching it from the east at 120 km/h.


Intuition Check: When objects move towards each other, their relative speed (magnitude of relative velocity) is the sum of their individual speeds. When they move in the same direction, their relative speed is the difference of their individual speeds.



6. Applications and Problem-Solving Strategy for JEE



Relative velocity is a powerful tool to simplify complex motion problems, especially those involving meeting points, crossing times, or minimum distances.



General Strategy:



  1. Choose a Reference Frame: For relative velocity problems, it's often easiest to shift your frame of reference to one of the moving objects. If you want to find out what A observes, you consider yourself on A.

  2. Define a Positive Direction: For 1D motion, this is crucial. Stick to it consistently. For example, right = positive, left = negative; or upwards = positive, downwards = negative.

  3. Assign Velocities with Signs: Write down $v_A$, $v_B$, etc., with appropriate positive or negative signs based on your chosen positive direction.

  4. Apply the Formula: Use $v_{XY} = v_Y - v_X$.

  5. Convert to Relative Displacement/Acceleration: Once you have relative velocity (and possibly relative acceleration), you can use the standard kinematic equations (e.g., $s = ut + frac{1}{2}at^2$, $v = u + at$, $v^2 = u^2 + 2as$) but with relative quantities.
    For example, if you want to find the time it takes for object B to cover a relative distance $x_{BA, initial}$ with respect to A, you'd use $x_{BA, initial} = v_{BA}t + frac{1}{2}a_{BA}t^2$.



JEE Focus: Meeting/Crossing Problems


These are very common. When two objects meet, their relative position becomes zero (if they started at the same point) or their relative displacement covers the initial separation. Using a relative frame simplifies these problems dramatically.


Example: Two trains, A (length $L_A$) and B (length $L_B$), are moving on parallel tracks. What is the time it takes for train A to completely pass train B?


If we consider train A as the observer, train B appears to move with relative velocity $v_{BA} = v_B - v_A$. For train A to completely pass train B, the front of A must reach the back of B, and then the back of A must pass the front of B. The total relative distance to be covered is $L_A + L_B$.


So, the time taken for passing will be:


$t = frac{ ext{Total relative distance}}{ ext{Relative speed}} = frac{L_A + L_B}{|v_{BA}|}$ (where $|v_{BA}|$ is the magnitude of relative velocity, i.e., relative speed).




CBSE vs. JEE Focus:

For CBSE, the concept of relative velocity is introduced with simpler scenarios, mostly involving constant velocities and straightforward calculations. The emphasis is on understanding the basic formula $v_{rel} = v_A pm v_B$ (depending on directions). For JEE, problems will often combine relative motion with constant acceleration, require setting up quadratic equations, or involve scenarios like a body dropped from a moving lift, or a person running on a train. The application of relative acceleration becomes more frequent, and often you'll need to choose the most convenient frame of reference to simplify the problem.




Example 1: Cars on a Highway



Two cars, Car P and Car Q, are moving on a straight highway. Car P is moving at $60 ext{ km/h}$ and Car Q at $80 ext{ km/h}$. At a certain instant, Car P is $100 ext{ km}$ ahead of Car Q.



  1. What is the velocity of Car Q with respect to Car P if both are moving in the same direction?

  2. How long will it take for Car Q to catch up with Car P?



Step-by-step solution:


Let's define the direction of motion as positive (+).


Given:
$v_P = +60 ext{ km/h}$
$v_Q = +80 ext{ km/h}$
Initial separation, $x_{PQ, initial} = 100 ext{ km}$ (P is ahead of Q, so Q needs to cover 100 km relative to P).



Part 1: Velocity of Car Q with respect to Car P ($v_{QP}$)


Using the formula: $v_{QP} = v_Q - v_P$
$v_{QP} = (+80) - (+60)$
$v_{QP} = +20 ext{ km/h}$


This means Car Q is approaching Car P at a relative speed of 20 km/h in the positive direction (i.e., it's closing the gap).



Part 2: Time for Car Q to catch up with Car P


In the frame of reference of Car P, Car Q is moving towards P with a speed of $20 ext{ km/h}$.
The relative distance Car Q needs to cover to catch up with Car P is the initial separation, which is $100 ext{ km}$.


Using the kinematic equation for constant velocity: distance = speed $ imes$ time
Relative distance = Relative speed $ imes$ time
$100 ext{ km} = 20 ext{ km/h} imes t$
$t = frac{100 ext{ km}}{20 ext{ km/h}}$
$t = 5 ext{ hours}$


So, it will take 5 hours for Car Q to catch up with Car P.



Example 2: Two Trains Approaching Each Other



Train A (length $150 ext{ m}$) is moving east at $10 ext{ m/s}$. Train B (length $200 ext{ m}$) is moving west at $15 ext{ m/s}$. If they are initially $2 ext{ km}$ apart (distance between their fronts), how long will it take for them to completely pass each other?



Step-by-step solution:


Let's define East as the positive (+) direction.


Given:
$v_A = +10 ext{ m/s}$ (East)
$v_B = -15 ext{ m/s}$ (West)
Length of Train A, $L_A = 150 ext{ m}$
Length of Train B, $L_B = 200 ext{ m}$
Initial distance between their fronts = $2 ext{ km} = 2000 ext{ m}$.



First, calculate the relative velocity of Train B with respect to Train A ($v_{BA}$).
$v_{BA} = v_B - v_A = (-15) - (+10) = -25 ext{ m/s}$
The relative speed is $25 ext{ m/s}$. The negative sign indicates B is approaching A from the west.



Now, consider the total relative distance they need to cover to *completely pass* each other.
Imagine we are sitting on Train A. Train B is approaching us at $25 ext{ m/s}$.
Initially, the front of B is $2000 ext{ m}$ away.
For the trains to completely pass, the front of B must first reach the front of A (covering $2000 ext{ m}$), and then the entire length of B must pass the entire length of A. This means the back of B must pass the back of A.


The total relative distance to be covered for complete passing is:
Initial separation + length of Train A + length of Train B (this is one way to think about it for this scenario of passing each other).
Let's simplify. When objects pass each other, the effective length they need to "traverse" each other is the sum of their lengths. When they are initially separated, the relative displacement that needs to occur for them to completely pass is the initial separation plus the sum of their lengths.



Let's use a cleaner approach: Consider the front of train A as $x_A$ and the front of train B as $x_B$.
Initially, let $x_A(0) = 0$. Then $x_B(0) = 2000 ext{ m}$ (since B is 2km ahead).
Train A's length means its back is at $x_A - L_A$. Train B's back is at $x_B - L_B$.
(Alternatively, consider the position of the front of A and the back of B. Let front of A be at $x_A$ and front of B at $x_B$. They are $2000m$ apart. Let $x_A=0$. $x_B=2000m$.
For them to *just meet*, their fronts would meet.
For them to *completely pass*, the back of train A must pass the back of train B. Or, the position of the front of A must go beyond the position of the back of B.


Let's consider the front of train A as a reference point. Train B's front is $2000 ext{ m}$ away.
For A to completely pass B, the front of B must effectively "move" a distance of $2000 ext{ m}$ (to reach A's front) + $L_A$ (to pass A's length) + $L_B$ (to have B's entire length past A).


This framing can be confusing. A simpler approach:
Pick a point on Train A (e.g., its front, $F_A$) and a point on Train B (e.g., its back, $B_B$).
Initially, let $F_A$ be at $x=0$.
$B_A$ is at $-150 ext{ m}$.
$F_B$ is at $2000 ext{ m}$.
$B_B$ is at $2000 - 200 = 1800 ext{ m}$.


For them to completely pass, $F_A$ must pass $B_B$. In the frame of reference of $F_A$, the initial position of $B_B$ is $1800 ext{ m}$. The relative speed of $B_B$ towards $F_A$ is $25 ext{ m/s}$.
So, time $t = frac{ ext{Initial relative distance}}{| ext{Relative speed}|} = frac{1800 ext{ m}}{25 ext{ m/s}}$ (No, this is incorrect). This calculates when $F_A$ reaches $B_B$'s initial position.



Let's simplify the relative displacement:
Consider train A as the observer. Train B approaches it with a relative speed of $25 ext{ m/s}$.
Initially, the front of B is $2000 ext{ m}$ from the front of A.
For them to *just meet*, the time would be $t_1 = frac{2000}{25} = 80 ext{ s}$. At this point, the fronts are aligned.


Now, for them to completely pass, after their fronts align, Train B (from A's perspective) must cover an additional distance equal to the sum of their lengths.
The total relative distance that needs to be covered from the instant their fronts meet until their backs clear each other is $L_A + L_B$.
So, additional distance $= 150 ext{ m} + 200 ext{ m} = 350 ext{ m}$.


Time to cover this additional relative distance $= frac{350 ext{ m}}{25 ext{ m/s}} = 14 ext{ s}$.


Total time for them to completely pass each other = Time to meet fronts + Time to clear backs
Total time $= 80 ext{ s} + 14 ext{ s} = 94 ext{ s}$.



Alternatively, the total relative displacement that must occur for the *effective start of passing* (front of A meets front of B) to the *effective end of passing* (back of A leaves back of B) is the initial separation + sum of lengths, if you take one endpoint (e.g., front of A) as the reference.
Initial separation between $F_A$ and $F_B$ is $2000 ext{ m}$.
For $F_A$ to pass $F_B$ and then $B_A$ pass $B_B$, effectively the relative distance to be covered by the reference point on one train relative to a corresponding point on the other, for complete passing, is the sum of the initial separation plus the sum of their lengths, when their direction is opposite.
Total effective distance $= ext{Initial separation} + L_A + L_B$
Total effective distance $= 2000 ext{ m} + 150 ext{ m} + 200 ext{ m} = 2350 ext{ m}$.


Time $= frac{2350 ext{ m}}{25 ext{ m/s}} = 94 ext{ s}$.


This second method is more direct. Consider the front of train A ($F_A$) and the back of train B ($B_B$).
Initially, $F_A$ is at $x=0$. $F_B$ is at $x=+2000 ext{ m}$. So $B_B$ is at $x = (2000-200) = +1800 ext{ m}$.
For complete passing, $F_A$ must cross $B_B$.
The initial relative position of $B_B$ with respect to $F_A$ is $1800 ext{ m}$.
The relative velocity of $B_B$ with respect to $F_A$ is $v_{B_B, F_A} = v_{B_B} - v_{F_A} = (-15) - (+10) = -25 ext{ m/s}$.
So the time taken for $F_A$ to reach $B_B$'s initial position if $B_B$ were stationary would be $frac{1800}{25} = 72 ext{ s}$.
This is incorrect for *complete* passing. The second method (Total effective distance $= ext{Initial separation} + L_A + L_B$) is the correct one for opposite directions.



Summary of distance for passing:



















Scenario Effective Relative Distance for Complete Passing
Objects moving in the same direction (one overtakes another) Sum of their lengths ($L_1 + L_2$)
Objects moving in opposite directions (one passes another after meeting) Initial separation + Sum of their lengths ($X_{initial} + L_1 + L_2$)


Therefore, for Example 2, the total effective distance to be covered for complete passing is $2000 ext{ m} + 150 ext{ m} + 200 ext{ m} = 2350 ext{ m}$.
Time $= frac{ ext{Total effective distance}}{ ext{Relative speed}} = frac{2350 ext{ m}}{25 ext{ m/s}} = 94 ext{ s}$.



Conclusion


Relative velocity in one dimension is a foundational concept. Mastering it helps simplify complex multi-object problems by changing your perspective. Remember to always define a consistent positive direction, assign correct signs to velocities and accelerations, and correctly identify the observer and observed. Practice with diverse problems, including those involving varying acceleration, to fully prepare for JEE. Keep building that intuition!

🎯 Shortcuts

Mastering relative velocity in one dimension involves correctly applying the formula and consistently using sign conventions. These mnemonics and shortcuts are designed to help you quickly recall the concepts and solve problems efficiently in your JEE and board exams.



1. Core Formula for Relative Velocity: $V_{AB}$


The velocity of object A relative to object B ($V_{AB}$) is given by $V_{AB} = V_A - V_B$. This means if you are observing A from B, you effectively subtract B's velocity from A's velocity.



  • Mnemonic: "FROM"

    • First object (A)

    • Relative to

    • Observer (B)

    • Minus (sign)


    Think: VFROM = VFirst - VObserver. So, $V_{AB} = V_A - V_B$. This clearly tells you which velocity to subtract from which.





2. Relative Speed in Special Cases (One Dimension)


When calculating the *magnitude* of relative velocity (relative speed), especially for 'time to meet' or 'time to cross' problems, these shortcuts are invaluable.



  • Objects Moving in the SAME Direction: SUBTRACT Speeds

    • Example: Car A going at 60 km/h and Car B at 40 km/h in the same direction. Relative speed = $|60 - 40| = 20$ km/h.

    • Mnemonic: "S.S.S.S." - Same Side, Subtract Speeds.



  • Objects Moving in OPPOSITE Directions: ADD Speeds

    • Example: Car A going at 60 km/h and Car B at 40 km/h in opposite directions. Relative speed = $60 + 40 = 100$ km/h.

    • Mnemonic: "O.D.A.S." - Opposite Directions, Add Speeds.





3. Conceptual Shortcut: "Imagine Yourself as the Observer"


A powerful shortcut, particularly for understanding complex scenarios, is to mentally place yourself (the observer) at rest. This changes your frame of reference to the observer's frame.



  • Shortcut: "O.A.R." - Observer At Rest.

    • To find $V_{AB}$, imagine B is at rest. What velocity would A then appear to have? It's $V_A - V_B$.

    • This simplifies complex thinking because you're always considering motion relative to a stationary point (your imagined self).





4. Shortcut for Time to Meet/Cross/Overtake


Many problems involve calculating the time for two objects to meet, cross, or for one to overtake the other. This can be simplified using relative concepts.



  • Shortcut: Time = Relative Distance / Relative Speed

    • Instead of writing equations of motion for both objects, calculate the relative distance they need to cover and the relative speed at which they are closing or separating.

    • Example: Two cars 100 km apart, approaching each other with speeds 60 km/h and 40 km/h.
      * Relative distance = 100 km.
      * Relative speed (opposite directions, so add) = 60 + 40 = 100 km/h.
      * Time to meet = 100 km / 100 km/h = 1 hour.





By consistently applying these mnemonics and shortcuts, you can solve relative velocity problems in one dimension with greater speed and accuracy, which is crucial for competitive exams like JEE Main.

πŸ’‘ Quick Tips

πŸš€ Quick Tips: Relative Velocity in One Dimension


Mastering relative velocity in one dimension is crucial for simplifying complex kinematics problems. These tips will help you approach problems efficiently and accurately.



1. Understand the Core Concept



  • Definition: Relative velocity is the velocity of an object with respect to another moving object (or observer). It describes how the position of one object changes as seen from the frame of reference of the other.

  • Vector Subtraction: The core idea is that velocity is a vector quantity. In one dimension, this simplifies to algebraic subtraction, but signs are critical.



2. The Fundamental Formula



  • If 'A' and 'B' are two objects moving with velocities $vec{V_A}$ and $vec{V_B}$ respectively, relative velocity of 'A' with respect to 'B' is:


    $vec{V_{AB}} = vec{V_A} - vec{V_B}$


    This means "velocity of A as observed from B".

  • Conversely, velocity of 'B' with respect to 'A' is:


    $vec{V_{BA}} = vec{V_B} - vec{V_A}$


    Note that $vec{V_{AB}} = - vec{V_{BA}}$.



3. Consistent Sign Convention (Crucial for 1D)



  • Choose a Positive Direction: Before solving, clearly define which direction is positive (e.g., rightward is +ve, leftward is -ve; upward is +ve, downward is -ve).

  • Assign Signs to Velocities: All velocities (of objects and observers) must be assigned a sign according to your chosen convention.

    • If moving in the positive direction, velocity is positive.

    • If moving in the negative direction, velocity is negative.





4. Simplification of Scenarios (1D)



























Scenario Velocities (Algebraic Values) Relative Velocity ($V_{AB}$)
Objects Moving in Same Direction (A and B both positive or both negative) $V_A = +10 ext{ m/s}, V_B = +5 ext{ m/s}$ $V_{AB} = V_A - V_B = 10 - 5 = +5 ext{ m/s}$ (A approaches B at 5 m/s)
Objects Moving in Opposite Directions (Towards Each Other) $V_A = +10 ext{ m/s}, V_B = -5 ext{ m/s}$ $V_{AB} = V_A - V_B = 10 - (-5) = +15 ext{ m/s}$ (They approach each other faster)
Objects Moving in Opposite Directions (Away From Each Other) $V_A = -10 ext{ m/s}, V_B = +5 ext{ m/s}$ $V_{AB} = V_A - V_B = -10 - 5 = -15 ext{ m/s}$ (They separate faster)


5. Relative Acceleration



  • If objects have acceleration, relative acceleration is found similarly:


    $vec{a_{AB}} = vec{a_A} - vec{a_B}$

  • This allows you to use equations of motion (SUVAT) directly in the relative frame.



6. Graphical Interpretation (JEE Focus)



  • On a position-time (x-t) graph, the slope represents velocity.

  • The relative velocity of A with respect to B ($V_{AB}$) at any instant is the difference between the slopes of the x-t graphs of A and B at that instant.

  • If the lines representing A and B on an x-t graph are parallel, their relative velocity is zero (they are moving with the same velocity).



7. When to Use Relative Velocity



  • Simplifying Problems: Use it when an event (like meeting or collision) is described from the perspective of one of the moving objects. Transforming into the relative frame often makes the problem much simpler (e.g., one object becomes stationary, and the other moves with relative velocity).

  • Time to Meet/Cross: If two objects are initially separated by distance 'd' and their relative speed of approach is $V_{rel}$, the time to meet is $t = d / V_{rel}$.



8. JEE vs. CBSE Specifics



  • CBSE: Focuses on direct application of the formula with straightforward scenarios (e.g., train overtaking another train, car approaching a pedestrian). Emphasis on correct sign convention.

  • JEE: May involve relative acceleration, integration of relative motion with variable velocities, or scenarios requiring a deeper understanding of frame transformation to simplify calculations (e.g., finding minimum distance, multiple events). Graphical analysis of relative motion is also common.



Keep these tips handy to swiftly tackle relative velocity problems in one dimension!


🧠 Intuitive Understanding

Intuitive Understanding of Relative Velocity in One Dimension



Understanding relative velocity in one dimension is crucial for kinematics. It essentially answers the question: "How does the motion of one object appear to an observer on another moving object?"

Every velocity measurement is always relative to some reference frame. When we say a car is moving at 60 km/h, we usually mean 60 km/h with respect to the ground (an observer standing still on the road).



The Core Idea: What Does One See From Another?


Imagine you are sitting in a moving car. The world outside appears to be moving past you. Relative velocity formalizes this perception.





  • Consider two objects, A and B, moving along a straight line.


    When we talk about the relative velocity of A with respect to B (VAB), we are asking: "If I were sitting on object B, what velocity would I observe for object A?"





Scenario 1: Objects Moving in the Same Direction


Let's say Car A is moving east at 60 km/h and Car B is moving east at 40 km/h. Both velocities are with respect to the ground.




  • If you are in Car A (the faster car):


    You would observe Car B moving *backwards* relative to you, but very slowly. Alternatively, you perceive yourself moving away from Car B at a speed of (60 - 40) = 20 km/h. This is because you are "gaining" on Car B at 20 km/h.



    VAB = VA - VB = 60 km/h - 40 km/h = 20 km/h (East)

    (Car A appears to move east at 20 km/h relative to Car B)




  • If you are in Car B (the slower car):


    You would observe Car A moving *forward* (east) relative to you at a speed of 20 km/h. Car A appears to pull away from you at this rate.



    VBA = VB - VA = 40 km/h - 60 km/h = -20 km/h (East)

    (The negative sign indicates West, or simply that Car A appears to move away from Car B at 20 km/h in the direction of A's original motion.)




  • What if both cars move at the same speed (e.g., both at 60 km/h east)?


    If you're in Car A, you see Car B as stationary beside you. Their relative velocity is zero. This matches our intuition: if two objects move together at the same pace, one sees the other as not moving.





Scenario 2: Objects Moving in Opposite Directions


Let's say Car A is moving east at 60 km/h and Car B is moving west at 40 km/h. Conventionally, we take East as positive (+ve) and West as negative (-ve).




  • If you are in Car A:


    You would see Car B approaching you at a much higher speed. It's not just 40 km/h, nor 60 km/h, but the combined speed at which they are closing the distance.



    VAB = VA - VB = (+60 km/h) - (-40 km/h) = 60 + 40 = 100 km/h (East)

    (Car A appears to move east at 100 km/h relative to Car B, meaning Car B appears to approach Car A at 100 km/h from the west.)




  • Intuition Check: The distance between them is decreasing by 100 km every hour. This makes perfect sense! They are effectively "adding" their speeds from each other's perspective.



Summary of Intuition



  • When objects move in the same direction, their relative speed is the difference of their speeds.

  • When objects move in opposite directions, their relative speed is the sum of their speeds.



JEE & CBSE Relevance: This intuitive understanding is fundamental for both exams. While CBSE might stick to simpler numerical problems, JEE often uses relative velocity in more complex scenarios involving multiple objects, river-boat problems, or motion with acceleration, making a strong intuitive base absolutely essential.

🌍 Real World Applications

Real World Applications of Relative Velocity in One Dimension


Understanding relative velocity isn't just a theoretical concept; it's fundamental to perceiving and predicting motion in everyday life. In one dimension, where motion is restricted to a straight line, its applications are numerous and form the basis of many practical problems encountered in competitive exams like JEE and CBSE board exams.



1. Transportation and Traffic Analysis



  • Overtaking/Approaching Vehicles: When two cars move on a straight highway, their relative velocity determines how quickly one approaches or overtakes the other.

    • If two cars A and B are moving in the same direction with velocities $V_A$ and $V_B$, the velocity of A relative to B is $V_{AB} = V_A - V_B$. If $V_A > V_B$, A overtakes B.

    • If they are moving in opposite directions, the magnitude of their relative velocity is $|V_A| + |V_B|$, indicating how quickly they close the distance between them. This is crucial for calculating safe passing distances or collision times.



  • Train Journeys: Similarly, when two trains are on parallel tracks, their relative speed dictates how long it takes for one to completely pass the other, or how quickly they approach each other at a station.



2. Navigation in Rivers and Air



  • Boats in a River: A classic example involves a boat moving in a straight river.

    • If a boat travels upstream (against the current), its speed relative to the river bank (ground speed) is its speed in still water minus the speed of the river current.

    • If it travels downstream (with the current), its ground speed is its speed in still water plus the speed of the river current.


    This directly impacts travel time and fuel consumption for boats.

  • Aircraft with Wind: While often a 2D problem, a simplified 1D scenario involves an aircraft flying directly into a headwind or with a tailwind.

    • With a headwind, the aircraft's ground speed is its airspeed (speed relative to the air) minus the wind speed.

    • With a tailwind, its ground speed is its airspeed plus the wind speed.


    Pilots use this calculation to determine flight duration and fuel requirements.



3. Observational Physics and Everyday Perceptions



  • Relative Speed Perception: Our perception of how fast something is moving often depends on our own motion. For instance, a stationary object appears to whizz past faster if we are moving quickly towards it.

  • Rain on a Moving Vehicle: While often considered in 2D, if a car is moving and rain is falling vertically, the raindrops appear to fall at an angle from the perspective of someone inside the car. If we consider the vertical component of rain and horizontal component of car, the relative velocity components help in calculating the apparent angle of rain. (Note: For 1D, we might consider a simplified case where rain is also moving horizontally relative to the ground and car is moving horizontally).



JEE/CBSE Relevance:


Understanding these real-world scenarios is crucial for competitive exams as problems on relative velocity often involve such contexts. You will be asked to calculate minimum distance between two objects, time to meet/overtake, or speeds relative to different frames of reference, directly applying the principles discussed above.


Mastering relative velocity concepts is key to solving a wide range of practical physics problems!


πŸ”„ Common Analogies

Common Analogies for Relative Velocity in One Dimension



Understanding relative velocity can be greatly simplified by drawing parallels to everyday situations. These analogies help build an intuitive grasp of how velocities combine or subtract depending on the observer's frame of reference.

1. Cars on a Highway


This is perhaps the most common and effective analogy for relative velocity in one dimension.


  • Two cars moving in the same direction: Imagine you are in Car A moving at 60 km/h, and Car B is ahead of you, moving at 80 km/h in the same direction. From your perspective (the observer in Car A), Car B appears to be moving away from you at 20 km/h (80 - 60). If Car B was behind you moving at 40 km/h, it would appear to be moving away from you at 20 km/h in the opposite direction (60 - 40).

    Key takeaway: When objects move in the same direction, their relative velocity is the difference between their individual velocities. (vrel = |v1 - v2|)




  • Two cars moving in opposite directions: Now, imagine Car A is moving towards you at 60 km/h, and you are in Car B moving towards Car A at 80 km/h. To you, Car A appears to be approaching at a much higher speed, 140 km/h (60 + 80).

    Key takeaway: When objects move in opposite directions, their relative velocity is the sum of their individual velocities. (vrel = |v1 + v2|)





2. People on an Escalator or Moving Walkway


This analogy is excellent for understanding relative velocity with respect to a moving medium.


  • Walking with the escalator (in the direction of its motion): If you walk at 1 m/s on an escalator moving at 0.5 m/s, your speed relative to the ground is 1.5 m/s (1 + 0.5). You cover the distance faster.

    Key takeaway: Your speed relative to the stationary ground is the sum of your speed relative to the escalator and the escalator's speed relative to the ground.




  • Walking against the escalator (opposite to its motion): If you walk at 1 m/s on the same escalator, but in the opposite direction to its motion (which is 0.5 m/s), your speed relative to the ground is 0.5 m/s (1 - 0.5). If you walk slower than the escalator (e.g., 0.3 m/s), you'd actually move backward relative to the ground (-0.2 m/s).

    Key takeaway: Your speed relative to the ground is the difference between your speed relative to the escalator and the escalator's speed.





3. Boats in a River


Similar to the escalator, this is a classic analogy for the effect of a moving medium (the river current).


  • Boating downstream (with the current): If a boat moves at 10 km/h in still water and the river current is 2 km/h, the boat's speed relative to the river bank (ground) when going downstream is 12 km/h (10 + 2).


  • Boating upstream (against the current): When the same boat goes upstream, its speed relative to the river bank is 8 km/h (10 - 2). If the current were stronger than the boat's speed in still water (e.g., 10 km/h boat, 12 km/h current), the boat would actually move backward relative to the bank.



These analogies provide a strong foundation for visualizing and interpreting relative velocity problems, which are crucial for both CBSE board exams and competitive exams like JEE Main. Always remember to define your frame of reference clearly!
πŸ“‹ Prerequisites

To effectively grasp the concept of Relative Velocity in One Dimension, a solid understanding of several fundamental kinematic principles is essential. These prerequisites form the bedrock upon which more complex concepts are built and are crucial for both CBSE board exams and JEE Main/Advanced. Mastering them will ensure you can tackle relative velocity problems with confidence.



Prerequisites for Relative Velocity in One Dimension




  • Scalars vs. Vectors:

    A clear distinction between scalar quantities (like distance and speed) and vector quantities (like displacement, velocity, and acceleration) is paramount. Relative velocity fundamentally deals with vector subtraction. In one dimension, the direction of a vector is represented by its sign (+ or -).



    • Displacement: Change in position, a vector quantity. Its magnitude is the shortest distance between initial and final points, and its direction is from initial to final.

    • Velocity: Rate of change of displacement, also a vector quantity. It includes both speed and direction.




  • Basic Definitions of Kinematic Quantities:

    You must be thoroughly familiar with the definitions and differences between:



    • Distance and Displacement: Distance is the total path length (scalar); displacement is the change in position (vector).

    • Speed and Velocity: Speed is the rate of distance covered (scalar); velocity is the rate of displacement (vector).

    • Acceleration: Rate of change of velocity (vector). While not directly used in defining relative velocity, understanding how velocity changes is part of overall kinematics.




  • Sign Conventions in One-Dimensional Motion:

    In 1D motion, direction is represented by positive (+) or negative (-) signs. It's crucial to consistently apply a chosen sign convention:



    • Typically, motion to the right or upwards is taken as positive.

    • Motion to the left or downwards is taken as negative.

    • This convention applies to displacement, velocity, and acceleration. Without proper sign usage, relative velocity calculations will be incorrect.




  • Understanding Frame of Reference:

    Before diving into relative velocity, you should understand that all motion is observed relative to some reference point or frame. For instance, the velocity of a car is usually stated with respect to the ground (an implicit frame of reference). Relative velocity formalizes this by considering motion as observed from a moving frame of reference.



    • A frame of reference is a system of coordinates with respect to which the motion of an object is described.

    • Understanding that 'absolute velocity' is typically velocity with respect to the ground or a stationary observer is key.




  • Basic Algebraic Operations:

    The ability to perform basic addition and subtraction, especially with signed numbers, is fundamental. Relative velocity equations often involve straightforward vector subtraction which, in one dimension, reduces to algebraic subtraction with signs.





JEE & CBSE Focus: All these concepts are foundational and are equally important for both board examinations and competitive exams like JEE Main. A strong grasp here will prevent common errors in applying the relative velocity formula.

πŸ”— Related Topics

Understanding "Relative Velocity in One Dimension" is a foundational step in kinematics. To truly master this concept and its applications in competitive exams like JEE Main and board exams (CBSE), it's crucial to connect it with several related topics. These connections strengthen your conceptual understanding and prepare you for more complex problems.



Prerequisites to Relative Velocity in One Dimension


Before diving into relative velocity, ensure you have a firm grasp of these fundamental concepts:




  • Scalars and Vectors:

    • Why it's related: Velocity is a vector quantity, possessing both magnitude and direction. Relative velocity problems fundamentally involve vector addition and subtraction. A clear understanding of how to assign positive and negative signs for direction in 1D is critical.

    • JEE/CBSE relevance: Both exams test basic vector understanding. For JEE, this understanding is vital for error-free calculations.




  • Displacement, Velocity, and Acceleration:

    • Why it's related: Relative velocity builds directly upon the definitions of these quantities. You must be comfortable with their definitions, units, and how they are represented in 1D motion (e.g., positive/negative signs indicating direction).

    • JEE/CBSE relevance: These are the building blocks of kinematics for both exams.




  • Frame of Reference:

    • Why it's related: Relative motion is inherently dependent on the observer's frame of reference. Understanding that all motion is observed relative to some point (or observer) is the philosophical core of relative velocity.

    • JEE/CBSE relevance: A conceptual understanding of frames of reference is important for both, especially when interpreting problem statements.




  • Basic Kinematic Equations for Uniformly Accelerated Motion (1D):

    • Why it's related: While relative velocity often involves constant velocities, relative acceleration is also a concept. You might need to apply the standard kinematic equations (e.g., v = u + at, s = ut + Β½atΒ²) using relative velocities or accelerations in more advanced problems.

    • JEE relevance: Essential for problems involving objects with varying relative speeds due to acceleration.





Extensions and Applications of Relative Velocity


Once you master 1D relative velocity, you can naturally extend your understanding to these topics:




  • Relative Velocity in Two Dimensions:

    • Why it's related: This is the direct generalization. Concepts learned in 1D (vector subtraction, frame transformation) are directly applied, but now with components along x and y axes.

    • JEE/CBSE relevance: Crucial for JEE Main, as it forms the basis for complex problems. CBSE also covers basic 2D relative motion.




  • River-Boat Problems:

    • Why it's related: A classic application of relative velocity in two dimensions. Here, the velocity of the boat relative to the water, and the velocity of the water relative to the ground, are vectorially combined.

    • JEE/CBSE relevance: A very common and important topic for both exams.




  • Rain-Man Problems:

    • Why it's related: Another classic application of 2D relative velocity, similar to river-boat problems, but involving the velocity of rain relative to the ground and the velocity of a man relative to the ground.

    • JEE/CBSE relevance: Frequently tested in JEE Main and sometimes in CBSE for conceptual clarity.




  • Collision Problems (Encounter/Overtake):

    • Why it's related: Relative velocity can significantly simplify problems where two objects are moving towards or away from each other, or one is overtaking the other. Calculating the relative velocity directly helps determine the time to collision or overtake without complex simultaneous equations.

    • JEE relevance: A common problem type in competitive exams where relative velocity offers an elegant solution.




By understanding these interconnected topics, you build a robust foundation for solving a wide range of kinematics problems efficiently and accurately.

⚠️ Common Exam Traps

Common Exam Traps in Relative Velocity (One Dimension)



Understanding relative velocity in one dimension is fundamental, but students frequently fall into specific traps during exams. Being aware of these common pitfalls can significantly improve accuracy and prevent loss of marks.


JEE & CBSE Relevance: These traps apply equally to both JEE Main and Board exams. JEE questions often embed these errors in more complex multi-step problems, making error detection crucial.


1. Sign Convention Errors


This is the most frequent and costly mistake.


  • The Trap: Failing to consistently define and use a positive direction for velocities. Students often treat all velocities as positive magnitudes, leading to incorrect calculations for relative velocity.


  • Example: If two objects are moving towards each other, say A moving right at 10 m/s and B moving left at 5 m/s. If right is taken as positive, VA = +10 m/s and VB = -5 m/s. The relative velocity VAB = VA - VB = (+10) - (-5) = +15 m/s. A common error is to calculate 10 - 5 = 5 m/s, or 10 + 5 = 15 m/s without proper sign consideration.


  • How to Avoid:

    • Always explicitly state your chosen positive direction (e.g., "Right is positive").

    • Assign appropriate signs (+ or -) to all given velocities according to this convention.

    • Substitute these signed values directly into the relative velocity formula.





2. Incorrect Identification of Observer and Observed


The order in which objects are mentioned in relative velocity problems matters.


  • The Trap: Confusing VAB (velocity of A relative to B) with VBA (velocity of B relative to A). Remember, VAB = VA - VB, whereas VBA = VB - VA. These are equal in magnitude but opposite in direction.


  • Example: If a question asks for "the velocity of train A as seen by a passenger in train B," it's asking for VAB. Students might mistakenly calculate VBA.


  • How to Avoid:

    • Clearly identify who is the "observer" and who is the "observed."

    • The formula is always V(observed) relative to (observer) = V(observed) - V(observer).





3. Ignoring Initial Separation/Positions


Many problems involve objects meeting or crossing.


  • The Trap: Focusing solely on relative velocity and forgetting to account for the initial distance separating the objects. For instance, calculating time to meet by just dividing the total distance an object travels by its velocity, rather than using initial separation and relative velocity.


  • Example: Two cars 100 km apart move towards each other with relative speed 30 km/h. Time to meet = Initial separation / Relative speed = 100 km / 30 km/h. A common error is to use individual speeds or just take 100 km as the distance for one car.


  • How to Avoid:

    • Always draw a simple diagram showing initial positions and directions of motion.

    • For meeting/crossing problems, use the concept that the relative displacement required for meeting is the initial separation between them.

    • Equation: Ξ”xrel = Vrel Γ— t. Here, Ξ”xrel is the initial separation.





4. Mistakes with Relative Acceleration (JEE Specific)


While most 1D relative velocity problems involve constant velocities, some JEE problems might introduce different accelerations.


  • The Trap: Assuming relative velocity is constant even when objects have different accelerations. If the accelerations are different, the relative velocity will change over time.


  • Example: If A has acceleration aA and B has acceleration aB, then the relative acceleration aAB = aA - aB. The relative velocity will then be VAB(t) = VAB(0) + aABt. Students might incorrectly use constant relative velocity equations.


  • How to Avoid:

    • Carefully read if accelerations are given and if they are different.

    • If aA β‰  aB, then relative acceleration exists, and kinematic equations for constant acceleration must be applied to the relative motion: Ξ”xrel = Vrel,0t + Β½ arelt2 and Vrel(t) = Vrel,0 + arelt.





By being mindful of these common traps and diligently applying correct conventions, you can significantly improve your problem-solving accuracy in relative velocity questions.

⭐ Key Takeaways

πŸš€ Key Takeaways: Relative Velocity in One Dimension πŸš€


Understanding relative velocity is fundamental to Kinematics. For motion in a straight line, it simplifies many complex problems. Here are the essential takeaways you must remember for both CBSE and JEE exams:




  • Definition: Relative velocity is the velocity of an object as observed from another moving (or stationary) object. It's essentially the velocity of one body with respect to another.

  • Core Formula (1D):

    • If $vec{V}_A$ is the velocity of object A and $vec{V}_B$ is the velocity of object B (both with respect to a common reference frame, usually the ground), then the velocity of A relative to B is:

      $vec{V}_{AB} = vec{V}_A - vec{V}_B$



    • Similarly, the velocity of B relative to A is:

      $vec{V}_{BA} = vec{V}_B - vec{V}_A$



    • Important: Notice that $vec{V}_{AB} = -vec{V}_{BA}$. This means if A appears to move east at 10 m/s relative to B, then B appears to move west at 10 m/s relative to A.



  • Sign Convention is CRUCIAL (1D):

    • In one dimension, velocity is a vector, and its direction is represented by a sign (e.g., + for right/up, - for left/down).

    • Always assign a consistent positive direction. For example, if velocity towards the right is positive (+), then velocity towards the left is negative (-).

    • Common Mistake: Forgetting to assign correct signs or inconsistently applying them leads to incorrect results.



  • Interpreting Relative Velocity:

    • If $V_{AB} > 0$, object A is moving in the positive direction relative to object B.

    • If $V_{AB} < 0$, object A is moving in the negative direction relative to object B.

    • If $V_{AB} = 0$, objects A and B are moving with the same velocity in the same direction, meaning their relative separation remains constant (they are effectively stationary with respect to each other).



  • Special Cases:

    • Objects moving in the Same Direction: If $V_A$ and $V_B$ are both positive (or both negative), then $V_{rel} = |V_A - V_B|$. The relative speed is the difference in their speeds.

    • Objects moving in Opposite Directions: If $V_A$ is positive and $V_B$ is negative (or vice-versa), then $V_{rel} = |V_A - (-V_B)| = |V_A + V_B|$. The relative speed is the sum of their speeds.



  • Applications in Problem Solving:

    • Meeting/Overtaking Problems: To find the time taken for two objects to meet or for one to overtake another, use the concept of relative displacement and relative velocity.

      Time = $frac{ ext{Initial Relative Separation}}{ ext{Relative Velocity}}$


      Make sure the relative velocity used is the velocity of approach or recession.

    • Minimum Distance: When objects are moving, relative velocity helps determine when they are closest or farthest apart in 1D (though more complex in 2D/3D).



  • JEE vs. CBSE Perspective:

    • CBSE: Focus is on direct application of the formula with proper sign convention and understanding meeting/overtaking scenarios.

    • JEE Main: Questions can involve more intricate scenarios, requiring a strong conceptual grasp of relative motion, often involving multiple phases of motion or changing velocities. The ability to switch between reference frames quickly is an advantage.




Remember, treating velocity as a vector (even in 1D, where signs matter) and consistently applying the chosen sign convention is the key to mastering relative velocity problems. Practice makes perfect!

🧩 Problem Solving Approach

Problem Solving Approach: Relative Velocity in One Dimension


Solving problems involving relative velocity in one dimension requires a systematic approach, especially in competitive exams like JEE. The key is consistent sign convention and a clear understanding of the observer's frame of reference.



Core Concept Review


Relative velocity of object A with respect to object B is given by:



  • Vector Form: $vec{V}_{AB} = vec{V}_A - vec{V}_B$

  • For one dimension, this simplifies to a scalar equation with appropriate signs: $V_{AB} = V_A - V_B$. Here, $V_A$ and $V_B$ are the velocities along a chosen axis, including their signs.



Step-by-Step Problem Solving Strategy




  1. Define a Positive Direction:

    • This is the most crucial first step. Choose one direction (e.g., right, East, upwards) as positive (+). The opposite direction will then be negative (-).

    • JEE Tip: Always draw a simple diagram indicating your chosen positive direction.




  2. Assign Velocities with Correct Signs:

    • Write down the given velocities of all objects involved, explicitly including their signs based on your chosen positive direction.

    • For example, if right is positive: a car moving right at 10 m/s is +10 m/s; a car moving left at 5 m/s is -5 m/s.




  3. Apply the Relative Velocity Formula:

    • Substitute the signed velocities into the formula $V_{observer\_A , w.r.t., B} = V_A - V_B$.

    • Remember, the object whose velocity is being observed is 'A', and the object from which it is observed (the observer) is 'B'.




  4. Interpret the Result:

    • The sign of the calculated relative velocity indicates its direction relative to the chosen positive axis.

    • A positive (+) result means object A is moving in your chosen positive direction relative to object B.

    • A negative (-) result means object A is moving in the opposite (negative) direction relative to object B.

    • The magnitude is the relative speed.





Key Considerations & JEE Specifics



  • Meeting/Crossing Problems: When two objects are moving towards each other, their relative speed is the sum of their individual speeds (magnitudes). When they are moving in the same direction, their relative speed is the difference of their individual speeds. Use the sign convention method for a fool-proof approach.

  • Relative Displacement & Time: For problems involving time to meet or cross, use relative velocity to find relative displacement or time.

    $Delta x_{AB} = V_{AB} imes Delta t$

  • JEE Callout: JEE problems often involve multiple stages of motion, scenarios where a third object (e.g., a bird flying between two trains) is involved, or require applying relative acceleration concepts if velocities are changing. The fundamental step-by-step approach remains the same; just apply it to each stage or pair of objects.

  • Consistency: Do not change your chosen positive direction midway through the problem!



Example


A car A is moving East at 20 m/s, and a car B is moving West at 15 m/s. What is the velocity of car A with respect to car B?



  1. Positive Direction: Let East be the positive direction (+).

  2. Assign Velocities:

    • $V_A = +20$ m/s (East)

    • $V_B = -15$ m/s (West)



  3. Apply Formula:

    • $V_{AB} = V_A - V_B = (+20) - (-15) = 20 + 15 = +35$ m/s



  4. Interpret Result:

    • The velocity of car A with respect to car B is +35 m/s. This means that from car B's perspective, car A is moving East (positive direction) at 35 m/s.




Mastering this systematic approach ensures accuracy and speed in competitive exams!


πŸ“ CBSE Focus Areas

For CBSE board examinations, a clear and fundamental understanding of relative velocity in one dimension is crucial. The focus is on conceptual clarity, correct application of basic formulas, and meticulous use of sign conventions. Direct derivations and straightforward numerical problems are commonly encountered.



Key Concepts and Formulas (CBSE Perspective)




  • Definition: Relative velocity is the velocity of an object observed from another moving frame of reference. It describes how fast one object appears to move with respect to another.


  • Formula: If object A has velocity $vec{v}_A$ and object B has velocity $vec{v}_B$, then the relative velocity of A with respect to B is given by:



    $vec{v}_{AB} = vec{v}_A - vec{v}_B$


    Similarly, the relative velocity of B with respect to A is $vec{v}_{BA} = vec{v}_B - vec{v}_A$.


  • Sign Conventions are Crucial: For one-dimensional motion, velocities are treated as scalars with positive or negative signs indicating direction.

    • First, designate a positive direction (e.g., rightwards, upwards).

    • Velocities in this designated direction are positive (+).

    • Velocities in the opposite direction are negative (-).

    • Example: If car A moves right at 10 m/s ($v_A = +10$ m/s) and car B moves left at 5 m/s ($v_B = -5$ m/s), then the relative velocity of A with respect to B is $v_{AB} = (+10) - (-5) = +15$ m/s.





Typical CBSE Problem Scenarios


CBSE questions often involve practical situations where a clear application of relative velocity helps in finding time or distance.




  • Objects Moving in the Same Direction: Problems where one object is chasing another. The relative velocity helps determine the time taken to catch up or the rate at which the distance between them changes.


  • Objects Moving in Opposite Directions: Calculate the effective speed at which two objects approach each other or move apart. The magnitude of relative velocity will be the sum of their individual speeds.


  • Train Problems: A classic CBSE scenario. Often, you'll need to calculate the time taken for one train to completely pass another. Remember that the relative distance to be covered in such cases is the sum of their lengths if they are considered extended bodies. If point objects, just the relative distance between their starting points.


  • CBSE Specific Tip: Always begin by drawing a simple diagram of the situation and explicitly marking your chosen positive direction. This minimizes sign errors.



Importance of Derivations


Unlike JEE, where derivations are less frequently asked in the main exam, CBSE board exams sometimes require you to derive basic kinematic equations or conceptually explain formulas like $vec{v}_{AB} = vec{v}_A - vec{v}_B$ using displacement arguments.



Distinction from JEE Approach


While the underlying physics is the same, the complexity and depth vary:




  • Simplicity: CBSE problems are generally more straightforward and directly test your foundational understanding.


  • No Complex Calculus: You will typically not encounter problems requiring advanced integration or differentiation for relative velocity calculations in CBSE.


  • Focus on Basics: Mastery of the core formulas and sign conventions is paramount for CBSE success, emphasizing the 'what' and 'how' rather than deeper analytical insights.



Exam Strategy for CBSE



  1. Read Carefully: Understand the reference frame and what quantity is being asked (velocity of A w.r.t. B or B w.r.t. A?).

  2. Define Positive Direction: Clearly choose and mark a positive direction for your calculations.

  3. Assign Signs: Correctly apply positive or negative signs to all given velocities based on your chosen direction.

  4. Apply Formula: Use $v_{rel} = v_{object} - v_{observer}$.

  5. Units and Answer: Ensure all units are consistent and provide your final answer with appropriate units.

πŸŽ“ JEE Focus Areas

Welcome to the JEE Focus Areas for Relative Velocity in One Dimension! This section emphasizes the critical concepts and problem-solving techniques essential for excelling in competitive exams like JEE Main and Advanced.



Key Concepts and Formulas



  • Definition: The relative velocity of object A with respect to object B (VAB) is the velocity with which object A appears to move when observed from object B. In essence, it's the velocity of A in the reference frame of B.

  • Fundamental Formula (1D):

    • VAB = VA - VB

    • Similarly, the relative velocity of B with respect to A is VBA = VB - VA = -VAB.

    • Here, VA and VB are the velocities of objects A and B, respectively, with respect to a common ground (or stationary) reference frame.



  • Relative Acceleration: If objects are accelerating, the concept extends:

    • aAB = aA - aB

    • This allows using kinematic equations in relative terms: Srel = Urelt + Β½ areltΒ², Vrel = Urel + arelt, etc.





Crucial for JEE: Sign Convention



  • In one-dimensional motion, direction is represented by the sign (+ or -). Consistent application of a sign convention is paramount.

  • Example: If right is positive (+), then left is negative (-).

    • If car A moves right at 10 m/s (VA = +10) and car B moves left at 5 m/s (VB = -5), then:

    • VAB = VA - VB = (+10) - (-5) = +15 m/s. (A appears to move right at 15 m/s relative to B).

    • VBA = VB - VA = (-5) - (+10) = -15 m/s. (B appears to move left at 15 m/s relative to A).





Common JEE Problem Scenarios


Understanding these scenarios simplifies complex problems:



  1. Bodies Moving in the Same Direction: If VA and VB have the same sign (e.g., both positive), the relative speed is |VA - VB|.

  2. Bodies Moving in Opposite Directions: If VA and VB have opposite signs, the relative speed of approach or separation is |VA - (-VB)| = |VA + VB|.

  3. Time to Meet/Overtake:

    • If two objects are initially separated by distance 'd' and are moving towards each other, the time to meet is t = d / |Vrel_approach|.

    • If one object is chasing another, the time to overtake is t = d / |Vrel_chase|. (Here, Vrel_chase is the relative velocity of the faster object with respect to the slower one).



  4. River-Boat Problems (1D):

    • Downstream: Vboat_ground = Vboat_water + Vwater_ground

    • Upstream: Vboat_ground = Vboat_water - Vwater_ground





JEE Advantage: Changing Reference Frame



  • Many problems become significantly simpler when solved from a relative reference frame. Instead of observing two moving bodies from the ground, imagine sitting on one of the bodies. The problem then reduces to observing the motion of a single object.

  • For instance, in a pursuit problem, if you sit on the object being chased, the chaser approaches you with its relative velocity, and you appear stationary. This simplifies the distance and time calculations.



JEE Tip: Always draw a clear diagram and establish your sign convention at the beginning of the problem. This prevents errors arising from incorrect directions. Don't just add/subtract magnitudes; always use the vector subtraction formula incorporating signs.

πŸ“Š AI Generation Metadata

AI Model: Gemini Full Parallel API Client
Status: AI Generated
Version: 1
Generated: Oct 22, 2025
🌐 Overview
Graham's law quantifies how fast gases spread (diffuse) or leak through pinholes (effuse): the rate varies inversely with the square root of molar mass. For gases A and B at the same T and P: Rate_A/Rate_B = √(M_B/M_A). Lighter gases move and spread faster; heavier ones are slower.
πŸ“š Fundamentals
Core: Rate ∝ vΜ„ ∝ 1/√M; comparative form: Rate_A/Rate_B = √(M_B/M_A). With densities at same T,P: Rate_A/Rate_B = √(d_B/d_A). For mixtures effusing: composition of effused gas is enriched in lighter species.
πŸ”¬ Deep Dive
From KE equality: Β½m_A v_AΒ² = Β½m_B v_BΒ² β‡’ v_A/v_B = √(m_B/m_A). Replace molecular mass by molar mass, tie average speed to diffusion/effusion rate; extend to effusion composition using partial pressures.
🎯 Shortcuts
β€œGraham flips it”: A over B on the left, B over A under the root. Heavier is a drag; square root tempers the effect.
πŸ’‘ Quick Tips
If one gas is 4Γ— heavier, it diffuses 2Γ— slower (√4). Time ratios invert rate ratios. For mixtures, initial effusate is richer in the lighter component.
🧠 Intuitive Understanding
At a fixed temperature, different gases share the same average kinetic energy (Β½mvΒ²). To keep KE equal, smaller m must have larger v. Hence Hβ‚‚ zips faster than Oβ‚‚; helium outruns xenon. Faster average speed β†’ faster diffusion/effusion rate.
🌍 Real World Applications
Isotope enrichment (UF₆ with ²³⁡U effuses slightly faster than ²³⁸U), helium leak detection, gas separation, mine safety monitoring of light combustible gases, tracer studies in ventilation and environmental flows.
πŸ”„ Common Analogies
Stadium exits: agile kids weave through the crowd faster than large adults. Race with equal energy: lighter runner has higher speed. These mirror mass–speed tradeoffs underlying Graham's law.
πŸ“‹ Prerequisites
KMT (KE∝T), computing molar mass from formulae, ratio algebra with square roots, partial pressure basics for mixtures.
πŸ”— Related Topics
Maxwell–Boltzmann speed distribution; ideal gas law; diffusion vs effusion; isotope separation principles; density relation d ∝ M at constant T,P.
⚠️ Common Exam Traps
Inverting the mass ratio; forgetting √; using atomic instead of molecular mass (e.g., O vs Oβ‚‚); mixing time with rate without inversion; ignoring that T,P must be comparable.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Lighter = faster (by √mass); careful with diatomic molar masses; density form is often convenient; time is inverse of rate so time ratios invert the mass ratio inside √.
🧩 Problem Solving Approach
Steps: 1) Identify the two gases and compute M_A, M_B (watch diatomics). 2) Write Rate_A/Rate_B = √(M_B/M_A). 3) Convert the given (distance, volume, moles, time) to rates if needed. 4) Solve for the unknown; sanity-check with β€œlighter should be faster.”
πŸ“ CBSE Focus Areas
State law, compute simple rate/mass ratios, and explain at a sentence level why lighter gases move faster from KE equality.
πŸŽ“ JEE Focus Areas
Effusion from mixtures (rate ∝ P_i/√M_i), cascade enrichment reasoning, multi-step problems combining PV=nRT for density with Graham's relation.

πŸ“Š AI Generation Metadata

Difficulty: Intermediate
Estimated Time: 75 mins
AI Model: ChatGPT 5 (Copilot Agent)
Status: AI Generated
Version: 1
Generated: Oct 22, 2025
🌐 Overview
Relative velocity describes the velocity of one object as measured from the reference frame of another object. In one-dimensional motion, relative velocity is the vector difference between the velocities of two objects. This concept is essential for understanding motion in non-inertial frames and solving collision/chase problems in kinematics. Understanding relative velocity bridges elementary kinematics with advanced concepts like transformations between reference frames and forms the foundation for special relativity. Critical for CBSE Class 11 physics and a frequent topic in IIT-JEE mechanics problems.
πŸ“š Fundamentals
Relative Velocity Definition: The velocity of object A with respect to (relative to) object B is:
( vec{v}_{A,rel} = vec{v}_A - vec{v}_B )

In one dimension, treating direction as sign (positive/negative):
( v_{A,rel} = v_A - v_B )

Key Property: Velocity of A relative to B is opposite to velocity of B relative to A:
( v_{A,rel} = -v_{B,rel} )
Or: ( vec{v}_{A,rel} + vec{v}_{B,rel} = 0 )

Relative Position and Displacement:
( x_{A,rel}(t) = x_A(t) - x_B(t) )
( Delta x_{A,rel} = Delta x_A - Delta x_B )

Relative Acceleration: Similarly,
( a_{A,rel} = a_A - a_B )

Reference Frame: Any motion is measured with respect to a chosen reference frame. Earth is typically the "ground frame" or "lab frame"; other objects define "moving frames."

Galilean Transformation (for non-relativistic speeds):
If object A has velocity ( v_A ) in lab frame and object B has velocity ( v_B ) in lab frame, then object A's velocity in B's frame is:
( v_{A}^{(B)} = v_A - v_B )
πŸ”¬ Deep Dive
Mathematical Framework: Treating one-dimensional motion with signed scalars, a reference frame is defined by an observer. If observer is at origin of ground frame (lab frame), positions are measured from lab origin. If observer moves with object B, then "B-frame" origin moves with velocity ( v_B ). In B's frame, all positions and velocities are shifted:

Position in B-frame: ( x'_A = x_A - x_B(t) ) (position of A relative to B)
Velocity in B-frame: ( v'_A = frac{dx'_A}{dt} = frac{dx_A}{dt} - frac{dx_B}{dt} = v_A - v_B )

For Uniform Motion (constant velocities): Relative velocity is constant, so relative position changes linearly:
( x_A(t) - x_B(t) = (x_{A,0} - x_{B,0}) + (v_A - v_B)t )

For Non-Uniform Motion: Relative acceleration exists, so relative motion can be analyzed using kinematic equations:
( v_{A,rel}(t) = v_{A,rel,0} + a_{A,rel} cdot t )
( x_{A,rel}(t) = x_{A,rel,0} + v_{A,rel,0} cdot t + frac{1}{2}a_{A,rel} t^2 )

Meeting/Collision Condition: Objects A and B meet when ( x_A = x_B ), i.e., ( x_{A,rel} = 0 ).

Time to Meet: If ( x_{A,rel,0} = d ) (initial separation, with A behind B):
- If accelerations equal (( a_A = a_B )), then ( a_{A,rel} = 0 ); meeting time is ( t = frac{d}{v_A - v_B} ) (if ( v_A > v_B ))
- If accelerations differ, use quadratic kinematic equation

Pursuit Problem: Object A chases object B. If A has higher constant velocity (( v_A > v_B )), A will eventually catch B. Time to catch:
( t = frac{ ext{initial separation}}{v_A - v_B} )

Closest Approach: If relative velocity becomes zero (objects momentarily have same velocity), minimum separation occurs. This happens when ( v_{A,rel} = 0 ), i.e., ( v_A(t) = v_B(t) ).

Example (Rain/Wind Relative Motion): If rain falls vertically downward at velocity ( v_r ) and wind blows horizontally at ( v_w ), a person moving horizontally at velocity ( v_p ) experiences relative rain velocity:
( vec{v}_{rain,rel} = vec{v}_{rain} - vec{v}_{person} = (v_w hat{i} - v_r hat{j}) - v_p hat{i} = (v_w - v_p)hat{i} - v_r hat{j} )

The rain appears to come at an angle; the umbrella must be tilted accordingly.
🎯 Shortcuts
Relative = "A minus B" (always the order matters). "V_A,rel = V_A - V_B." "Meeting: set x_A = x_B." "Closest approach: v_A,rel = 0."
πŸ’‘ Quick Tips
Always define reference frame clearly. Sign matters: positive relative velocity means approaching; negative means receding (or vice versa depending on setup). For pursuit problems with constant velocities, relative velocity is constant; use simple proportion ( t = d / v_{rel} ). If velocities are in different directions, use vector subtraction. For time to meet, ensure ( v_A
eq v_B ); otherwise they never meet (parallel motion).
🧠 Intuitive Understanding
Imagine two cars on a highway. From a stationary observer, car A travels at 80 km/h and car B at 60 km/h. From car B's perspective (moving at 60 km/h), car A appears to approach at only 20 km/h. From car A's perspective, car B recedes at 20 km/h. Relative velocity captures motion as "seen" from a moving observer. If you're on a train moving at 60 km/h and another train passes at 80 km/h, that other train's relative velocity to you is 20 km/h.
🌍 Real World Applications
Air Traffic Control: calculating relative velocities of aircraft to avoid collisions; determining closest approach distances. Highway Safety: relative velocity between vehicles for safe following distances. Athletics: runners chasing one another, calculating when one overtakes another. Astronomy: relative motion of planets, moons, and satellites; recession velocities of galaxies. Naval/Maritime: relative velocities between ships for collision avoidance and docking. Relativistic Physics: foundation for special relativity (Galilean transformation becomes Lorentz transformation at high speeds). Navigation: GPS systems account for relative motion of receiver and satellites.Air Traffic Control: calculating relative velocities of aircraft to avoid collisions; determining closest approach distances. Highway Safety: relative velocity between vehicles for safe following distances. Athletics: runners chasing one another, calculating when one overtakes another. Astronomy: relative motion of planets, moons, and satellites; recession velocities of galaxies. Naval/Maritime: relative velocities between ships for collision avoidance and docking. Relativistic Physics: foundation for special relativity (Galilean transformation becomes Lorentz transformation at high speeds). Navigation: GPS systems account for relative motion of receiver and satellites.
πŸ”„ Common Analogies
Think of relative velocity like a train's perspective. From inside a moving train, the ground seems to move backward. The train's motion "adds to" or "subtracts from" ground velocities depending on direction. From the train's frame, other objects' velocities are shifted by the train's velocity.Think of relative velocity like a train's perspective. From inside a moving train, the ground seems to move backward. The train's motion "adds to" or "subtracts from" ground velocities depending on direction. From the train's frame, other objects' velocities are shifted by the train's velocity.
πŸ“‹ Prerequisites
One-dimensional kinematics, velocity and acceleration concepts, vector subtraction, reference frames (basic understanding), scalar and vector quantities, signed scalars on number line.
πŸ”— Related Topics
Velocity and Speed, Acceleration, Kinematics in One Dimension, Reference Frames, Galilean Transformation, Relative Motion in 2D/3D, Projectile Motion, Collision and Separation Problems, Non-inertial Frames, Special Relativity (Lorentz Transformation)
⚠️ Common Exam Traps
Forgetting to subtract velocities correctly; using addition instead of subtraction. Sign errors: not carefully tracking positive/negative directions. Confusing "relative to B" with "relative to ground." Assuming meeting happens when one object catches velocity of other (incorrect; meeting is position, not velocity). Not recognizing that relative velocity is symmetric but opposite: ( v_{A,rel} = -v_{B,rel} ). Time to meet formula wrong: using ( t = d / (v_A + v_B) ) instead of difference. Assuming objects always meet (they don't if slower object is ahead and faster is behind).
⭐ Key Takeaways
Relative velocity ( v_{A,rel} = v_A - v_B ). Direction matters: positive or negative. Relative velocity of B with respect to A is opposite: ( v_{B,rel} = -v_{A,rel} ). For collision/meeting: set ( x_A = x_B ). Time to meet (constant velocities, A behind B): ( t = frac{d}{v_A - v_B} ) if ( v_A > v_B ). Relative acceleration follows same rule: ( a_{A,rel} = a_A - a_B ). Closest approach when relative velocity = 0. Relative velocity ( v_{A,rel} = v_A - v_B ). Direction matters: positive or negative. Relative velocity of B with respect to A is opposite: ( v_{B,rel} = -v_{A,rel} ). For collision/meeting: set ( x_A = x_B ). Time to meet (constant velocities, A behind B): ( t = frac{d}{v_A - v_B} ) if ( v_A > v_B ). Relative acceleration follows same rule: ( a_{A,rel} = a_A - a_B ). Closest approach when relative velocity = 0.
🧩 Problem Solving Approach
Step 1: Identify two objects and choose a reference frame (usually lab frame or one object's frame). Step 2: Write velocities of both objects in that frame. Step 3: Calculate relative velocity as difference. Step 4: For pursuit/collision, set up relative position equation. Step 5: For constant velocities, use ( Delta x = v Delta t ) in relative frame. Step 6: For accelerations, apply kinematic equations to relative motion. Step 7: Interpret answer in context (time to meet, separation distance, etc.).
πŸ“ CBSE Focus Areas
Definition of relative velocity. Calculating relative velocity given velocities of two objects. Relative velocity in same direction (both moving same way) vs. opposite directions. Motion of object A as seen from object B's reference frame. Pursuit and collision problems with constant velocities. Time to meet calculation. Relative displacement and separation distance. Simple one-dimensional applications.
πŸŽ“ JEE Focus Areas
Relative velocity with non-uniform acceleration. Closest approach calculations (finding minimum separation distance). Reference frame transformations and Galilean invariance. Relative position and velocity equations for complex multi-stage problems. Constraint-based relative motion (e.g., connected objects). Rain/wind relative velocity problems (2D extension). Relative motion in rotating frames (introduction to centrifugal effects). Derivation of relative acceleration from forces in different frames. Applications to collision problems with acceleration. Minimum distance between trajectories using calculus.

πŸ“Š AI Generation Metadata

Difficulty: Intermediate
Estimated Time: 40 mins
AI Model: Claude Haiku 4.5 (Preview)
Status: AI Generated
Version: 1
Generated: Oct 18, 2025

πŸ“CBSE 12th Board Problems (19)

Problem 247
Easy 2 Marks
Two cars, A and B, are moving on a straight road in the same direction. Car A is moving at a speed of 60 km/h and Car B is moving at a speed of 40 km/h. Calculate the relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B.
Show Solution
1. Define a positive direction. Let the direction of motion be positive.<br/>2. Assign velocities with appropriate signs: V_A = +60 km/h, V_B = +40 km/h.<br/>3. Use the formula for relative velocity: V_AB = V_A - V_B.<br/>4. Substitute the values and calculate.
Final Answer: 20 km/h in the direction of motion.
Problem 248
Easy 3 Marks
Train P is moving eastward at a speed of 70 km/h. Train Q is moving westward on a parallel track at a speed of 50 km/h. Find the relative velocity of Train P with respect to Train Q.
Show Solution
1. Define a positive direction. Let East be positive.<br/>2. Assign velocities with appropriate signs: V_P = +70 km/h, V_Q = -50 km/h.<br/>3. Use the formula for relative velocity: V_PQ = V_P - V_Q.<br/>4. Substitute the values and calculate.
Final Answer: 120 km/h eastward.
Problem 249
Easy 2 Marks
A car is traveling northward at a constant speed of 50 km/h. A tree is observed on the side of the road. Calculate:<br/>(a) The velocity of the car with respect to the tree.<br/>(b) The velocity of the tree with respect to the car.
Show Solution
1. Define North as the positive direction.<br/>2. Assign velocities: V_C = +50 km/h, V_T = 0 km/h.<br/>3. For (a), use V_CT = V_C - V_T.<br/>4. For (b), use V_TC = V_T - V_C.<br/>5. Calculate both values.
Final Answer: (a) 50 km/h North<br/>(b) 50 km/h South
Problem 250
Easy 2 Marks
An escalator is moving upwards at a constant speed of 2 m/s relative to the ground. A person walks up the escalator at a speed of 1 m/s relative to the escalator. What is the velocity of the person relative to the ground?
Show Solution
1. Define upwards as the positive direction.<br/>2. Assign velocities with appropriate signs: V_E,G = +2 m/s, V_P,E = +1 m/s.<br/>3. Use the relative velocity addition formula: V_P,G = V_P,E + V_E,G.<br/>4. Substitute values and calculate.
Final Answer: 3 m/s upwards.
Problem 251
Easy 3 Marks
Two cars, X and Y, are initially moving in the same direction. Car X moves East at 50 km/h and Car Y moves East at 30 km/h. At a certain point, Car Y reverses its direction and starts moving West at 30 km/h, while Car X continues to move East at 50 km/h. Calculate the relative velocity of Car X with respect to Car Y after Car Y reverses its direction.
Show Solution
1. Define East as the positive direction.<br/>2. Assign velocities with appropriate signs after Car Y reverses: V_X = +50 km/h, V_Y = -30 km/h.<br/>3. Use the formula for relative velocity: V_XY = V_X - V_Y.<br/>4. Substitute the values and calculate.
Final Answer: 80 km/h East.
Problem 252
Easy 3 Marks
A boat is moving in a river. The velocity of the boat with respect to still water is 10 km/h. The velocity of the river water is 2 km/h. Calculate the velocity of the boat with respect to the river bank when:<br/>(a) The boat moves downstream (in the direction of the current).<br/>(b) The boat moves upstream (against the direction of the current).
Show Solution
1. Define a positive direction (e.g., downstream).<br/>2. For (a), add velocities: V_B,R = V_B,W + V_W,B (same direction).<br/>3. For (b), subtract velocities: V_B,R = V_B,W - V_W,B (opposite direction).<br/>4. Calculate both values.
Final Answer: (a) 12 km/h downstream<br/>(b) 8 km/h upstream
Problem 253
Medium 2 Marks
Car A is moving at a speed of 60 km/h in the easterly direction. Car B is moving on the same road in the same direction at a speed of 40 km/h. Calculate the relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B.
Show Solution
1. Define a positive direction. Let East be the positive direction. 2. Apply the formula for relative velocity: vAB = vA - vB. 3. Substitute the given values and calculate.
Final Answer: 20 km/h (East)
Problem 254
Medium 3 Marks
Two trains, one 100 m long and the other 150 m long, are moving towards each other on parallel tracks. Their speeds are 54 km/h and 36 km/h respectively. How long will it take for them to completely cross each other?
Show Solution
1. Convert speeds from km/h to m/s. 2. Calculate the relative speed of the trains (since they are moving towards each other, their speeds add up). 3. Determine the total distance to be covered for complete crossing (sum of their lengths). 4. Use the formula: Time = Total Distance / Relative Speed.
Final Answer: 10 seconds
Problem 255
Hard 3 Marks
A man is standing on a moving escalator that is going up at a constant speed of 2 m/s. The man walks up the escalator at a speed of 1.5 m/s relative to the escalator. The escalator is 40 m long.
Show Solution
1. **(i) Man walks up the escalator:** The escalator is moving up, and the man walks up relative to the escalator in the same direction. Speed of man relative to ground (v_m) = v_m_e + v_e = 1.5 m/s + 2 m/s = 3.5 m/s. Time taken (t_up) = Length of escalator / v_m = 40 m / 3.5 m/s = 80/7 s β‰ˆ 11.43 s. 2. **(ii) Man walks down the escalator:** The escalator is still moving up (2 m/s), but the man walks down relative to the escalator (1.5 m/s). Speed of man relative to ground (v'_m) = v_m_e (down) + v_e (up) = -1.5 m/s + 2 m/s = 0.5 m/s (upwards). Since the effective speed of the man relative to the ground is still upwards (0.5 m/s), he will eventually reach the top, not the bottom. This implies a condition for reaching the bottom: the man's speed relative to the escalator must be greater than the escalator's speed, and in the opposite direction. If the question means 'how long would it take if the man wanted to reach the bottom, assuming he eventually reaches it' then the effective speed of the man is 0.5 m/s upwards, so he will never reach the bottom. He will reach the top. Time taken to reach top = 40 / 0.5 = 80s. Let's assume the intent is for the man to reach the bottom. For that, his speed relative to the escalator must be greater than the escalator's speed (1.5 m/s) and he should walk 'down' such that his effective speed is downwards. If the question implies 'man walks down, and escalator is going up, what time to reach bottom assuming he is at top initially'. This scenario is not physically possible to reach bottom if v_m_e < v_e. Let's re-interpret part (ii) as: 'If the man walks down the escalator (moving up), what is his effective speed and will he reach the bottom?' Effective speed = 2 m/s (up) - 1.5 m/s (down) = 0.5 m/s (up). So he will move upwards and reach the top. If the question *implies* he somehow gets to the bottom, it's ill-posed. A hard question for CBSE means it could have a trick. The trick here is that if his downward speed (relative to escalator) is less than the escalator's upward speed, he will still effectively move upwards relative to the ground. He will not reach the bottom. So, the time to reach the bottom is undefined or impossible under these conditions.
Final Answer: (i) 11.43 s (approx). (ii) The man will not reach the bottom; he will continue to move upwards and reach the top.
Problem 255
Hard 4 Marks
A train A of length 180 m is moving at a speed of 20 m/s. Another train B of length 120 m is moving in the same direction as A at a speed of 10 m/s. A bird starts flying from the front end of train A towards the front end of train B at a constant speed of 30 m/s (relative to ground). As soon as it reaches the front end of B, it immediately turns back and flies towards the front end of A, again at 30 m/s. It continues this until A completely overtakes B.
Show Solution
1. **(i) Time taken for train A to completely overtake train B:** Relative velocity of A with respect to B (v_rel_AB) = v_A - v_B = 20 m/s - 10 m/s = 10 m/s. For A to completely overtake B, the relative distance to be covered is the sum of their lengths: L_total = L_A + L_B = 180 m + 120 m = 300 m. Time (t) = L_total / v_rel_AB = 300 m / 10 m/s = 30 s. 2. **(ii) Total distance covered by the bird:** The bird flies continuously for the entire duration 't' until A overtakes B. Total distance covered by bird (D_bird) = v_bird * t = 30 m/s * 30 s = 900 m. 3. **(iii) Average speed of the bird:** Average speed is always (Total Distance) / (Total Time). Average speed of bird = D_bird / t = 900 m / 30 s = 30 m/s. (This is trivially its given constant speed, as speed is distance/time and it's constant throughout).
Final Answer: (i) 30 s (ii) 900 m (iii) 30 m/s
Problem 255
Hard 3 Marks
A police jeep is chasing a culprit's car on a straight highway. The jeep is moving at 40 m/s and the car at 25 m/s. At a certain instant, the jeep is 800 m behind the car. The police driver observes a stationary pedestrian standing on the road 400 m ahead of the culprit's car.
Show Solution
1. **(i) Time for the police jeep to reach the pedestrian:** The pedestrian is stationary (v_P = 0). The police jeep is moving at 40 m/s. First, find the initial position of the pedestrian relative to the jeep. Initial separation (Jeep to Car) = 800 m. Distance (Car to Pedestrian) = 400 m. So, initial distance (Jeep to Pedestrian) = 800 m + 400 m = 1200 m. Time taken for jeep to reach pedestrian (t) = Distance / Speed of jeep = 1200 m / 40 m/s = 30 s. 2. **(ii) Relative velocity of jeep with respect to the pedestrian:** The pedestrian is stationary, so v_P = 0. The velocity of the jeep is v_J = 40 m/s. Relative velocity (v_JP) = v_J - v_P = 40 m/s - 0 m/s = 40 m/s.
Final Answer: (i) 30 s (ii) 40 m/s
Problem 255
Hard 4 Marks
Two cars, C1 and C2, are on a straight road. C1 is initially at position x=0 and moves with a constant velocity of 20 m/s. C2 is initially at position x=100 m and moves with a constant velocity of 10 m/s in the same direction as C1.
Show Solution
1. (i) When C1 overtakes C2, their positions will be the same. Equation of motion for C1: x_1(t) = x_1_0 + v_1*t = 0 + 20t = 20t. Equation of motion for C2: x_2(t) = x_2_0 + v_2*t = 100 + 10t. Set x_1(t) = x_2(t): 20t = 100 + 10t 10t = 100 t = 10 s. Position of overtaking: x = 20 * 10 = 200 m. 2. (ii) First, calculate positions and velocities at t=5 s. Position of C1 at t=5s: x_1(5) = 20 * 5 = 100 m. Position of C2 at t=5s: x_2(5) = 100 + 10 * 5 = 150 m. At t=5s, C2 increases its velocity to v'_2 = 25 m/s. Now, let t' be the time elapsed *after* t=5s (i.e., t' = t - 5). New initial position for C1 (at t'=0) = 100 m. Velocity of C1 = 20 m/s. New initial position for C2 (at t'=0) = 150 m. Velocity of C2 = 25 m/s. Equation of motion for C1: x_1(t') = 100 + 20t'. Equation of motion for C2: x_2(t') = 150 + 25t'. Now, C2 is faster than C1. So C1 will *never* overtake C2 if they continue like this. This is a trick question/scenario. If the question implies 'from this point onwards, when C1 *would have* overtaken C2 if speeds didn't change'. But the question is direct: 'when C1 overtakes C2'. Since v1 (20 m/s) < v2' (25 m/s), C1 will not overtake C2. Instead, C2 will pull further ahead. Therefore, C1 will never overtake C2 under these new conditions.
Final Answer: (i) C1 overtakes C2 at t = 10 s, at x = 200 m. (ii) C1 will never overtake C2 under the new conditions.
Problem 255
Hard 3 Marks
Two boys, P and Q, are standing 150 m apart. P starts running towards Q at 6 m/s. At the same instant, Q starts running away from P at 4 m/s. A bird starts flying from P towards Q at 15 m/s. When it reaches Q, it immediately turns back and flies towards P. This continues until P catches Q.
Show Solution
1. To find the time taken for P to catch Q, consider their relative motion. P is chasing Q. Relative velocity of P with respect to Q (v_rel_PQ) = v_P - v_Q = 6 m/s - 4 m/s = 2 m/s. Time taken (t) = Initial separation / v_rel_PQ = 150 m / 2 m/s = 75 s. 2. The bird flies continuously during this entire time 't'. Total distance covered by the bird (D_bird) = Speed of bird * Total time = 15 m/s * 75 s = 1125 m.
Final Answer: (i) 75 s (ii) 1125 m
Problem 255
Hard 5 Marks
A car A is moving at a constant speed of 30 m/s on a straight highway. Another car B is 120 m ahead of A and moving in the same direction at a constant speed of 20 m/s. The driver of car A suddenly observes car B applying brakes (decelerating uniformly at 5 m/sΒ²). The driver of A has a reaction time of 0.6 s.
Show Solution
1. **During reaction time (0.6 s):** Distance covered by A (d_A_react) = u_A * t_reaction = 30 * 0.6 = 18 m. Distance covered by B (d_B_react) = u_B * t_reaction = 20 * 0.6 = 12 m. Relative distance between A and B after reaction time = (120 + 12) - 18 = 114 m. Speed of A remains 30 m/s. Speed of B remains 20 m/s (as B started braking at t=0, so its speed changes after t=0). Let's rephrase: B starts braking *at the moment* A's driver sees it. So B's velocity changes immediately. Revised approach: Let t=0 be the instant A's driver sees B braking. Initial relative distance, x_rel = 120 m. Relative velocity, v_rel = v_A - v_B = 30 - 20 = 10 m/s. **Phase 1: During A's reaction time (0.6 s):** Car A moves at 30 m/s. Car B decelerates from 20 m/s at -5 m/s^2. Displacement of A: Ξ”x_A = 30 * 0.6 = 18 m. Displacement of B: Ξ”x_B = u_B * t_reaction + (1/2) * a_B * t_reaction^2 = 20 * 0.6 + (1/2) * (-5) * (0.6)^2 = 12 - 0.9 = 11.1 m. New separation = 120 + Ξ”x_B - Ξ”x_A = 120 + 11.1 - 18 = 113.1 m. Speed of A (at t=0.6s) = 30 m/s. Speed of B (at t=0.6s) = 20 + (-5) * 0.6 = 20 - 3 = 17 m/s. **Phase 2: After reaction time, A also brakes.** New initial relative distance = 113.1 m. New initial relative velocity (u'_rel) = v_A - v_B = 30 - 17 = 13 m/s. Relative acceleration (a_rel) = a_A - a_B = a_A - (-5) = a_A + 5. To avoid collision, the relative displacement should be less than the initial relative distance, or when v'_rel = 0, the relative displacement must be <= 113.1m. Using v'^2 = u'^2 + 2 * a_rel * x_rel (where v'=0 for minimum collision distance): 0 = (13)^2 + 2 * (a_A + 5) * x_rel_stop. For no collision, x_rel_stop must be <= 113.1 m. The smallest braking distance for A would be if relative final velocity is 0. Relative displacement (Ξ”x_rel) = (0^2 - u'_rel^2) / (2 * a_rel) = (-13^2) / (2 * (a_A + 5)). We need a_rel to be negative for A to decelerate relative to B's changing speed. So a_A must be negative. Let a_A be the magnitude of deceleration of A, so actual acceleration is -a_A. a_rel = -a_A - (-5) = 5 - a_A. For A to avoid collision, it must decelerate *more* than B effectively. 0^2 = (13)^2 + 2 * (5 - a_A) * x_rel_stop. For minimum deceleration, A must stop just at B's position. So x_rel_stop = 113.1 m. 169 = 2 * (a_A - 5) * 113.1 (The sign for a_rel is tricky. If relative velocity is positive (A faster), relative acceleration must be negative to reduce it). So, a_rel = a_A - a_B. If A decelerates, its 'a_A' is negative. So, a_rel = (-a_A_mag) - (-5) = 5 - a_A_mag. 0 = (13)^2 + 2 * (5 - a_A_mag) * 113.1. 2 * (5 - a_A_mag) = -169 / 113.1 β‰ˆ -1.494. 5 - a_A_mag β‰ˆ -0.747. a_A_mag β‰ˆ 5 + 0.747 = 5.747 m/sΒ². (ii) If a_A_mag = 4 m/sΒ²: a_rel = 5 - 4 = 1 m/sΒ² (positive relative acceleration, meaning A is *still gaining* on B). Since the relative acceleration is positive, and A is already faster than B, A will definitely collide. Or, using the formula for distance covered to relative stop: If a_A = -4 m/s^2, then a_rel = -4 - (-5) = 1 m/s^2. Since u_rel = 13 m/s, and a_rel = 1 m/s^2, the relative velocity will increase, meaning A will always catch up to B faster than B is slowing down. Thus, collision will occur.
Final Answer: (i) Minimum deceleration for A β‰ˆ 5.75 m/sΒ². (ii) Yes, a collision will occur.
Problem 255
Hard 3 Marks
Two trains, A and B, of lengths 120 m and 80 m respectively, are moving on parallel tracks. Train A moves at a constant speed of 72 km/h, and Train B moves at a constant speed of 54 km/h.
Show Solution
1. Convert speeds from km/h to m/s. v_A = 72 * (5/18) = 20 m/s. v_B = 54 * (5/18) = 15 m/s. 2. Calculate the total relative distance to be covered for complete overtaking/crossing: L_total = L_A + L_B = 120 + 80 = 200 m. 3. Case (i): Same direction. Relative velocity (v_rel_same) = v_A - v_B = 20 - 15 = 5 m/s (assuming A is faster and behind B). Time (t_same) = L_total / v_rel_same = 200 m / 5 m/s = 40 s. 4. Case (ii): Opposite directions. Relative velocity (v_rel_opp) = v_A + v_B = 20 + 15 = 35 m/s. Time (t_opp) = L_total / v_rel_opp = 200 m / 35 m/s = 40/7 s β‰ˆ 5.71 s. 5. Relative speeds: (iii) Relative speed of A w.r.t B in same direction = 5 m/s. (iii) Relative speed of A w.r.t B in opposite direction = 35 m/s.
Final Answer: (i) 40 s (ii) 5.71 s (approx) (iii) 5 m/s (same direction), 35 m/s (opposite direction)
Problem 255
Medium 2 Marks
Two cars, P and Q, start from the same point at the same time and move in the same direction. Car P moves with a constant speed of 70 km/h and Car Q moves with a constant speed of 50 km/h. What is the distance between the two cars after 30 minutes?
Show Solution
1. Convert time from minutes to hours. 2. Calculate the relative speed of Car P with respect to Car Q. 3. Multiply the relative speed by the time to find the relative distance covered, which is the distance between them.
Final Answer: 10 km
Problem 255
Medium 3 Marks
A man is walking on a moving escalator at a speed of 1.5 m/s relative to the escalator. If the escalator itself moves at 0.5 m/s relative to the ground, how long will it take the man to cover a distance of 40 m when he walks (a) in the direction of the escalator's motion, and (b) against the direction of the escalator's motion?
Show Solution
1. Calculate the man's effective speed relative to the ground for both cases (with and against the escalator). 2. Use the formula: Time = Distance / Speed.
Final Answer: (a) 20 s, (b) 40 s
Problem 255
Medium 3 Marks
A swimmer can swim at 4 m/s in still water. If the river flows at 2 m/s, calculate the swimmer's speed relative to the ground when he swims (a) downstream, and (b) upstream.
Show Solution
1. For downstream motion, the velocities add up. 2. For upstream motion, the river velocity opposes the swimmer's velocity, so they subtract.
Final Answer: (a) 6 m/s, (b) 2 m/s
Problem 255
Medium 3 Marks
A police car is chasing a speeding car. The police car is moving at 90 km/h and the speeding car is at 72 km/h. If the police car is initially 500 m behind the speeding car, how long will it take for the police car to catch the speeding car?
Show Solution
1. Convert speeds from km/h to m/s. 2. Calculate the relative speed of the police car with respect to the speeding car. 3. Use the formula: Time = Initial Distance / Relative Speed.
Final Answer: 100 seconds

🎯IIT-JEE Main Problems (12)

Problem 255
Easy 4 Marks
Car A moves at 30 m/s and Car B moves at 20 m/s in the same direction. What is the relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B?
Show Solution
1. Define a coordinate system; let the direction of motion be positive. 2. Both cars are moving in the same direction. 3. The formula for relative velocity of A with respect to B is $V_{AB} = V_A - V_B$. 4. Substitute the given values: $V_{AB} = 30 ext{ m/s} - 20 ext{ m/s}$. 5. Calculate the result.
Final Answer: 10 m/s
Problem 255
Easy 4 Marks
Two trains, Train P and Train Q, are moving on parallel tracks towards each other. Train P has a speed of 15 m/s and Train Q has a speed of 10 m/s. What is the relative speed of Train P with respect to Train Q?
Show Solution
1. Define a positive direction. Let Train P move in the positive direction and Train Q in the negative direction. 2. Velocity of Train P ($V_P$) = +15 m/s. Velocity of Train Q ($V_Q$) = -10 m/s. 3. The relative velocity of P with respect to Q is $V_{PQ} = V_P - V_Q$. 4. Substitute the values: $V_{PQ} = (+15 ext{ m/s}) - (-10 ext{ m/s})$. 5. Calculate the result and take its magnitude for relative speed.
Final Answer: 25 m/s
Problem 255
Easy 4 Marks
A car is moving at 10 m/s. A motorcycle 100 m behind it starts moving in the same direction at 20 m/s. How much time will it take for the motorcycle to overtake the car?
Show Solution
1. Calculate the relative velocity of the motorcycle with respect to the car. Since they are moving in the same direction, $V_{rel} = V_M - V_C$. 2. The distance to be covered by the motorcycle relative to the car is the initial separation. 3. Use the formula: Time = Distance / Relative Velocity ($t = D / V_{rel}$).
Final Answer: 10 s
Problem 255
Easy 4 Marks
A man can walk at 2 m/s on a stationary escalator. If the escalator itself moves upwards at 1 m/s, how fast will the man move relative to the ground if he walks upwards on the moving escalator?
Show Solution
1. Identify the reference frames: man, escalator, ground. 2. Apply the relative velocity formula: $V_{man, ground} = V_{man, escalator} + V_{escalator, ground}$. 3. Substitute the given values and sum them up.
Final Answer: 3 m/s
Problem 255
Easy 4 Marks
Two particles A and B start from the same point and move in opposite directions along a straight line. Particle A moves at 5 m/s and Particle B moves at 7 m/s. What is the distance between them after 5 seconds?
Show Solution
1. Calculate the relative speed of the two particles. Since they move in opposite directions, the relative speed is the sum of their individual speeds. 2. Use the formula: Distance = Relative Speed Γ— Time.
Final Answer: 60 m
Problem 255
Easy 4 Marks
A boat travels downstream in a river. The speed of the boat in still water is 10 km/h and the speed of the river current is 2 km/h. What is the speed of the boat relative to the river bank?
Show Solution
1. Identify the two velocities involved: boat relative to water and water relative to bank. 2. For downstream motion, the velocities add up. 3. Apply the relative velocity formula: $V_{boat, bank} = V_{boat, water} + V_{water, bank}$. 4. Substitute the given values and sum them up.
Final Answer: 12 km/h
Problem 255
Medium 4 Marks
A train A of length 120 m is moving with a speed of 10 m/s in one direction. Another train B of length 130 m is moving with a speed of 15 m/s in the opposite direction on a parallel track. What is the time (in seconds) taken for train B to completely cross train A?
Show Solution
Calculate the total distance to be covered for complete crossing, which is the sum of the lengths of the two trains. Determine the relative speed of the trains. Since they are moving in opposite directions, their speeds add up. Divide the total distance by the relative speed to find the time taken.
Final Answer: 10
Problem 255
Medium 4 Marks
Two particles P and Q are initially 100 m apart. P starts moving towards Q with a constant speed of 10 m/s. 2 seconds later, Q starts moving towards P with a constant speed of 5 m/s. Find the time (in seconds) from the moment P started, when they meet.
Show Solution
Set up a coordinate system, e.g., P starts at origin. Write position equations for P and Q. Account for Q's delayed start. Equate their positions to find the time when they meet.
Final Answer: 7.33
Problem 255
Medium 4 Marks
Two buses, A and B, are moving in the same direction with speeds 30 km/h and 40 km/h respectively. Bus B is initially ahead of bus A by 10 km. What is the distance (in km) between them after 3 hours, assuming they maintain their speeds?
Show Solution
Calculate the relative speed of bus B with respect to bus A, as they are moving in the same direction. Calculate the change in separation over the given time using the relative speed. Add this change to the initial separation to find the final distance.
Final Answer: 40
Problem 255
Medium 4 Marks
A boat moves downstream in a river with a speed of 15 km/h relative to the bank and upstream with a speed of 9 km/h relative to the bank. What is the speed of the river current (in km/h)?
Show Solution
Formulate equations for downstream and upstream speeds in terms of boat's speed in still water (v_b) and current's speed (v_c). Solve the system of two linear equations to find v_c.
Final Answer: 3
Problem 255
Medium 4 Marks
Car A is initially at rest at the origin and starts accelerating at 2 m/sΒ². At the same instant, Car B is 75 m ahead of Car A and moves with a constant velocity of 10 m/s in the same direction as A. How much time (in seconds) does it take for Car A to overtake Car B?
Show Solution
Write down the position equation for Car A as a function of time. Write down the position equation for Car B as a function of time. Set the positions equal to each other to find the time of overtaking. Solve the resulting quadratic equation for time.
Final Answer: 15
Problem 255
Medium 4 Marks
A police car (P) starts from rest and accelerates at 4 m/sΒ². At the same instant, a thief's car (T) passes it with a constant speed of 20 m/s in the same direction. How far (in meters) will the police car travel before it catches the thief's car?
Show Solution
Write position equations for both the police car and the thief's car, assuming they start at the same origin at t=0. Equate their positions to find the time when the police car catches the thief's car. Substitute this time back into the police car's position equation to find the distance traveled by the police car.
Final Answer: 200

No videos available yet.

No images available yet.

πŸ“Important Formulas (3)

Relative Velocity ($v_{AB}$)
$v_{AB} = v_A - v_B$
Text: v_AB = v_A - v_B
<p>This fundamental formula defines the <strong>velocity of object A as perceived by an observer situated on object B</strong>. In one-dimensional motion, all velocities are vectors aligned along a single axis. It is crucial to adopt a consistent <strong>sign convention</strong>: for example, velocities directed to the right or upwards are positive, and those to the left or downwards are negative. This formula effectively describes how quickly the separation between A and B is changing.</p><ul><li><span style='color: #007bff;'><strong>Case 1: Same Direction</strong></span> (e.g., both moving right with $v_A, v_B > 0$): $v_{AB} = v_A - v_B$. The relative speed is the difference in their speeds.</li><li><span style='color: #007bff;'><strong>Case 2: Opposite Directions</strong></span> (e.g., A right $v_A > 0$, B left $v_B < 0$): $v_{AB} = v_A - v_B$. If $v_B = -|v_B|$, then $v_{AB} = v_A + |v_B|$. The relative speed is the sum of their speeds.</li></ul>
Variables: Use this to determine how one object moves relative to another. It is essential for problems involving objects meeting, overtaking, or calculating the time to separation/collision. It simplifies complex absolute motion problems into a simpler relative one.
Relative Position ($x_{AB}$)
$x_{AB} = x_A - x_B$
Text: x_AB = x_A - x_B
<p>This formula defines the <strong>position of object A as measured by an observer on object B</strong>. It represents the displacement of A from B. Like velocities, positions must adhere to a strict <strong>sign convention</strong> along the chosen one-dimensional axis. If $x_{AB}$ is positive, A is to the positive side of B; if negative, A is to the negative side of B.</p>
Variables: Primarily used to establish the initial relative displacement between two objects or to calculate the position of one object with respect to another at any given time. Often used in conjunction with relative velocity to predict meeting points.
Relative Acceleration ($a_{AB}$)
$a_{AB} = a_A - a_B$
Text: a_AB = a_A - a_B
<p>This formula gives the <strong>acceleration of object A as observed from the frame of reference of object B</strong>. In one dimension, similar to velocity and position, a consistent <strong>sign convention</strong> for acceleration must be applied (e.g., positive for acceleration in the positive direction, negative for acceleration in the negative direction). If object B is accelerating, its frame of reference is non-inertial.</p>
Variables: Applicable when objects are undergoing acceleration. This is crucial for solving problems where the relative velocity is not constant, and kinematics equations ($v = u + at$, $s = ut + frac{1}{2}at^2$) need to be applied in a relative frame.

πŸ“šReferences & Further Reading (10)

Book
Fundamentals of Physics
By: David Halliday, Robert Resnick, Jearl Walker
N/A
A globally recognized classic physics textbook providing a strong foundation in mechanics. It covers relative motion principles thoroughly, illustrating one-dimensional cases as foundational examples.
Note: Offers a rigorous conceptual understanding, valuable for students seeking a deeper insight into physics principles beyond just problem-solving. Good for fundamental understanding.
Book
By:
Website
Relative Velocity - One Dimensional Motion
By: Vedantu Learning App
https://www.vedantu.com/physics/relative-velocity
An online article that explains relative velocity in one dimension, covering definitions, formulas, and solved examples tailored for students preparing for competitive exams.
Note: Provides targeted explanations and solved problems, making it a good resource for JEE Main and advanced CBSE preparation.
Website
By:
PDF
3.5: Relative Motion in One Dimension (OpenStax University Physics I)
By: Physics LibreTexts (contributed by various authors)
https://phys.libretexts.org/@api/deki/files/42079/3_5_Relative_Motion_in_One_Dimension.pdf
A direct PDF download of a section from the open-source 'University Physics I' textbook, focusing exclusively on relative motion in one dimension with detailed derivations and examples.
Note: Excellent for detailed conceptual understanding and derivations, freely available in a concise PDF format.
PDF
By:
Article
Relative Motion - Concepts and Solved Problems
By: askIITians
https://www.askiitians.com/iit-jee-kinematics/relative-motion.html
An article designed for IIT JEE aspirants, covering the theoretical aspects of relative motion, including one-dimensional scenarios, formulas, and solved problems with a focus on competitive exam patterns.
Note: Directly relevant for JEE preparation, providing theory and problem-solving strategies specifically for relative motion in the context of competitive exams.
Article
By:
Research_Paper
Teaching Relative Motion Concept using a Physics-Oriented Programming Environment
By: I. E. Idriss, K. Y. Z. Abdou, M. E. Hamed
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/328225574_Teaching_Relative_Motion_Concept_using_a_Physics-Oriented_Programming_Environment
This research explores an innovative pedagogical approach using a programming environment to enhance students' understanding of relative motion, providing an alternative learning perspective for complex concepts.
Note: Relevant for students interested in advanced learning methods or educators exploring new ways to teach fundamental physics concepts like relative velocity. Less direct for exam problems but highlights conceptual clarity.
Research_Paper
By:

⚠️Common Mistakes to Avoid (60)

Minor Other

❌ <strong>Inconsistent Sign Convention and Misinterpretation of Reference Frames</strong>

Students often make errors by not consistently defining a positive direction or by incorrectly interpreting "velocity of A with respect to B". This leads to wrong signs in calculations, ultimately affecting the direction and sometimes even the magnitude of the relative velocity in one dimension.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake typically arises from:
  • Lack of a clear convention: Not explicitly stating or visualizing the chosen positive direction.
  • Haste: Rushing calculations and ignoring the vector nature of velocity.
  • Conceptual confusion: Not understanding that $V_{AB} = V_A - V_B$ (where $V_A$ and $V_B$ are velocities with respect to a common ground frame), and similarly for $V_{BA}$.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always follow these steps for relative velocity in one dimension:
  1. Establish a positive direction: Clearly define which direction (e.g., right, up) will be considered positive.
  2. Assign signs: Assign appropriate positive or negative signs to the velocities of all objects based on your chosen convention.
  3. Apply the formula: For the velocity of object A relative to object B ($V_{AB}$), use the formula $V_{AB} = V_A - V_B$. Remember that $V_{BA} = V_B - V_A = -V_{AB}$.

JEE Advanced Tip: Always draw a simple diagram indicating directions and chosen positive axis for clarity, especially in multi-object scenarios.

πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Car A moves at 10 m/s to the right. Car B moves at 5 m/s to the left. A student might incorrectly calculate the velocity of A relative to B as $10 - 5 = 5$ m/s, or simply add their magnitudes due to opposing directions, leading to $10 + 5 = 15$ m/s without considering the correct relative velocity formula and signs.
βœ… Correct:
Let's define right as the positive direction.
  • Velocity of Car A, $V_A = +10$ m/s (to the right).
  • Velocity of Car B, $V_B = -5$ m/s (to the left).
  • Velocity of A relative to B:
    $V_{AB} = V_A - V_B = (+10) - (-5) = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s.
    This means car A appears to move at 15 m/s to the right from the perspective of car B.
  • Velocity of B relative to A:
    $V_{BA} = V_B - V_A = (-5) - (+10) = -15 m/s.
    This means car B appears to move at 15 m/s to the left from the perspective of car A.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Standardize your convention: Always assume right or upward as positive unless specified otherwise, and stick to it throughout a problem.
  • Visualize and draw: A simple diagram with velocity vectors and the chosen positive axis can prevent sign errors.
  • Mentally check: Does the calculated relative velocity make sense? If two objects are moving towards each other, their relative speed (magnitude) will be the sum of their individual speeds. If they are moving in the same direction, it will be the difference.
JEE_Advanced
Minor Conceptual

❌ Incorrect Handling of Directional Signs in Relative Velocity

Students frequently make errors in applying the correct sign conventions for velocities when calculating relative velocity in one dimension. This often leads to incorrect magnitudes and directions, especially when objects are moving in opposite directions. They might treat velocities as scalar speeds, simply adding or subtracting magnitudes without considering their vector nature.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake stems from a weak conceptual understanding of vectors and coordinate systems. Students often grasp the formula VAB = VA - VB but fail to assign appropriate positive or negative signs to VA and VB based on a chosen positive direction. There's a tendency to confuse relative velocity with relative speed.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always define a clear positive direction (e.g., right, East, or along the positive x-axis). Assign positive values to velocities in this chosen positive direction and negative values to velocities in the opposite direction. Then, strictly apply the relative velocity formula as a vector subtraction: Vrelative = Vobserved - Vobserver, using the signed values for each velocity.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Problem: Car A moves right at 10 m/s. Car B moves left at 5 m/s. Find the velocity of A relative to B.
Wrong Approach:
1. Assuming relative velocity is always subtraction of magnitudes: VAB = 10 - 5 = 5 m/s.
2. Incorrectly adding magnitudes because they are moving towards each other: VAB = 10 + 5 = 15 m/s (often done if students think of 'closing speed').
βœ… Correct:
Problem: Car A moves right at 10 m/s. Car B moves left at 5 m/s. Find the velocity of A relative to B.
Correct Approach:
1. Choose the positive direction: Let right be positive (+x-axis).
2. Assign signed velocities:
VA = +10 m/s (moving right)
VB = -5 m/s (moving left)
3. Apply the relative velocity formula VAB = VA - VB:
VAB = (+10 m/s) - (-5 m/s) = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s.
This means car A appears to be moving to the right at 15 m/s as observed from car B.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Draw a Diagram: Always sketch a simple diagram to visualize the directions of motion.
  • Define Positive Direction: Explicitly state your chosen positive direction before solving.
  • Assign Signs First: Write down the velocities of all objects with their correct positive or negative signs.
  • Vector Subtraction: Remember that the relative velocity formula is a vector subtraction, and signs are integral to this operation.
JEE_Main
Minor Calculation

❌ Ignoring or Incorrectly Applying Sign Conventions in 1D Relative Velocity Calculations

A frequent error in JEE Main is the inconsistent or incorrect application of sign conventions when calculating relative velocity in one dimension. Students often treat velocities as magnitudes (speeds) rather than vectors, leading to incorrect addition or subtraction and consequently, a wrong magnitude or direction for the relative velocity. This is a common calculation understanding mistake.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake stems from a lack of establishing a clear and consistent positive direction, rushing calculations, or forgetting that relative velocity is a vector operation requiring careful algebraic subtraction of signed values. Students might instinctively just subtract smaller from larger values or add them, without considering directions.
βœ… Correct Approach:
  1. Establish a Consistent Sign Convention: Before starting, explicitly define one direction (e.g., right, east, upward) as positive (+) and the opposite as negative (-).
  2. Assign Signs to Velocities: Write down each given velocity (e.g., V_A, V_B) with its correct sign based on your chosen convention.
  3. Apply the Relative Velocity Formula: Use the appropriate formula, V_AB = V_A - V_B (velocity of A relative to B), performing the algebraic subtraction meticulously with the assigned signs.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Problem: Car A moves East at 30 m/s. Car B moves West at 20 m/s. Find the velocity of Car A relative to Car B (V_AB).
Wrong Calculation: A student might incorrectly calculate V_AB = 30 - 20 = 10 m/s, implicitly assuming both are in the same direction or simply subtracting magnitudes without considering the vector nature.
βœ… Correct:
Problem: Car A moves East at 30 m/s. Car B moves West at 20 m/s. Find the velocity of Car A relative to Car B (V_AB).
Correct Approach:
  • Let East be the positive (+) direction.
  • Velocity of Car A, V_A = +30 m/s (East)
  • Velocity of Car B, V_B = -20 m/s (West, opposite to positive direction)
  • Using the formula V_AB = V_A - V_B:
  • V_AB = (+30) - (-20) = 30 + 20 = +50 m/s.

Interpretation: Car A appears to move East at 50 m/s with respect to Car B. For CBSE and JEE Main, understanding this sign convention is fundamental.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always begin by explicitly stating your chosen positive direction. This sets a clear framework for all subsequent calculations.
  • Assign signs to every velocity term in the problem statement before substituting into any formula.
  • Be extra careful with double negatives during subtraction (e.g., A - (-B) becomes A + B).
  • Visualize the scenario: Imagine yourself on the reference object (e.g., Car B in the example) and consider how the other object (Car A) appears to move from your perspective.
JEE_Main
Minor Formula

❌ Ignoring Sign Conventions in One-Dimensional Relative Velocity

Students often treat velocities as scalar magnitudes rather than vectors when applying the relative velocity formula VAB = VA - VB in one dimension. This leads to incorrect addition or subtraction, as the direction (sign) of the velocities is overlooked.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This common mistake stems from not consistently defining a positive direction for the motion. When given problem statements, students might instinctively add magnitudes (e.g., if objects move towards each other) or subtract magnitudes, without first assigning appropriate positive or negative signs to each velocity based on a chosen coordinate system.
βœ… Correct Approach:
To correctly apply the relative velocity formula in one dimension, follow these steps:
  1. Define a Positive Direction: Clearly establish one direction (e.g., right, East, upwards) as positive. All velocities acting in this direction will be positive, and those in the opposite direction will be negative.
  2. Assign Signs to Individual Velocities: Before plugging values into the formula, ensure each velocity (VA, VB) is assigned its correct sign based on the chosen positive direction.
  3. Apply the Formula VAB = VA - VB: Substitute the signed velocities into the formula. The resulting sign of VAB will indicate the direction of A's velocity relative to B.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Car A moves right at 10 m/s. Car B moves left at 5 m/s. A student might incorrectly calculate VAB = 10 - 5 = 5 m/s, or even 10 + 5 = 15 m/s if they mistakenly think relative speed implies addition. The former treats B's speed as positive, ignoring its direction.
βœ… Correct:
Consider the same scenario: Car A moves right at 10 m/s. Car B moves left at 5 m/s.
1. Define right as the positive direction.
2. So, VA = +10 m/s (moving right).
3. And VB = -5 m/s (moving left, opposite to positive direction).
4. Now apply VAB = VA - VB = (+10 m/s) - (-5 m/s) = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s.
This means Car A appears to move to the right at 15 m/s relative to Car B.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always Draw: Sketch a simple diagram showing the objects and their velocity vectors.
  • Consistent Convention: Explicitly state your chosen positive direction at the beginning of the problem.
  • JEE Tip: Relative velocity in 1D is often a 'trap' for sign errors. Pay close attention to directions when setting up your equations.
JEE_Main
Minor Unit Conversion

❌ Inconsistent Unit Usage in Calculations

Students often make the mistake of using quantities with different units (e.g., velocity in km/h and time in seconds, or distance in km and velocity in m/s) directly in formulas for relative velocity problems. This leads to incorrect numerical answers.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This error primarily stems from a lack of careful attention to units given in the problem statement. Students might rush, assume all values are already in SI units, or forget to convert all quantities to a single, consistent unit system before performing calculations. Sometimes, confusion between SI and non-SI units (like km/h) also contributes.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always convert all given physical quantities to a single, consistent system of units (preferably the SI system: meters, seconds, kg) *before* substituting them into any formula or performing calculations. For relative velocity, ensure all velocities are in m/s, all distances in meters, and all times in seconds.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Two trains are moving towards each other on parallel tracks. Train A moves at 72 km/h and Train B moves at 15 m/s. A student might try to calculate their relative speed as 72 + 15 = 87, directly adding values with mixed units, which is incorrect.
βœ… Correct:
For the scenario above, first convert Train A's speed to m/s:
72 km/h = 72 * (1000 m / 3600 s) = 72 * (5/18) m/s = 4 * 5 m/s = 20 m/s
Now, both speeds are in m/s. Their relative speed (since they are moving towards each other) is:
Relative Speed = 20 m/s + 15 m/s = 35 m/s
This ensures consistency and accuracy.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Highlight Units: When reading a problem, circle or highlight the units for every given numerical value.
  • Standardize Early: Make it a habit to convert all quantities to a chosen consistent unit system (ideally SI) at the very beginning of solving the problem.
  • Unit Conversions Practice: Practice common conversions like km/h to m/s (multiply by 5/18) and m/s to km/h (multiply by 18/5).
  • Write Units: Always write the units alongside the numerical values throughout your calculation steps. This helps in identifying inconsistencies.
JEE_Main
Minor Sign Error

❌ Incorrect Sign Assignment in One-Dimensional Relative Velocity

Students frequently make errors by not consistently assigning signs to velocities based on a chosen coordinate system, especially when objects move in opposite directions. This leads to incorrect magnitudes and directions for relative velocity calculations.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake stems from a misunderstanding of velocity as a vector quantity or a failure to establish a clear, consistent positive direction. Sometimes, students treat all velocity values as magnitudes (always positive) and simply subtract them, ignoring the directional component which should be represented by a sign (positive or negative).
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always define a clear positive direction for your one-dimensional motion (e.g., rightwards, eastwards, upwards). Assign positive or negative signs to the given velocities of objects consistently with this chosen direction. Then, apply the relative velocity formula: vAB = vA - vB, where vA and vB include their respective signs.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Consider Car A moving East at 20 m/s and Car B moving West at 10 m/s. A common mistake is to calculate the velocity of A relative to B as:
vAB = vA - vB = 20 - 10 = 10 m/s (incorrectly assuming both are positive magnitudes).
βœ… Correct:
Let's use the same scenario: Car A moves East at 20 m/s, Car B moves West at 10 m/s.
1. Define East as the positive direction.
2. Therefore, vA = +20 m/s.
3. Since Car B moves West (opposite to positive), vB = -10 m/s.
4. Applying the formula: vAB = vA - vB = (+20) - (-10) = 20 + 10 = +30 m/s.
This means Car A appears to move at 30 m/s East relative to Car B.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Explicitly Define Positive Direction: Before starting any calculation, draw a simple diagram and mark your chosen positive direction with an arrow.
  • Assign Signs Consistently: Assign signs to all given velocities according to your chosen positive direction.
  • Treat as Algebraic Quantities: Remember that velocities are vectors in 1D; their signs are crucial. Perform algebraic addition/subtraction, not just magnitude subtraction.
  • Verify with Common Sense: For simple cases, check if your answer makes intuitive sense. If two cars are moving towards each other, their relative speed should be the sum of their individual speeds.
JEE_Main
Minor Approximation

❌ <span style='color: #FF0000;'>Confusing speeds with velocities and inconsistent sign convention</span>

Students often treat given 'speeds' as velocities directly without assigning a consistent sign convention (e.g., rightwards positive, leftwards negative). This leads to incorrect magnitudes of relative velocity, particularly when objects move towards each other or in opposite directions. They might 'approximate' the relative speed by just adding or subtracting magnitudes based on a vague idea of 'approaching' or 'separating,' instead of rigorous vector subtraction.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Lack of strong conceptual understanding of vectors in one dimension, where direction is simply represented by a sign.
  • Over-reliance on simplified rules like Vrel = V1 +/- V2 without understanding the underlying vector subtraction (VAB = VA - VB).
  • Skipping the crucial step of defining a consistent positive direction at the beginning of the problem.
  • Confusion between 'speed' (scalar magnitude) and 'velocity' (vector with magnitude and direction).
βœ… Correct Approach:
To avoid errors and ensure precision in relative velocity calculations:
  1. Define a consistent positive direction (e.g., rightwards positive, upwards positive).
  2. Assign appropriate signs to all given velocities based on this defined convention.
  3. Use the vector subtraction formula: VAB = VA - VB (velocity of A with respect to B, where A and B are velocities with their respective signs).
  4. The sign of the calculated result indicates the direction of the relative velocity. The magnitude is its absolute value.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Problem: Car A moves right at 20 m/s. Car B moves left at 10 m/s. What is the velocity of A relative to B?

Wrong thought process: 'They are moving in opposite directions, so their relative velocity will be found by adding their speeds.' Velocity of A relative to B = 20 + 10 = 30 m/s. (This is an intuitive 'approximation' of the magnitude but lacks directional rigor and can lead to errors in other scenarios or when defining VBA).

βœ… Correct:

Problem: Car A moves right at 20 m/s. Car B moves left at 10 m/s. What is the velocity of A relative to B?

Correct approach:

  1. Let the direction to the right be positive (+).
  2. Velocity of Car A, VA = +20 m/s.
  3. Velocity of Car B, VB = -10 m/s (since it moves left).
  4. Velocity of A relative to B: VAB = VA - VB = (+20 m/s) - (-10 m/s) = 20 + 10 = +30 m/s.

This means an observer in Car B would see Car A moving at 30 m/s in the positive (right) direction. If the question asked for relative speed, it would be |+30| = 30 m/s. This method is consistent and avoids 'approximate' reasoning.

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always draw a simple diagram for the problem to visualize the directions of motion.
  • Establish a clear and consistent sign convention at the very beginning of solving any relative velocity problem.
  • Distinguish clearly between scalar speed and vector velocity. Relative velocity is inherently a vector quantity in JEE Main.
  • Practice various problems, including those where objects move in the same direction, opposite directions, and when one is stationary, to solidify your understanding.
JEE_Main
Minor Other

❌ Incorrect Sign Convention for Direction

Students frequently make errors by not consistently applying a sign convention (positive/negative) to velocities based on their direction along a chosen axis. This leads to incorrect magnitudes and directions for relative velocities, especially when objects are moving in opposite directions.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake often stems from a lack of establishing a clear coordinate system at the beginning of the problem. Students might intuitively subtract or add magnitudes without considering the vector nature of velocity, or they might flip their chosen positive direction mid-calculation. Rushing through problems without drawing a simple diagram also contributes.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always define a positive direction (e.g., right, east, or upwards) for your one-dimensional motion. Assign appropriate signs (+ or -) to the velocity of each object based on this convention. Then, apply the relative velocity formula, VAB = VA - VB, ensuring all velocities include their respective signs.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Two trains, P and Q, are moving towards each other. Train P moves at 20 m/s and Train Q at 15 m/s. A student might incorrectly calculate the relative velocity of P with respect to Q as 20 - 15 = 5 m/s, assuming both velocities are positive without considering their opposite directions.

βœ… Correct:

Consider Train P moving at 20 m/s to the right and Train Q moving at 15 m/s to the left.

  • Let's define the right direction as positive (+).
  • Velocity of Train P, VP = +20 m/s.
  • Velocity of Train Q, VQ = -15 m/s (since it's moving left).
  • Relative velocity of P with respect to Q:
  • VPQ = VP - VQ = (+20) - (-15) = 20 + 15 = +35 m/s.
  • This positive result indicates that Train P appears to be moving at 35 m/s to the right from Train Q's perspective.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Draw a simple diagram: Always sketch the scenario and indicate the directions of motion.
  • Choose a consistent sign convention: Explicitly state which direction is positive at the start of solving the problem.
  • Treat velocities as vectors: Even in one dimension, velocity has both magnitude and direction, represented by its sign.
  • Double-check calculations: Ensure that the signs are correctly handled when applying the relative velocity formula.
JEE_Main
Minor Other

❌ Inconsistent Sign Convention for 1D Relative Velocity

Students frequently make errors by not consistently applying a chosen sign convention (positive/negative direction) to all velocities when calculating relative velocity in one dimension. This often leads to incorrect magnitudes or directions for the resultant relative velocity.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Lack of Initial Convention: Failing to define a positive direction at the start of the problem.
  • Treating Speeds Instead of Velocities: Confusing the scalar 'speed' with the vector 'velocity', ignoring the directional aspect (sign).
  • Misconception of Relative Motion: Incorrectly thinking that velocities always add up when objects move towards each other or always subtract when moving away, without considering the observer's frame and vector subtraction.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always establish a clear positive direction (e.g., rightward is positive) at the outset. Then, assign appropriate signs (+ or -) to all velocities involved based on this convention. Finally, apply the vector subtraction formula for relative velocity: VAB = VA - VB, where VA and VB are the velocities with their correct signs.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Scenario: Car A moves right at 20 m/s, Car B moves left at 10 m/s. Calculate VAB.
Student's Mistake:
Thinking VA = 20, VB = 10 (ignoring sign for direction).
Calculating VAB = 20 - 10 = 10 m/s, or sometimes 20 + 10 = 30 m/s.
This shows an inconsistent application of direction.
βœ… Correct:
Scenario: Car A moves right at 20 m/s, Car B moves left at 10 m/s. Calculate VAB (velocity of A with respect to B).
Correct Approach:
  1. Define Positive Direction: Let rightward be the positive direction.
  2. Assign Velocities with Signs:
    • Velocity of A, VA = +20 m/s (since it's moving right)
    • Velocity of B, VB = -10 m/s (since it's moving left)
  3. Apply Relative Velocity Formula:
    VAB = VA - VB
    VAB = (+20) - (-10)
    VAB = 20 + 10 = +30 m/s
Interpretation: Car A appears to move at 30 m/s in the positive (rightward) direction as seen by Car B. This means B sees A moving away from it to the right at 30 m/s.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Establish Convention First: Always state your chosen positive direction (e.g., 'Let positive X be to the right') at the very beginning of solving a problem.
  • Draw Diagrams: Use simple diagrams to visualize the directions of velocities and mark them with appropriate signs.
  • Practice with Varied Scenarios: Solve problems where objects move in the same direction, opposite directions, and where one object is stationary.
  • Understand Vector Subtraction: Remember that relative velocity is a vector difference, and signs are crucial for correct vector arithmetic in 1D.
CBSE_12th
Minor Approximation

❌ Incorrect Application of Sign Conventions for Relative Velocity in One Dimension

Students often approximate the relative velocity by simply adding or subtracting magnitudes based on whether objects are moving towards or away from each other, neglecting to consistently apply a chosen positive direction and the vector subtraction formula (vAB = vA - vB). This frequently leads to errors in the sign and sometimes the magnitude of the calculated relative velocity.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Confusion between relative speed (magnitude) and relative velocity (vector).
  • Lack of a clear, consistent sign convention for all velocities involved.
  • Over-reliance on 'rules of thumb' like 'opposite directions, add speeds' without fully understanding the underlying vector principle for velocity.
  • Approximating the final direction based on intuition rather than a rigorous calculation.
βœ… Correct Approach:
  • Always define a positive direction (e.g., rightwards, East, or upwards) at the beginning of the problem.
  • Assign appropriate signs (+ or -) to the individual velocities of each object based on this chosen positive direction.
  • Consistently use the vector subtraction formula: vAB = vA - vB for the velocity of A relative to B.
  • The resulting sign of vAB directly indicates the direction of the relative velocity with respect to the chosen positive direction.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Scenario: Car A moves East at 20 m/s. Car B moves West at 10 m/s.

Student's Incorrect Thought Process (Approximation): 'They are moving towards each other, so their relative speed is 20 + 10 = 30 m/s. Since Car A is faster, the relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B must be 30 m/s East.' (Here, the student correctly calculates magnitude but approximates the direction based on intuition rather than formal subtraction).

βœ… Correct:

Scenario: Car A moves East at 20 m/s. Car B moves West at 10 m/s.

Correct Approach:

  1. Define East as the positive direction.
  2. Velocity of Car A, vA = +20 m/s (since it's East).
  3. Velocity of Car B, vB = -10 m/s (since it's West).
  4. Relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B (vAB):
    vAB = vA - vB = (+20 m/s) - (-10 m/s) = 20 + 10 = +30 m/s.

The positive sign indicates that Car A is moving at 30 m/s in the East direction relative to Car B, which matches the formal calculation.

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Draw and Label: Always draw a simple diagram and clearly mark your chosen positive direction.
  • Sign Discipline: Meticulously assign signs to all velocities before applying the relative velocity formula.
  • Formula Adherence: Stick to vAB = vA - vB without attempting mental shortcuts based on directions.
  • Interpret Sign: Understand that the final sign of the relative velocity value tells you its direction relative to your chosen positive direction.
CBSE_12th
Minor Sign Error

❌ Sign Errors in Relative Velocity Direction

Students frequently make mistakes in assigning the correct positive or negative signs to individual velocities when calculating relative velocity in one dimension. This oversight leads to incorrect magnitudes and, more critically, incorrect directions for the resultant relative velocity, even when the formula VAB = VA - VB is known.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This minor error typically stems from:
  • Inconsistent Sign Convention: Not establishing a clear positive direction for the entire problem.
  • Treating Velocity as Speed: Confusing velocity (a vector quantity with direction) with speed (a scalar magnitude), leading to all values being taken as positive.
  • Careless Substitution: Rushing to substitute values without proper regard for their assigned signs based on the chosen direction.
  • Misinterpreting 'Relative To': Incorrectly assuming how directions should combine (e.g., always adding magnitudes when moving apart, or subtracting when moving in the same direction, without a proper vector approach).
βœ… Correct Approach:
To avoid sign errors, always follow these steps:
  1. Define a Consistent Positive Direction: Clearly state your positive direction (e.g., 'right is positive', 'east is positive', 'upwards is positive').
  2. Assign Signs to Individual Velocities: Based on your chosen positive direction, assign the correct + or - sign to each given velocity.
  3. Apply the Formula Consistently: Use the formula VAB = VA - VB, ensuring you substitute the velocities with their appropriate signs.
  4. Interpret the Result: The sign of the calculated relative velocity (VAB) indicates its direction relative to your chosen positive direction.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Consider Car A moving East at 20 m/s and Car B moving West at 10 m/s. A common mistake is to calculate relative velocity of A with respect to B (VAB) as 20 - 10 = 10 m/s, or sometimes even 20 + 10 = 30 m/s without a proper sign convention, leading to confusion about its direction.
βœ… Correct:
Let's use the same scenario: Car A (VA) moves East at 20 m/s, Car B (VB) moves West at 10 m/s.
StepActionValue / Calculation
1.Define positive directionLet East be positive (+).
2.Assign signs to velocitiesVA = +20 m/s (East)
VB = -10 m/s (West)
3.Apply formula (VAB = VA - VB)VAB = (+20 m/s) - (-10 m/s)
= 20 + 10 = +30 m/s
4.Interpret resultThe positive sign indicates VAB is 30 m/s East (i.e., Car A appears to move East at 30 m/s to an observer in Car B).
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always Draw: Sketch a simple diagram showing the objects and their velocity vectors, then mark your positive direction.
  • Explicitly Write Signs: When writing down given data, always include the sign with the velocity (e.g., VP = +15 m/s, VQ = -8 m/s).
  • Parentheses for Negatives: Use parentheses when substituting negative values into the formula to prevent arithmetic errors (e.g., A - (-B)).
  • Practice: Solve a variety of problems involving objects moving in the same, opposite, and perpendicular (though not for 1D) directions to solidify understanding.
CBSE_12th
Minor Unit Conversion

❌ Ignoring or Inconsistent Unit Conversion

Students frequently make errors by either ignoring the units of given physical quantities or by performing calculations with inconsistent units (e.g., mixing km/h with m/s directly) when dealing with relative velocity problems in one dimension. This leads to incorrect numerical answers, even if the conceptual understanding of relative velocity is correct.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake often arises due to:
  • Lack of attention: Students might overlook the units while quickly reading the problem.
  • Rushing: In exam pressure, unit conversion steps are sometimes skipped or performed incorrectly.
  • Poor habit: Not consistently writing down units alongside numerical values during calculations.
  • Misconception: Assuming that simply subtracting or adding numerical values is sufficient, irrespective of their units.
βœ… Correct Approach:
The correct approach involves ensuring all physical quantities are expressed in a consistent system of units before any calculations are performed. The SI system (meters for distance, seconds for time) is generally preferred for physics problems. Convert all velocities to m/s or km/h, whichever is convenient for the problem and final answer required, before applying the relative velocity formula.

Key Conversion Factor:
1 km/h = 1000 meters / 3600 seconds = 5/18 m/s
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
A train A moves at 72 km/h and a car B moves at 10 m/s in the same direction. What is the relative velocity of train A with respect to car B?
Incorrect Calculation:
Relative velocity = VA - VB = 72 - 10 = 62.
Error: Units (km/h and m/s) were mixed directly without conversion.
βœ… Correct:
A train A moves at 72 km/h and a car B moves at 10 m/s in the same direction. What is the relative velocity of train A with respect to car B?
Correct Calculation:
1. Convert VA to m/s:
   VA = 72 km/h = 72 Γ— (5/18) m/s = 4 Γ— 5 m/s = 20 m/s.
2. VB = 10 m/s.
3. Relative velocity (VAB) = VA - VB (since both are in the same direction)
   VAB = 20 m/s - 10 m/s = 10 m/s.
Note: All units are consistent (m/s) before and after subtraction.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always write units: Develop the habit of writing the units with every numerical value throughout your calculations.
  • Check units before calculation: Before performing any arithmetic operation (addition, subtraction), visually inspect if all quantities involved have consistent units.
  • Standardize units: If no specific unit is asked for the final answer, convert all given values to SI units (m and s) at the beginning of the problem. This is a good practice for JEE as well as CBSE.
  • Box the answer with correct units: Always write the final answer along with its appropriate unit and highlight it (e.g., by boxing it).
CBSE_12th
Minor Formula

❌ Incorrect Sign Convention in Relative Velocity Formulas

Students frequently make errors in applying the correct sign convention when calculating relative velocity in one dimension. This typically involves misinterpreting the direction of velocities or the vector subtraction inherent in the relative velocity formula, leading to incorrect magnitudes and directions of the relative velocity.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake often stems from two main reasons:
  • Lack of Consistent Sign Convention: Students fail to establish a clear and consistent positive direction for the motion.
  • Treating Velocity as Scalar: Forgetting that velocity is a vector quantity and simply subtracting magnitudes, especially when objects are moving in opposite directions, rather than performing vector subtraction with appropriate signs. They might incorrectly assume that 'relative' always means 'subtraction of positive values'.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always begin by establishing a consistent positive direction (e.g., rightwards or eastwards is positive, leftwards or westwards is negative). Then, assign appropriate positive or negative signs to the velocities of individual objects based on this convention. Finally, use the standard relative velocity formula:
  • Velocity of object A with respect to object B: VAB = VA - VB
  • Velocity of object B with respect to object A: VBA = VB - VA
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Scenario: Car A moves right at 10 m/s, Car B moves left at 5 m/s.
Wrong Calculation: A student might incorrectly calculate the velocity of A with respect to B as VAB = 10 - 5 = 5 m/s, assuming both are moving in the 'same' general direction or ignoring the true vector nature of the subtraction.
βœ… Correct:
Scenario: Car A moves right at 10 m/s, Car B moves left at 5 m/s.
Correct Approach:
1. Define rightwards as positive (+).
2. So, VA = +10 m/s and VB = -5 m/s.
3. Using the formula VAB = VA - VB:
VAB = (+10) - (-5) = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s.
This means Car A appears to move at 15 m/s to the right relative to Car B. For CBSE, demonstrating this clear sign convention is crucial.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always Define Direction: Explicitly state your chosen positive direction at the start of every problem.
  • Draw Diagrams: A simple diagram showing the direction of velocities helps visualize the scenario.
  • Treat Velocities as Vectors: Consistently assign signs to velocities before applying the formula.
  • Practice Varied Scenarios: Work through examples where objects move in the same direction, opposite directions, and when one is stationary.
CBSE_12th
Minor Calculation

❌ Incorrect Sign Convention for Relative Velocity in One Dimension

Students frequently make errors in assigning correct positive and negative signs to velocities when calculating relative velocity, particularly when objects are moving in opposite directions. This leads to an incorrect magnitude for the relative velocity.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake stems from a misunderstanding that relative velocity is simply the difference between the magnitudes of the velocities, or from failing to consistently define a positive direction. Students might treat velocity as a scalar quantity (speed) instead of a vector quantity.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always establish a positive direction (e.g., East, right, upwards). Assign positive signs to velocities in this chosen direction and negative signs to velocities in the opposite direction. Then, use the vector subtraction formula for relative velocity: VAB = VA - VB, where VA and VB are the velocities with their correct signs.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Two cars, Car A moving at 40 km/h East and Car B moving at 30 km/h West. What is the relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B (VAB)?
Student's incorrect calculation: VAB = 40 km/h - 30 km/h = 10 km/h (assuming they are simply subtracting magnitudes without considering direction).
βœ… Correct:
Two cars, Car A moving at 40 km/h East and Car B moving at 30 km/h West. What is the relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B (VAB)?
Let's define East as the positive (+) direction.
Velocity of Car A (VA) = +40 km/h
Velocity of Car B (VB) = -30 km/h (since it moves West, opposite to positive)
Using the formula: VAB = VA - VB
VAB = (+40 km/h) - (-30 km/h)
VAB = 40 km/h + 30 km/h = +70 km/h
The relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B is 70 km/h East.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Define a Coordinate System: Before starting any calculation, explicitly state which direction is positive.
  • Vector vs. Scalar: Always remember that velocity is a vector. Its direction is crucial.
  • Practice with Opposite Directions: Pay special attention to problems where objects move towards or away from each other. These are common traps.
  • Double Check Signs: After setting up the equation, pause and review if each velocity has the correct positive or negative sign according to your chosen direction.
    This simple check is vital for both CBSE and JEE Main questions.
CBSE_12th
Minor Conceptual

❌ Ignoring or Inconsistent Sign Conventions for Direction

Students frequently make errors by not consistently applying a chosen sign convention (e.g., positive for rightward/upward, negative for leftward/downward) when dealing with velocities in one dimension. This leads to incorrect magnitudes and directions for relative velocity, especially when objects move in opposite directions.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake stems from treating velocities as scalar quantities rather than vector quantities. Students often perform arithmetic operations (addition/subtraction) directly without first assigning proper signs that reflect the direction of motion relative to a common reference frame. The confusion arises when the formula VAB = VA - VB is used without understanding the vector nature of VA and VB.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always establish a clear and consistent positive direction for your coordinate system (e.g., right is +ve, left is -ve). Assign appropriate signs to the velocities of all objects involved based on this convention. Only then apply the relative velocity formula, ensuring the signs of VA and VB are correctly substituted.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Consider Car A moving at 30 m/s towards the East and Car B moving at 20 m/s towards the West. A common error is calculating the velocity of A relative to B (VAB) as 30 - 20 = 10 m/s, assuming both are moving in the same 'sense' or just subtracting magnitudes. This is incorrect because the directions are opposite.
βœ… Correct:
Using the same scenario: Let East be the positive direction.
Therefore, VA = +30 m/s (East).
Since Car B moves West, VB = -20 m/s (West).
Applying the relative velocity formula:
VAB = VA - VB
VAB = (+30) - (-20) = 30 + 20 = +50 m/s.
The +50 m/s indicates that Car A appears to move at 50 m/s towards the East relative to Car B. For VBA = VB - VA = (-20) - (+30) = -50 m/s, meaning Car B appears to move at 50 m/s towards the West relative to Car A.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Visualize: Always draw a simple diagram showing the direction of motion for each object.
  • Choose a Convention: Clearly state your positive direction at the beginning of the problem. For instance, 'Let rightward be positive (+).'
  • Assign Signs: Convert all given speeds into velocities by assigning them appropriate positive or negative signs based on your chosen convention.
  • CBSE/JEE Focus: In CBSE, clear steps with sign conventions are crucial for full marks. For JEE, this understanding ensures accuracy in more complex problems involving multiple dimensions or varying velocities.
CBSE_12th
Minor Conceptual

❌ Ignoring or Inconsistent Sign Convention in 1D Relative Velocity

Students frequently make errors by not consistently applying a sign convention (e.g., positive for right/up, negative for left/down) when dealing with velocities in one dimension. This often leads to incorrect magnitudes or directions for the relative velocity. They might mistakenly subtract scalar speeds instead of performing vector subtraction with signed velocities.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake stems from a weak conceptual understanding of velocity as a vector quantity and confusing it with speed. Students tend to treat velocities as simple magnitudes to be added or subtracted, rather than as directed quantities that require a chosen reference direction for assigning signs. Lack of habit in drawing clear diagrams also contributes.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always define a positive direction at the outset. Assign appropriate signs (+ or -) to all given velocities based on this chosen convention. Then, apply the vector subtraction formula for relative velocity: VAB = VA - VB, where VAB is the velocity of object A relative to object B.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Two trains, A and B, are moving towards each other. Train A has a speed of 20 m/s and Train B has a speed of 10 m/s. A common mistake is to calculate the relative speed as 20 - 10 = 10 m/s, ignoring the opposite directions.
βœ… Correct:
Consider the same scenario: Train A (speed 20 m/s), Train B (speed 10 m/s), moving towards each other.
1. Define 'right' as positive.
2. If Train A moves right, VA = +20 m/s.
3. If Train B moves left (towards A), VB = -10 m/s.
4. Relative velocity of A with respect to B: VAB = VA - VB = (+20) - (-10) = +30 m/s.
The positive sign indicates that Train A is observed to move right at 30 m/s by an observer on Train B.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Start with a Diagram: Always draw a simple diagram indicating the directions of motion.
  • Establish Convention: Clearly state your chosen positive direction (e.g., 'East is +ve', 'Up is +ve').
  • Assign Signs Consistently: Before any calculation, write down the velocities with their correct signs.
  • Remember Velocity is Vector: Emphasize to yourself that velocity has both magnitude and direction, unlike speed.
  • Practice with Varied Directions: Solve problems where objects move in the same, opposite, and perpendicular directions (though for 1D, only same/opposite applies for now).
JEE_Advanced
Minor Calculation

❌ Incorrect Sign Convention in 1D Relative Velocity Calculations

A common mistake involves failing to consistently assign appropriate positive or negative signs to velocities based on a chosen direction. Students often treat all speeds as positive magnitudes when applying the relative velocity formula, leading to errors in the final calculated value.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This error stems from an incomplete understanding of velocity as a vector quantity, even in one dimension where direction is represented by a sign. Rushing through problems without explicitly defining a positive direction, or confusing speed with velocity, are frequent causes.
βœ… Correct Approach:
To correctly calculate relative velocity in one dimension:
  • Establish a consistent positive direction (e.g., rightwards or upwards) at the beginning of the problem.
  • Assign positive or negative signs to the velocities of all objects (with respect to the ground or a stationary observer) based on this chosen positive direction.
  • Apply the relative velocity formula: VAB = VA - VB, where VA and VB are the signed velocities of object A and object B, respectively.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Problem: Car A moves right at 20 m/s. Car B moves left at 10 m/s. Find the velocity of A relative to B.

Student's Incorrect Calculation: Assuming both speeds are positive magnitudes, VAB = 20 - 10 = 10 m/s.

Error: Failed to assign a negative sign to the velocity of Car B moving left.

βœ… Correct:

Problem: Car A moves right at 20 m/s. Car B moves left at 10 m/s. Find the velocity of A relative to B.

Correct Approach:

  1. Define positive direction: Let rightwards be positive.
  2. Assign signed velocities:
    VA = +20 m/s (since Car A moves right)
    VB = -10 m/s (since Car B moves left)
  3. Apply formula:
    VAB = VA - VB
    VAB = (+20 m/s) - (-10 m/s)
    VAB = 20 + 10 = +30 m/s

Interpretation: The velocity of A relative to B is 30 m/s to the right. Car B observes Car A moving away at 30 m/s.

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always explicitly define your positive direction for 1D motion at the start of every problem.
  • Write down the velocities of all objects with their correct positive or negative signs before substituting them into the relative velocity formula.
  • Understand that the 'minus' sign in VA - VB represents vector subtraction, not just arithmetic subtraction of magnitudes.
  • For JEE Advanced, practice visualizing the scenario to intuitively cross-check the direction and magnitude of your calculated relative velocity.
JEE_Advanced
Minor Formula

❌ Incorrect Application of Relative Velocity Formula in One Dimension

Students often incorrectly apply the relative velocity formula in one dimension, particularly when dealing with objects moving in opposite directions or when the reference frame is not clearly established. The common error lies in treating velocities as scalar magnitudes and simply adding or subtracting them, rather than performing a vector subtraction using a consistent sign convention.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake primarily stems from a lack of understanding of the vector nature of velocity and the importance of a consistent sign convention. Students forget that the relative velocity formula vAB = vA - vB is a vector subtraction. They might intuitively add magnitudes if objects are moving towards each other, or subtract if moving in the same direction, without properly assigning positive and negative signs based on a chosen coordinate axis.
βœ… Correct Approach:
The correct approach is to always define a positive direction for your chosen coordinate axis (e.g., rightwards is positive). Then, assign appropriate positive or negative signs to the velocities of both objects (vA and vB) relative to a stationary ground frame. Finally, apply the vector subtraction formula: vAB = vA - vB, where vAB is the velocity of object A relative to object B.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Problem: Car A moves at 20 m/s to the right and Car B moves at 10 m/s to the left. What is the velocity of A with respect to B?
Wrong thinking: 'They are moving towards each other, so I should add their speeds.' vAB = 20 + 10 = 30 m/s (magnitude only). Or, 'vA - vB = 20 - 10 = 10 m/s', without proper sign consideration.
βœ… Correct:
Problem: Car A moves at 20 m/s to the right and Car B moves at 10 m/s to the left. What is the velocity of A with respect to B?
Solution:
1. Define 'right' as the positive direction.
2. Velocity of Car A, vA = +20 m/s
3. Velocity of Car B, vB = -10 m/s (since it's moving left)
4. Apply the formula: vAB = vA - vB
5. vAB = (+20 m/s) - (-10 m/s) = 20 + 10 = +30 m/s.
The positive sign indicates that Car A appears to be moving to the right at 30 m/s relative to Car B.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always choose a positive direction: Make this choice explicit before solving any problem.
  • Assign signs consistently: Assign positive or negative signs to all velocities based on your chosen positive direction.
  • Use the vector subtraction formula: Remember that vAB = vA - vB is a vector subtraction. For 1D, this means subtracting signed scalar values.
  • Practice with diverse examples: Solve problems where objects move in the same direction, opposite directions, and where one object is stationary.
JEE_Advanced
Minor Unit Conversion

❌ Inconsistent Unit Usage in Relative Velocity Calculations

A common minor error in relative velocity problems is failing to ensure all physical quantities are expressed in a consistent set of units before performing calculations. Students often mix units, for instance, using one velocity in kilometers per hour (km/h) and another in meters per second (m/s) directly within the same equation without proper conversion. This leads to numerically incorrect results, even if the conceptual understanding of relative velocity is sound.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake primarily stems from a lack of meticulousness or rushing through the problem-solving process. Students might overlook unit specifications in different parts of the question, or simply forget to convert one quantity while diligently converting others. It's often an oversight rather than a fundamental misunderstanding of physics principles.
βœ… Correct Approach:
The fundamental principle is to convert all given quantities (velocities, distances, and times) into a single, consistent system of units, preferably the International System of Units (SI units: meters, seconds, m/s), before applying any relative velocity formulas. This ensures that all terms in an equation are dimensionally consistent and compatible for arithmetic operations.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Problem: Car A travels at 72 km/h. Car B travels at 15 m/s in the same direction. What is the relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B?

Incorrect Calculation:
VA = 72 km/h, VB = 15 m/s
VAB = VA - VB = 72 - 15 = 57 m/s (Incorrect, as units are mixed)

βœ… Correct:

Correct Calculation:
First, convert VA to m/s:
VA = 72 km/h * (1000 m / 1 km) * (1 h / 3600 s) = 72 * (5/18) m/s = 20 m/s
Now, both velocities are in m/s:
VA = 20 m/s, VB = 15 m/s
VAB = VA - VB = 20 m/s - 15 m/s = 5 m/s (Correct)

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Initial Check: Always scan the entire problem statement for units of all given quantities before beginning any calculations.
  • Standardize Early: Develop a habit of converting all values to a chosen consistent unit system (e.g., SI units) as the very first step in problem-solving.
  • Write Units: Include units with every numerical value during intermediate calculation steps to visually track consistency.
  • JEE Advanced Callout: While seemingly minor, unit inconsistency is a common trap in JEE Advanced. Examiners often provide mixed units to test attention to detail, which is a crucial skill for high-stakes exams. Develop a systematic approach to unit conversion.
JEE_Advanced
Minor Sign Error

❌ Inconsistent Sign Convention in Relative Velocity Calculations

Students frequently make sign errors in relative velocity problems by not establishing or consistently adhering to a chosen positive direction. This leads to incorrect magnitudes or directions for the relative velocity vector, especially in multi-step problems or when dealing with objects moving towards each other.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This error primarily stems from:
  • Lack of a Defined Coordinate System: Not explicitly choosing a positive direction (e.g., rightward, upward) before solving.
  • Intuitive vs. Formal Approach: Relying on intuition (e.g., 'they are moving towards each other, so their speeds add up') instead of the vector subtraction formula VAB = VA - VB, where VA and VB include their signs based on the chosen convention.
  • Mixing Conventions: Inadvertently switching the positive direction mid-problem or assigning signs based on magnitude addition/subtraction rather than vector representation.
βœ… Correct Approach:
To correctly handle relative velocity, always:
  1. Establish a Consistent Positive Direction: Clearly define which direction is positive (e.g., right, East, up) at the very beginning of the problem. This is critical for both CBSE and JEE.
  2. Assign Signs to All Velocities: Based on your chosen positive direction, assign appropriate positive or negative signs to the velocities of all objects involved.
  3. Apply the Relative Velocity Formula: Use the vector subtraction formula: VAB = VA - VB, where VA and VB are the velocities (including their signs) of object A and object B with respect to the ground, respectively.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Consider Car A moving right at 10 m/s and Car B moving left at 5 m/s.
Incorrect thought process: 'They are moving towards each other, so their relative speed is 10 + 5 = 15 m/s.' Or, 'VA = +10, VB = -5. Relative velocity = VA + VB = 10 + (-5) = 5 m/s.' This common mistake often arises from not sticking to the formula's vector nature.
βœ… Correct:
Let's use the same scenario: Car A moving right at 10 m/s and Car B moving left at 5 m/s.
Step 1: Define Positive Direction. Let 'right' be the positive direction.
Step 2: Assign Signs to Velocities.
  • Velocity of Car A (VA) = +10 m/s (since it's moving right)
  • Velocity of Car B (VB) = -5 m/s (since it's moving left)
Step 3: Apply Relative Velocity Formula. To find the velocity of A relative to B (VAB):
VAB = VA - VB
VAB = (+10 m/s) - (-5 m/s)
VAB = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s
This means Car A appears to move at 15 m/s to the right from the perspective of Car B.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Draw a Diagram: Always sketch the scenario and explicitly mark your chosen positive direction with an arrow.
  • Write Down Sign Convention: At the start of every problem, state your chosen positive direction (e.g., 'Let right be positive').
  • Treat Velocities as Vectors: Remember that velocity is a vector. The formula VAB = VA - VB performs vector subtraction, so the signs of VA and VB are crucial.
  • Practice Consistently: Solve numerous problems, consciously applying the same sign convention every time. This consistency is vital for scoring well in JEE Advanced where multi-concept problems can amplify simple sign errors.
JEE_Advanced
Minor Approximation

❌ Misinterpreting Small Non-Zero Relative Velocities as Zero

Students sometimes incorrectly approximate that if the magnitude of the calculated relative velocity between two objects is very small (e.g., when individual velocities are very close), it can be treated as zero. This leads to fundamental errors in predicting outcomes like meeting times, overtaking, or calculating relative displacement, assuming no relative motion exists.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This error often arises from a tendency to prematurely round off values or an incomplete understanding of what a non-zero relative velocity signifies. When individual velocities are numerically very close (e.g., VA = 20.0 m/s and VB = 19.9 m/s), students might perceive their difference (0.1 m/s) as 'negligible' and round it to zero, effectively assuming the objects are moving at identical speeds. This overlooks the cumulative effect of even a small relative speed over time.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always calculate the precise relative velocity using the formula Vrel = VA - VB (or VA - (-VB) for opposite directions, with proper sign conventions). A small, non-zero relative velocity is crucial; it implies definite relative motion and a finite time for objects to meet or overtake. For JEE Advanced, precision is paramount; avoid rounding until the very final step, unless explicitly stated in the problem to approximate.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Two trains, P and Q, are moving on parallel tracks in the same direction. Train P has a velocity of 60.0 km/h and Train Q has a velocity of 59.9 km/h. If P is 5 km behind Q, will P ever overtake Q?
Student's approximation: Relative velocity VPQ = 60.0 - 59.9 = 0.1 km/h. This is a very small number, so I will approximate VPQ β‰ˆ 0. Therefore, Train P will 'almost never' overtake Train Q, or it will take an infinite amount of time.
βœ… Correct:
Two trains, P and Q, are moving on parallel tracks in the same direction. Train P has a velocity of 60.0 km/h and Train Q has a velocity of 59.9 km/h. If P is 5 km behind Q, when will P overtake Q?
Correct calculation: Relative velocity VPQ = VP - VQ = 60.0 km/h - 59.9 km/h = 0.1 km/h.
Time taken for Train P to overtake Train Q = Relative Distance / Relative Velocity = 5 km / 0.1 km/h = 50 hours. This is a significant, finite time, clearly showing that P will indeed overtake Q, contrary to the approximation.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Strict Precision: For JEE Advanced, treat all calculated values, no matter how small, as exact until the final answer.
  • Conceptual Understanding: Remember that any non-zero relative velocity, however small, implies a change in relative position over time.
  • Units Consistency: Always ensure units are consistent before performing calculations to avoid numerical errors that might tempt premature rounding.
  • JEE Advanced Context: Questions are designed to test your exact understanding; rounding off 'small' non-zero values is generally not acceptable unless specifically instructed (e.g., 'approximate to the nearest integer').
JEE_Advanced
Important Conceptual

❌ Ignoring the Vector Nature of Velocity and Inconsistent Sign Convention

Students frequently make errors by not consistently defining a positive direction or by treating speeds as velocities directly in relative velocity equations. This leads to incorrect signs in their calculations, fundamentally misunderstanding that velocity is a vector quantity.

πŸ’­ Why This Happens:

This typically occurs due to:

  • Not defining a clear positive direction at the outset.
  • Confusing speed (a scalar) with velocity (a vector).
  • Attempting to subtract or add magnitudes directly without considering their directions.
βœ… Correct Approach:

Always treat velocity as a vector. For one-dimensional motion:

  1. Step 1: Explicitly choose and define a positive direction (e.g., rightwards, upwards, eastwards).
  2. Step 2: Assign appropriate signs (+ or -) to the absolute velocities of individual objects (vA, vB) based on this chosen positive direction.
  3. Step 3: Apply the relative velocity formula: vAB = vA - vB. The sign of the result will correctly indicate the direction of vAB relative to your chosen positive direction.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Two cars, A and B, are moving towards each other. Car A moves at 20 m/s, and Car B moves at 15 m/s. Calculate the relative velocity of A with respect to B (vAB).

Student's Incorrect Approach: Assuming A moves right (+20) and B moves right (+15) (ignoring 'moving towards each other'), then vAB = 20 - 15 = 5 m/s. Or, incorrectly adding magnitudes: vAB = 20 + 15 = 35 m/s without assigning signs properly.

βœ… Correct:

Following the above scenario:

  1. Step 1: Let the positive direction be towards the right.
  2. Step 2: If Car A moves rightwards, vA = +20 m/s. Since Car B moves towards A, it must be moving leftwards, so vB = -15 m/s.
  3. Step 3: Apply the formula: vAB = vA - vB = (+20) - (-15) = 20 + 15 = +35 m/s.

This means Car A appears to move at 35 m/s in the positive direction (rightwards) to an observer in Car B.

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always draw a simple diagram and explicitly mark your chosen positive direction.
  • Before substituting values, write down the velocities of individual objects with their correct signs based on your chosen positive direction.
  • Understand that vAB = vA - vB is a vector subtraction, not just subtraction of magnitudes.
  • JEE Advanced Tip: This foundational error can propagate into more complex 2D relative motion or kinematics problems, so master it for 1D first.
JEE_Advanced
Important Formula

❌ Incorrect Sign Convention in Relative Velocity Formula

Students frequently make errors by not consistently applying sign conventions for velocities when using the relative velocity formula in one dimension. This often leads to misinterpreting the direction of motion and magnitude of relative velocity.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake stems from a failure to treat velocities as vector quantities rather than scalar magnitudes. Students often forget to assign a specific sign (+ or -) to velocities based on a chosen coordinate system, or they perform simple arithmetic subtraction without considering the directional aspect of each velocity vector.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always establish a clear, consistent positive direction for the one-dimensional motion (e.g., rightwards or eastwards is positive). Assign appropriate signs (+ for motion in the positive direction, - for motion in the negative direction) to all individual velocities. Then, apply the vector subtraction formula: VAB = VA - VB, where VAB is the velocity of object A relative to object B.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Consider Car A moving east at 10 m/s and Car B moving west at 5 m/s.
A common mistake is to calculate relative velocity as 10 - 5 = 5 m/s or even 10 + 5 = 15 m/s without a clear directional convention or understanding of the formula. This leads to ambiguity and incorrect results.
βœ… Correct:
Let's apply the correct approach to the above example:
1. Choose a positive direction: Let East be the positive direction (+).
2. Assign signs to velocities:
  • Velocity of Car A (VA) = +10 m/s (since it's moving East)
  • Velocity of Car B (VB) = -5 m/s (since it's moving West)
3. Apply the formula VAB = VA - VB:
VAB = (+10) - (-5) = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s
This means Car A appears to move at 15 m/s in the East direction when observed from Car B. Similarly, VBA = VB - VA = (-5) - (+10) = -15 m/s, meaning Car B appears to move at 15 m/s in the West direction relative to Car A.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Draw a diagram: A simple visual helps in assigning directions.
  • Define positive direction first: Explicitly state which direction is positive for your calculation.
  • Assign signs carefully: Ensure each velocity has a correct positive or negative sign according to your chosen convention.
  • Understand 'relative to': Remember that VAB means 'velocity of A with respect to B', leading to VA - VB.
  • JEE Advanced Focus: These details are crucial in multi-part questions where an initial sign error propagates.
JEE_Advanced
Important Unit Conversion

❌ Inconsistent Units in Relative Velocity Calculations

Students often perform relative velocity calculations without ensuring all given quantities (velocities, distances, times) are expressed in a consistent system of units. This leads to numerically incorrect answers, even if the conceptual understanding of relative velocity is correct. For example, mixing km/h with m/s, or using time in minutes with velocity in km/h.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake primarily stems from carelessness or rushing during the exam. Sometimes, students might be confident in the relative velocity formula (V_rel = V_A - V_B) and overlook the fundamental requirement of unit homogeneity. Lack of practice in unit conversions or not explicitly writing down units at each step can also contribute.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always convert all quantities to a single, consistent system of units (e.g., SI units: meters, seconds, m/s) before performing any calculations. For JEE Advanced, it's generally safest to stick to SI units unless the question specifically asks for the answer in different units. If the answer is required in non-SI units, perform all calculations in SI and convert the final result.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Two cars approach each other. Car A moves at 36 km/h, Car B moves at 10 m/s. What is their relative speed?
Incorrect calculation: Relative speed = 36 - 10 = 26 (units undefined or incorrectly assumed km/h or m/s).
βœ… Correct:
Two cars approach each other. Car A moves at 36 km/h, Car B moves at 10 m/s.
  • Convert Car A's speed to m/s: 36 km/h = 36 * (1000 m / 3600 s) = 10 m/s.
  • Now both speeds are in m/s.
  • Correct calculation: Relative speed = |V_A - V_B| (since they are approaching, their relative speed is the sum of magnitudes in 1D if directions are opposite, but the 'difference' formula works by careful sign convention). If we take one direction as positive, say A is +10 m/s and B is -10 m/s. Relative velocity of A w.r.t B = V_A - V_B = 10 - (-10) = 20 m/s.
  • If only magnitude is asked, their speeds add up when approaching: 10 m/s + 10 m/s = 20 m/s.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Initial Check: Before starting any problem, explicitly check the units of all given values.
  • Standardize Early: Convert all quantities to SI units (meters, seconds) at the very beginning of the problem.
  • Write Units: Carry units through your calculations. This helps in identifying inconsistencies.
  • Practice Conversions: Regularly practice common conversions like km/h to m/s, cm to m, minutes to seconds.
  • Final Review: Before marking the answer, quickly check if the final answer's unit matches the expected unit or if any conversion was missed.
JEE_Advanced
Important Sign Error

❌ Incorrect Sign Convention in Relative Velocity (1D)

Students frequently make sign errors when calculating relative velocity in one dimension. This typically involves misapplying the positive and negative signs for velocities, leading to incorrect magnitudes and directions of the relative velocity vector. Forgetting that velocities are vectors and their signs denote direction is the primary oversight.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Inconsistent Sign Convention: Students often fail to establish and consistently follow a chosen positive direction (e.g., right as positive, left as negative) throughout the problem.
  • Treating Velocity as Scalar: Mistakenly adding or subtracting magnitudes without considering their directional signs.
  • Direct Subtraction without Vector Consideration: Applying VAB = VA - VB directly without ensuring VA and VB are signed correctly relative to the chosen coordinate system.
  • Confusion with 'Approaching' vs. 'Separating': While intuition can help, relying solely on it without formal sign application can lead to errors.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always define a clear positive direction for your coordinate system (e.g., East or Right is +ve, West or Left is -ve). Then, assign appropriate signs to the individual velocities (VA, VB) based on this convention. The relative velocity formula for object A with respect to B is VAB = VA - VB, where VA and VB are the velocities with their respective signs. A positive result for VAB means A is moving in the chosen positive direction relative to B, and a negative result means it's moving in the negative direction.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

A car A moves right at 20 m/s and car B moves left at 10 m/s.

Wrong calculation for VAB (velocity of A w.r.t. B):
VAB = 20 - 10 = 10 m/s (incorrectly assuming both are positive or ignoring direction).

βœ… Correct:

A car A moves right at 20 m/s and car B moves left at 10 m/s.

Let right be the positive direction (+).
VA = +20 m/s (since it's moving right)
VB = -10 m/s (since it's moving left)

Correct calculation for VAB:
VAB = VA - VB = (+20) - (-10) = 20 + 10 = +30 m/s

This means car A is moving at 30 m/s to the right relative to car B.

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Establish a Coordinate System: Always draw a simple diagram and explicitly mark your positive direction at the start of the problem.
  • Assign Signs Consistently: Ensure every velocity value is written with its correct sign based on your chosen convention.
  • Use Parentheses: When substituting into VAB = VA - VB, always use parentheses for negative velocities to avoid arithmetic errors (e.g., VA - (-VB)).
  • Conceptual Check: After calculation, ask if the sign of the result makes physical sense. If A is moving right and B is moving left, A should appear to move right even faster from B's perspective.
JEE_Advanced
Important Approximation

❌ Incorrect Approximation of Relative Speed/Velocity due to Sign Errors

Students frequently make errors in determining the relative velocity in one dimension by incorrectly applying sign conventions, especially when calculating relative speed. They often treat velocities as scalar magnitudes and simply subtract them, or always use |VA - VB|, without properly considering the assigned positive and negative directions for each individual velocity. This leads to an incorrect "approximation" of the true relative velocity or speed.

πŸ’­ Why This Happens:

  • Ignoring Vector Nature: In 1D, velocity is still a vector, requiring a consistent sign convention. Students often forget this and treat 'speed' as the primary quantity.

  • Confusion with Relative Speed: Confusion arises between 'relative velocity' (which is directional) and 'relative speed' (magnitude of relative velocity). Many assume relative speed is always |VA - VB|, even when objects move towards each other (where relative speed is |VA + VB| if VA and VB are individual speeds).

  • Over-simplification: Students try to quickly get to a numerical answer, skipping the crucial step of assigning signs based on a chosen coordinate system.

βœ… Correct Approach:

Always define a positive direction (e.g., rightward or upward) and consistently assign signs to all velocities based on this convention. Then, use the fundamental vector subtraction formula for relative velocity:


VAB = VA - VB


Where VA and VB are the velocities (with their correct signs) of object A and object B, respectively. The magnitude of this result is the relative speed.



  • If objects move in the same direction: Relative speed = |VA - VB| (assuming VA and VB are speeds).

  • If objects move in the opposite direction (towards or away from each other): Relative speed = |VA + VB| (assuming VA and VB are speeds).

πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Two cars, A and B, are moving on a straight road. Car A moves at 10 m/s to the right. Car B moves at 5 m/s to the left. What is the relative speed of A with respect to B?


Wrong Approximation: Students might just calculate the difference in magnitudes: Relative speed = 10 - 5 = 5 m/s.

βœ… Correct:

Using the same scenario:



  1. Define positive direction: Let right be positive (+).

  2. Assign signed velocities:

    • VA = +10 m/s (moving right)

    • VB = -5 m/s (moving left)



  3. Calculate relative velocity:

    • VAB = VA - VB = (+10) - (-5) = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s



  4. Determine relative speed: The relative speed is the magnitude of VAB, which is 15 m/s. This means A is approaching B (or moving away from B, depending on initial positions) at 15 m/s.


JEE Advanced Tip: Always be meticulous with signs. A common scenario involves objects moving towards each other, where relative speed is the sum of their individual speeds (magnitudes).

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:

  • Establish a Coordinate System: Before any calculation, explicitly state which direction is positive.

  • Assign Signs Consistently: Write down the velocity of each object with its correct sign.

  • Use the Formula: Always apply the vector subtraction formula Vrelative = Vobject1 - Vobject2.

  • Distinguish Velocity vs. Speed: Remember relative velocity has direction; relative speed is its magnitude.

  • Practice Scenarios: Work through problems where objects move in the same direction, opposite directions, and one is stationary, to reinforce understanding.

JEE_Advanced
Important Other

❌ <span style='color: red;'>Incorrect Sign Convention and Reference Frame Selection in Relative Velocity</span>

Students frequently err in assigning signs to velocities when calculating relative velocity, especially when objects move in opposite directions or when the positive direction isn't consistently applied. A major oversight is failing to correctly identify the observer and the observed object, leading to an incorrect formulation (e.g., calculating VAB instead of VBA).
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Lack of consistent sign convention: Students often forget to define a positive direction and adhere to it throughout the problem.
  • Confusion with vector subtraction: Simply adding or subtracting magnitudes without considering the vector directions (signs).
  • Misinterpretation of 'relative to': Not clearly understanding that VAB = VA - VB means the velocity of A with respect to B.
βœ… Correct Approach:
To avoid these errors:
  • Establish a clear coordinate system: Always define a positive direction (e.g., right is positive, up is positive) at the outset.
  • Assign signs to individual velocities: Based on your chosen coordinate system, assign a '+' or '-' sign to each object's absolute velocity.
  • Apply the relative velocity formula consistently: Remember, Vrelative = Vobject - Vobserver. If you need the velocity of A relative to B (VAB), it is always VA - VB.
  • JEE Advanced Tip: For complex problems, visualize the scenario from the observer's frame; the observer is considered stationary.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Two cars, A and B, approach each other. Car A moves right at 10 m/s, and Car B moves left at 5 m/s. A common mistake is calculating the relative velocity of A with respect to B as 10 + 5 = 15 m/s, without explicitly stating the sign convention or clearly defining which velocity is being subtracted from which.
βœ… Correct:
Let's define the right direction as positive.
Velocity of Car A (VA) = +10 m/s (moving right)
Velocity of Car B (VB) = -5 m/s (moving left)

The velocity of A relative to B (VAB) is:
VAB = VA - VB = (+10) - (-5) = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s.
This positive sign indicates that Car A appears to move to the right at 15 m/s from Car B's perspective.

Conversely, the velocity of B relative to A (VBA) is:
VBA = VB - VA = (-5) - (+10) = -5 - 10 = -15 m/s.
This negative sign indicates that Car B appears to move to the left at 15 m/s from Car A's perspective.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Visualize and Draw: Always sketch a simple diagram, indicating the chosen positive direction and the directions of all velocities.
  • Label Velocities with Signs: Explicitly write down Vobject = Β±value before substitution.
  • Understand 'Relative to': Reinforce that VXY is velocity of X with respect to Y, computed as VX - VY.
  • Practice Diverse Problems: Work through examples where objects move in the same direction, opposite directions, and when one is stationary.
JEE_Advanced
Important Sign Error

❌ Incorrect Sign Convention for Relative Velocity

Students frequently make errors in assigning appropriate positive or negative signs to velocities when calculating relative velocity in one dimension. This often stems from not establishing a consistent sign convention or confusing the 'direction of movement' with the mathematical sign.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Lack of Defined Convention: Not explicitly defining a positive direction (e.g., right as positive, left as negative) before calculations.
  • Treating Velocity as Speed: Confusing velocity (a vector) with speed (a scalar magnitude) and simply adding or subtracting magnitudes without considering direction.
  • Algebraic Carelessness: Errors in handling the negative signs during the subtraction process (Vrel = V1 - V2).
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always begin by explicitly defining a positive direction for the entire problem (e.g., east is positive, north is positive, or right is positive). Assign signs to the velocities of all objects based on this convention. Then, apply the relative velocity formula VAB = VA - VB, ensuring correct substitution of signed velocity values.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Two cars, A and B, are moving towards each other. Car A moves at 10 m/s towards the right, and Car B moves at 5 m/s towards the left.
Wrong Calculation: A student might incorrectly assume VAB = VA - VB = 10 - 5 = 5 m/s, treating both as positive magnitudes or making a sign error in the formula, leading to an incorrect relative velocity magnitude and direction.
βœ… Correct:
Using the same scenario:
1. Define Convention: Let's consider motion towards the right as positive (+).
2. Assign Signs:
  • Velocity of Car A, VA = +10 m/s (since it moves right)
  • Velocity of Car B, VB = -5 m/s (since it moves left)
3. Calculate Relative Velocity:
VAB = VA - VB = (+10 m/s) - (-5 m/s) = +10 + 5 = +15 m/s.
This indicates that Car A appears to move at 15 m/s towards the right with respect to Car B.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Strictly Define Positive Direction: Before starting any calculation, draw a diagram and clearly mark your chosen positive direction.
  • Assign Signs Consistently: Ensure every velocity value is assigned a sign based on your chosen convention.
  • Use Parentheses: When substituting negative velocities into the relative velocity formula (VA - VB), always use parentheses, e.g., (+10) - (-5), to avoid algebraic mistakes.
  • JEE Main Insight: While the concept is simple, sign errors are common traps. Practice problems involving objects moving in opposite directions or where the 'observer' is also moving to solidify your understanding.
JEE_Main
Important Other

❌ Ignoring Sign Convention for Direction in 1D Relative Velocity

A very common error is failing to consistently apply a sign convention for directions when calculating relative velocity in one dimension. Students often treat all velocities as positive magnitudes, leading to incorrect results, especially when objects move in opposite directions.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake stems from a misunderstanding that velocity is a vector quantity even in one dimension. Students might perform arithmetic operations directly on magnitudes without considering the vector nature (direction) of velocities. Haste or lack of a clear coordinate system setup also contributes.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always establish a clear sign convention (e.g., right/east as positive, left/west as negative). Assign appropriate positive or negative signs to each object's velocity based on this convention. Then, apply the relative velocity formula: VAB = VA - VB. The sign of the result will correctly indicate the relative direction.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Problem: Car A moves east at 10 m/s. Car B moves west at 5 m/s. Find the relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B.

Incorrect approach: VAB = 10 m/s - 5 m/s = 5 m/s. (This is wrong because directions are ignored, and velocities are treated as magnitudes.)

βœ… Correct:

Problem: Car A moves east at 10 m/s. Car B moves west at 5 m/s. Find the relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B.

Correct approach:

  • Establish convention: Let East be positive (+x direction).
  • Assign signed velocities:
    VA = +10 m/s (East)
    VB = -5 m/s (West)
  • Calculate relative velocity:
    VAB = VA - VB = (+10 m/s) - (-5 m/s)
    VAB = 10 m/s + 5 m/s = +15 m/s
  • Interpretation: Car A appears to move at 15 m/s in the positive direction (East) relative to Car B.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always draw a diagram: A simple visual helps reinforce direction.
  • Explicitly state your sign convention: Write it down before solving.
  • Treat velocity as a vector: Even in 1D, use positive and negative signs consistently.
  • Check the physical meaning: After calculating, ask yourself if the sign and magnitude make sense in the real world.
JEE_Main
Important Approximation

❌ Confusing Signs in Relative Velocity and Frame of Reference

Students frequently make errors in assigning correct signs to velocities, especially when objects move in opposite directions or when the frame of reference changes. This often leads to incorrect relative velocity calculations. A common pitfall is confusing VAB (velocity of A with respect to B) with VBA.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake primarily stems from a lack of a consistent sign convention or not clearly identifying the observer and the observed in a relative motion scenario. Forgetting that velocity is a vector quantity and incorrectly applying scalar arithmetic (e.g., simply adding or subtracting magnitudes without considering direction) is a significant contributing factor.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always establish a consistent positive direction (e.g., rightward or upward is positive) for all velocities. Then, write down the absolute velocities of the objects with their appropriate signs relative to the ground (or a common inertial frame). Apply the relative velocity formula: VAB = VA - VB, where VA and VB are velocities with respect to the ground. Remember the crucial relationship: VBA = VB - VA = -VAB.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Two cars, A and B, move towards each other. Car A moves at 10 m/s to the right, and Car B moves at 15 m/s to the left. A student might incorrectly calculate the relative velocity as 10 - 15 = -5 m/s (treating magnitudes only) or 10 + 15 = 25 m/s (incorrectly adding magnitudes for opposite directions) without properly incorporating signs.
βœ… Correct:
Let's establish that the right direction is positive (+).
  • Velocity of Car A (VA) = +10 m/s (moving right).
  • Velocity of Car B (VB) = -15 m/s (moving left, hence negative).
To find the velocity of Car A with respect to Car B (VAB):
VAB = VA - VB = (+10) - (-15) = 10 + 15 = +25 m/s.
This means Car B observes Car A moving at 25 m/s in the positive direction (to the right).

To find the velocity of Car B with respect to Car A (VBA):
VBA = VB - VA = (-15) - (+10) = -15 - 10 = -25 m/s.
This means Car A observes Car B moving at 25 m/s in the negative direction (to the left).
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • 1. Adopt a Consistent Sign Convention: Always define a positive direction and strictly adhere to it throughout the problem. This is critical for 1D motion.
  • 2. Clearly Identify Observer and Observed: Explicitly state which relative velocity you are calculating (e.g., VAB means velocity of A as seen by B).
  • 3. Treat Velocities as Vectors: Even in one dimension, velocities are vectors. Use appropriate signs to represent their direction.
  • 4. Visualize with Diagrams: Draw simple diagrams indicating the directions of motion to help in assigning signs correctly.
JEE_Main
Important Unit Conversion

❌ Inconsistent Unit Conversion in Relative Velocity Problems

Students frequently make errors by performing calculations involving relative velocity without ensuring all given quantities (velocities, distances, times) are expressed in a consistent system of units. For instance, mixing kilometers per hour (km/h) with meters per second (m/s) directly in a single equation is a common oversight.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake primarily stems from a lack of attention to detail under exam pressure, or an incorrect assumption that all provided values are already in compatible units. Sometimes, students forget the standard conversion factors or simply rush through the problem-solving steps without a thorough unit check. The JEE Main exam often presents values in different units to test this specific understanding.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Before initiating any calculation for relative velocity, always convert all given quantities to a single, consistent system of units. The International System of Units (SI) (meters for distance, seconds for time, m/s for velocity) is generally preferred unless the problem explicitly demands otherwise. Remember key conversion factors such as 1 km/h = 5/18 m/s or 1 m/s = 18/5 km/h.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
A train moves at 54 km/h and a car moves at 10 m/s in the same direction. Calculate the relative velocity of the train with respect to the car as 54 - 10 = 44 m/s.
Reason for error: Direct subtraction without unit conversion. The result '44 m/s' is dimensionally incorrect for the calculation performed.
βœ… Correct:
A train moves at 54 km/h and a car moves at 10 m/s in the same direction.
  1. First, convert the train's velocity to m/s: 54 km/h * (5/18) m/s per km/h = 15 m/s.
  2. Now, both velocities are in m/s.
  3. Relative velocity (train w.r.t car) = Velocity of train - Velocity of car = 15 m/s - 10 m/s = 5 m/s.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always write down units explicitly: Include units with every numerical value during problem-solving to visually track consistency.
  • Initial Unit Check: Before starting any calculation, dedicate a moment to verify that all given quantities are in a compatible unit system.
  • Master Conversion Factors: Practice common unit conversions until they become second nature (e.g., km/h to m/s, minutes to seconds).
  • Dimensional Analysis: Briefly check the dimensions of your final answer. If you're calculating velocity, the final unit must be a unit of velocity (e.g., m/s, km/h).
JEE_Main
Important Other

❌ Incorrect Application of Sign Conventions and Vector Nature of Velocity

Students frequently overlook the vector nature of velocity in one dimension, failing to assign appropriate positive and negative signs to velocities based on their direction. This leads to simple addition or subtraction of magnitudes instead of correct vector subtraction, resulting in incorrect relative velocity values.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Lack of Consistent Convention: Students often don't explicitly define a positive direction for the problem.
  • Confusion with Scalars: Treating velocity as a scalar quantity (speed) rather than a vector.
  • Misunderstanding the Formula: Applying simplified rules (e.g., 'add if moving towards, subtract if moving away') without understanding the fundamental vector subtraction formula VAB = VA - VB.
βœ… Correct Approach:

To correctly determine relative velocity:

  1. Define a Positive Direction: Clearly establish a consistent positive direction (e.g., right, east, or upwards) for the entire problem.
  2. Assign Signs: Assign positive or negative signs to the velocities of all objects according to the chosen positive direction.
  3. Apply the Formula: Use the vector subtraction formula VAB = VA - VB, where VA and VB are the velocities (with their signs) of object A and object B, respectively.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Problem: Train A moves east at 60 km/h. Train B moves west at 40 km/h. Find the velocity of A relative to B.

Incorrect approach: Some students might think, "They are moving in opposite directions, so I add their speeds."
VAB = 60 + 40 = 100 km/h (Incorrect, as it ignores the actual vector subtraction).

βœ… Correct:

Problem: Train A moves east at 60 km/h. Train B moves west at 40 km/h. Find the velocity of A relative to B.

Correct approach:

  • Let East be the positive direction.
  • Velocity of Train A, VA = +60 km/h (since it moves East).
  • Velocity of Train B, VB = -40 km/h (since it moves West).

Using the formula VAB = VA - VB:

VAB = (+60) - (-40) = 60 + 40 = +100 km/h.

The positive sign indicates that Train A appears to be moving East at 100 km/h with respect to Train B.

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always Start with a Diagram: Visualize the directions of motion.
  • Define Your Coordinate System: Explicitly state which direction is positive. This is crucial for both CBSE and JEE.
  • Treat Velocity as a Vector: Always include signs based on your chosen positive direction.
  • Memorize and Understand the Formula: VAB = VA - VB is fundamental. Don't rely on intuitive (and often incorrect) shortcut rules.
CBSE_12th
Important Approximation

❌ <strong>Incorrect Sign Convention & Approximation of Relative Velocity</strong>

Students frequently make critical errors by incorrectly assigning signs to velocities or by approximating relative velocity as a simple sum or difference of magnitudes. This is especially prevalent when objects move in opposite directions, leading to an incorrect understanding of both the magnitude and, crucially, the direction of the relative velocity. They often confuse speed (magnitude only) with velocity (magnitude + direction).
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Weak Vector Foundation: A fundamental misunderstanding that velocity is a vector quantity, which necessitates defining a consistent positive direction.
  • Ignoring Coordinate System: Failing to establish and adhere to a clear positive and negative direction for the motion.
  • Conceptual Confusion: Misinterpreting phrases like 'moving towards' or 'moving away' as always implying direct addition or subtraction of magnitudes, without considering the underlying vector operations.
  • Rushing Calculations: Students often jump straight to numerical calculations without first setting up the problem correctly with appropriate vector signs.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always begin by defining a positive direction (e.g., rightward, eastward, or upward). Assign appropriate signs (+ or -) to each individual velocity based on this chosen convention. Then, correctly apply the relative velocity formula: VAB = VA - VB, where VAB is the velocity of object A relative to object B. The final sign of the calculated relative velocity will correctly indicate its direction.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Scenario: Car A moves east at 20 m/s. Car B moves west at 15 m/s.

Common Mistake: A student might incorrectly calculate the relative velocity by simply adding the magnitudes (20 + 15 = 35 m/s), stating 'they are moving towards each other, so their speeds add up.' This approximation, while yielding the correct magnitude in this specific case, neglects the vector nature and often leads to errors in other scenarios or when direction is explicitly asked.

βœ… Correct:

Scenario: Car A moves east at 20 m/s. Car B moves west at 15 m/s.

Correct Approach:

  1. Define Positive Direction: Let East be the positive (+) direction.
  2. Individual Velocities:
    • Velocity of Car A, VA = +20 m/s.
    • Velocity of Car B, VB = -15 m/s (since it's moving west, opposite to our positive direction).
  3. Relative Velocity Calculation (VAB = VA - VB):
    VAB = (+20 m/s) - (-15 m/s) = 20 + 15 = +35 m/s.

Interpretation: The positive sign indicates that Car A is moving at 35 m/s in the positive direction (East) relative to Car B. For CBSE, clear explanation of sign convention and formula usage is key.

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always Draw a Diagram: Visualise the motion and clearly mark the directions of individual velocities. This is crucial for both CBSE and JEE.
  • Establish a Consistent Coordinate System: Explicitly state which direction is positive (e.g., 'Let North be positive'). Stick to this convention throughout the problem.
  • Use Signs Consistently: Write all velocities with their correct positive or negative signs before plugging them into the formula.
  • Understand the Formula: Remember that VAB = VA - VB is a vector subtraction. It means 'velocity of A as observed from B'.
  • Practice Diverse Problems: Solve problems where objects move in the same direction, opposite directions, and when one object is stationary, to solidify your conceptual understanding.
CBSE_12th
Important Sign Error

❌ Incorrect Sign Convention in Relative Velocity Calculations

Students often make crucial sign errors when calculating relative velocity in one dimension. This usually stems from treating velocities as scalar magnitudes rather than vector quantities, leading to incorrect addition or subtraction based solely on intuition rather than a consistent sign convention.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Inconsistent Sign Convention: Students might choose a positive direction for one object and then inconsistently apply it or forget it for the second object.
  • Scalar Approach: Forgetting that velocity is a vector and applying simple arithmetic (addition/subtraction of magnitudes) instead of vector subtraction.
  • Misinterpretation of 'Opposite Direction': Assuming 'opposite' automatically means subtracting magnitudes, without considering that one of the velocities is inherently negative in a chosen coordinate system.
  • Formula Misapplication: Directly applying Vrel = VA - VB without ensuring VA and VB already incorporate their correct positive or negative signs relative to a common reference direction.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always establish a clear, consistent sign convention (e.g., right/east as positive, left/west as negative) for all velocities involved. Then, represent each velocity with its correct sign. Finally, apply the relative velocity formula: VAB = VA - VB, where VA and VB are the velocities of object A and B with their respective signs relative to the chosen positive direction. This formula inherently handles both 'same direction' and 'opposite direction' scenarios.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Consider Car A moving East at 10 m/s and Car B moving West at 5 m/s.
Incorrect Calculation: VA = 10 m/s, VB = 5 m/s. Relative velocity of A with respect to B, VAB = VA - VB = 10 - 5 = 5 m/s (Incorrect because VB's direction was ignored).
βœ… Correct:
Consider Car A moving East at 10 m/s and Car B moving West at 5 m/s.
Correct Calculation:
1. Establish Convention: Let East be the positive direction.
2. Assign Signs: Velocity of Car A (VA) = +10 m/s. Velocity of Car B (VB) = -5 m/s.
3. Apply Formula: Relative velocity of A with respect to B, VAB = VA - VB = (+10) - (-5) = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s.
This means Car A appears to move East at 15 m/s to an observer in Car B.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always Define Positive Direction: Clearly state your positive direction at the beginning of every problem (e.g., 'Let East be positive').
  • Assign Signs Carefully: Before any calculation, write down each velocity with its correct positive or negative sign according to your defined convention.
  • Treat as Vectors: Remember that all velocity terms (VA, VB) in the relative velocity formula are vectors, meaning they carry direction through their signs.
  • JEE & CBSE Note: This fundamental understanding is critical for both board exams and competitive exams. A sign error will lead to completely incorrect answers.
CBSE_12th
Important Unit Conversion

❌ Inconsistent Units in Relative Velocity Calculations

Students frequently make the mistake of performing calculations for relative velocity when the given velocities of objects are not in the same system of units (e.g., one in km/h and another in m/s). They often proceed to add or subtract these values directly without prior unit conversion, leading to incorrect results.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake primarily stems from a lack of attention to detail and overlooking the units provided with each numerical value. Sometimes, students rush through problems, assuming all given values are already in a compatible unit system. It can also be due to insufficient practice with unit conversions or a misconception that units can be ignored during intermediate steps.
βœ… Correct Approach:
The fundamental principle is to ensure all physical quantities are expressed in a consistent system of units before performing any mathematical operations. For competitive exams like JEE and CBSE, the SI system (meters, seconds, kilograms) is generally preferred. Convert all velocities to m/s, or if the question explicitly asks for a different unit, convert all to that specific unit (e.g., km/h) before calculating relative velocity.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Problem: Car A moves at 72 km/h and Car B moves in the same direction at 10 m/s. Find the relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B.

Wrong Calculation:
Relative velocity = VA - VB = 72 - 10 = 62 (Incorrect unit implied, result is wrong).

βœ… Correct:

Problem: Car A moves at 72 km/h and Car B moves in the same direction at 10 m/s. Find the relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B.

Correct Approach:
1. Convert VA to m/s:
VA = 72 km/h = 72 × (1000 m / 3600 s) = 72 × (5/18) m/s = 4 × 5 m/s = 20 m/s.
2. VB = 10 m/s (already in SI unit).
3. Calculate relative velocity:
Relative velocity (VAB) = VA - VB = 20 m/s - 10 m/s = 10 m/s.

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always check units: Before starting any calculation, explicitly write down the units of all given quantities.
  • Standardize units first: Convert all values to a common unit system (preferably SI) as the very first step.
  • Practice conversion factors: Memorize common conversion factors like 1 km/h = 5/18 m/s and 1 m/s = 18/5 km/h.
  • Write units at every step: Maintain units throughout your calculations to identify inconsistencies.
  • Self-check: After obtaining the final answer, quickly review if the units are appropriate for the quantity calculated.
CBSE_12th
Important Formula

❌ Incorrect Sign Convention in Relative Velocity Formulas

Students frequently make errors by not consistently applying sign conventions when using the relative velocity formula: vAB = vA - vB. They might treat all speeds as positive magnitudes or arbitrarily add/subtract velocities without defining a reference positive direction, leading to incorrect results, especially in one-dimensional motion where direction is crucial.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of velocity as a vector quantity. Students often confuse speed (scalar) with velocity (vector). They also fail to establish a clear positive direction for their coordinate system before assigning signs to individual velocities, or they forget that the subtraction in the formula accounts for direction.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always define a clear positive direction (e.g., East is positive, Right is positive). Then, assign appropriate signs to each individual velocity (vA and vB) based on their direction relative to your chosen positive direction. Finally, substitute these signed velocities into the formula vAB = vA - vB. Remember that vBA = vB - vA = -vAB.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Consider Car A moving East at 20 m/s and Car B moving West at 10 m/s.
A common wrong approach:
1. Assuming vA = 20 m/s and vB = 10 m/s.
2. Calculating vAB = vA - vB = 20 - 10 = 10 m/s (incorrect).
Another common mistake is thinking, 'they are moving towards each other, so add speeds', leading to vAB = 20 + 10 = 30 m/s (also incorrect for vAB, though 30 m/s is the relative speed of approach).
βœ… Correct:
Using the same scenario: Car A (East at 20 m/s), Car B (West at 10 m/s).
1. Define East as the positive direction.
2. Velocity of Car A, vA = +20 m/s (since it's moving East).
3. Velocity of Car B, vB = -10 m/s (since it's moving West, opposite to positive direction).
4. Relative velocity of A with respect to B:
vAB = vA - vB = (+20) - (-10) = 20 + 10 = +30 m/s.
This means from B's perspective, A is moving at 30 m/s in the positive (East) direction.
5. Relative velocity of B with respect to A:
vBA = vB - vA = (-10) - (+20) = -10 - 20 = -30 m/s.
This means from A's perspective, B is moving at 30 m/s in the negative (West) direction.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always draw a simple diagram to visualize the directions of motion.
  • Explicitly state your chosen positive direction at the beginning of the problem.
  • Assign signs carefully to each individual velocity based on this chosen direction.
  • Double-check if you're calculating vAB or vBA, as the sign will differ.
  • For JEE, this precision is even more critical as options often include both positive and negative results.
CBSE_12th
Important Calculation

❌ Incorrect Application of Sign Convention in Relative Velocity Calculations

Students frequently make errors in assigning positive or negative signs to the velocities of objects when calculating relative velocity in one dimension. This common misstep directly impacts the final magnitude and direction of the relative velocity, leading to incorrect answers.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Lack of Consistent Sign Convention: Not defining a clear positive direction at the outset of the problem.
  • Confusing Speed with Velocity: Treating all given values as positive magnitudes (speeds) instead of velocities with appropriate signs.
  • Poor Visualization: Difficulty in mentally or graphically representing the directions of motion for multiple objects.
  • Misinterpretation of Formula: Applying the relative velocity formula (VAB = VA - VB) without correctly substituting signed velocities.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always establish a consistent sign convention (e.g., right/east as positive, left/west as negative) at the beginning of the problem. Represent each object's velocity as a vector quantity, including its appropriate sign based on the chosen convention. Then, apply the relative velocity formula: VAB = VA - VB (velocity of object A relative to object B).
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Problem: Car A moves to the right at 10 m/s. Car B moves to the left at 5 m/s. Calculate the velocity of A relative to B (VAB).
Wrong Calculation: VA = 10 m/s, VB = 5 m/s. VAB = VA - VB = 10 - 5 = 5 m/s. (This is incorrect because VB is treated as a positive value, ignoring its direction.)
βœ… Correct:
Problem: Car A moves to the right at 10 m/s. Car B moves to the left at 5 m/s. Calculate the velocity of A relative to B (VAB).
Correct Approach:
1. Define Sign Convention: Let right be positive (+), and left be negative (-).
2. Assign Signed Velocities:
  • Velocity of Car A, VA = +10 m/s (moving right)
  • Velocity of Car B, VB = -5 m/s (moving left)
3. Apply Formula: VAB = VA - VB = (+10) - (-5) = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s.
Interpretation: Car A appears to be moving at 15 m/s in the positive direction (to the right) when observed from Car B. This is crucial for both CBSE and JEE calculations.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always Define Direction: Explicitly state your chosen positive direction (e.g., 'Let east be positive').
  • Draw a Diagram: A simple sketch showing the direction of velocities helps prevent sign errors.
  • Differentiate Speed vs. Velocity: Remember that velocity is a vector, and its sign indicates direction.
  • Practice with Both Directions: Solve problems where objects move in the same direction and in opposite directions to solidify understanding.
  • Review the Formula: Clearly understand that VAB means 'velocity of A with respect to B'.
CBSE_12th
Important Conceptual

❌ Ignoring Sign Conventions for Direction in One-Dimensional Relative Velocity

Students frequently treat velocities as scalar quantities (magnitudes only) even when dealing with relative velocity in one dimension. This leads to incorrect addition or subtraction of speeds instead of vector velocities, especially when objects are moving in opposite directions.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of velocity as a vector quantity, where direction is crucial. It often happens due to:
  • Lack of a consistent sign convention (e.g., always taking right as positive).
  • Rushing through problems without drawing a simple diagram.
  • Confusing 'speed' with 'velocity' in calculations.
For CBSE students, this can be a common point of error in descriptive answers where clarity of direction is expected.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always define a positive direction and consistently assign signs to velocities. For one-dimensional motion, if an object moves in the chosen positive direction, its velocity is positive; if it moves in the negative direction, its velocity is negative. The relative velocity of object A with respect to object B is given by VAB = VA - VB, where VA and VB are the absolute velocities (with respect to a common ground frame) and include their respective signs.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Two trains, A and B, are moving towards each other on parallel tracks. Train A moves at 60 km/h and Train B at 40 km/h. A student calculates the relative speed of A with respect to B as (60 + 40) = 100 km/h, assuming speeds add up because they are moving towards each other.
βœ… Correct:
Let's assume the direction of Train A is positive (+).
Velocity of Train A, VA = +60 km/h.
Since Train B is moving towards Train A, its direction is opposite to A's. So, Velocity of Train B, VB = -40 km/h.
Relative velocity of A with respect to B, VAB = VA - VB = (+60) - (-40) = 60 + 40 = +100 km/h.
The positive sign indicates that Train A appears to be moving in its original positive direction at 100 km/h relative to Train B.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Choose a consistent sign convention: Explicitly state which direction is positive at the start of every problem.
  • Draw diagrams: A simple sketch showing the objects and their velocity vectors helps visualize the directions.
  • Remember the formula: Always use Vrelative = Vobject - Vobserver, making sure to substitute velocities with their correct signs.
  • For JEE Advanced: This conceptual clarity is non-negotiable and crucial for solving complex multi-dimensional problems too.
CBSE_12th
Important Conceptual

❌ Ignoring Direction (Sign Convention) in Relative Velocity Calculation

A common conceptual mistake is to treat velocities as scalar quantities or to improperly handle their directions when calculating relative velocity in one dimension. Students often simply subtract the magnitudes, or incorrectly apply sign conventions, leading to errors in both the magnitude and crucial direction of the relative velocity.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Lack of Vector Understanding: Students sometimes forget that even in one dimension, velocity is a vector and its direction (represented by a sign) is critical.
  • Carelessness in Sign Assignment: Failing to consistently assign positive (+) or negative (-) signs to velocities based on a chosen reference direction.
  • Over-simplification: Automatically assuming all velocities are positive or only considering the absolute difference of speeds.
βœ… Correct Approach:
To correctly calculate relative velocity, always:
  1. Choose a Positive Direction: Establish a clear positive direction (e.g., rightward, upward) for your coordinate system.
  2. Assign Signs: Consistently assign positive (+) or negative (-) signs to all given velocities based on this chosen direction.
  3. Apply Vector Subtraction: Use the formula VAB = VA - VB (velocity of A relative to B is velocity of A minus velocity of B). The resulting sign will indicate the direction of the relative velocity.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Problem: Car A moves right at 10 m/s. Car B moves left at 5 m/s.
Wrong approach: Calculating relative velocity as 10 - 5 = 5 m/s. This ignores the opposing directions, giving an incorrect magnitude and no clear direction.
βœ… Correct:
Problem: Car A moves right at 10 m/s. Car B moves left at 5 m/s.
Correct Approach:
Let the right direction be positive (+).
  • Velocity of Car A (VA) = +10 m/s
  • Velocity of Car B (VB) = -5 m/s (since it moves left)
Relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B (VAB) = VA - VB
VAB = (+10 m/s) - (-5 m/s)
VAB = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s.
This means Car A appears to move right at 15 m/s as seen from Car B.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Define Your Axis: Always start by explicitly stating your chosen positive direction (e.g., 'Let positive X be towards the East').
  • Draw Diagrams: A simple diagram showing the direction of each velocity vector can prevent sign errors.
  • Rigorous Sign Usage: Treat the signs as non-negotiable parts of the velocity values.
  • Understand 'Relative To': Remember that 'velocity of A relative to B' means the observer is B, and the formula is always VA - VB.
  • JEE Main Focus: Questions often test this exact conceptual clarity, so attention to signs is paramount for correct answers.
JEE_Main
Important Calculation

❌ Incorrect Sign Convention in Relative Velocity Calculations

A frequent error in one-dimensional relative velocity problems is the improper application of sign conventions when calculating relative velocities. Students often subtract magnitudes directly or assign incorrect signs to velocities, leading to an incorrect resultant relative velocity, especially when objects are moving in opposite directions. This directly impacts the magnitude and perceived direction of relative motion.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake primarily stems from a weak understanding of velocities as vectors and the need for a consistent coordinate system. Students might:
  • Forget to establish a clear positive direction.
  • Treat velocities as scalar quantities (magnitudes only) rather than vectors with direction.
  • Confuse the formula (e.g., VAB = VA - VB) by incorrectly interpreting the subtraction of vector components, particularly when dealing with negative values.
  • Rush through calculations without visualizing the direction of motion for each object.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always define a positive direction (e.g., right, east, north) at the beginning of the problem. Assign appropriate positive or negative signs to the velocities of all objects based on this chosen direction. Then, use the vector subtraction formula VAB = VA - VB, ensuring that VA and VB include their correct signs. The resulting sign of VAB will indicate its direction relative to the chosen positive axis.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Scenario: Car A moves East at 20 m/s. Car B moves West at 10 m/s. Calculate the velocity of Car A with respect to Car B (VAB).

Common Wrong Calculation:

  • Student sets East as positive.
  • VA = +20 m/s.
  • VB = +10 m/s (incorrectly assuming direction).
  • VAB = VA - VB = 20 - 10 = 10 m/s (East).

Mistake: Incorrectly assigned VB as positive, treating it as moving in the same direction as Car A, or simply subtracting magnitudes without considering actual vector directions.

βœ… Correct:

Scenario: Car A moves East at 20 m/s. Car B moves West at 10 m/s. Calculate the velocity of Car A with respect to Car B (VAB).

Correct Calculation:

  1. Define Positive Direction: Let East be the positive direction.
  2. Assign Velocities with Signs:
    VA = +20 m/s (moving East)
    VB = -10 m/s (moving West, opposite to positive direction)
  3. Apply Relative Velocity Formula:
    VAB = VA - VB
    VAB = (+20 m/s) - (-10 m/s)
    VAB = 20 + 10 m/s
    VAB = +30 m/s

Result: The velocity of Car A with respect to Car B is 30 m/s East. This means from Car B's perspective, Car A is approaching it (or moving away from it if A is ahead) at 30 m/s in the eastward direction.

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always Draw a Diagram: A simple diagram showing the direction of motion for each object helps visualize the problem.
  • Establish a Coordinate System: Clearly state which direction is positive (e.g., 'Right is +ve', 'North is +ve'). This is crucial for consistency in JEE Main.
  • Treat Velocities as Vectors: Remember that velocity has both magnitude and direction. Always include the sign (+ or -) with the magnitude based on your chosen coordinate system.
  • Double-Check Sign Application: Pay close attention when substituting values into VAB = VA - VB, especially if one of the velocities is negative.
  • Conceptual Check: After calculation, quickly think if the answer makes sense. If two objects are moving towards each other, their relative speed should be the sum of their individual speeds (magnitudes). If moving away, also sum. If moving in the same direction, the relative speed is the difference.
JEE_Main
Important Formula

❌ Incorrect Sign Convention and Misinterpretation of Relative Velocity Formula

Students frequently make critical errors by not consistently applying sign conventions to velocities in one dimension. This leads to incorrect addition or subtraction in the relative velocity formula. Another common mistake is misinterpreting the meaning of VAB (velocity of A relative to B) or confusing it with VBA.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This error primarily stems from a lack of understanding that velocity is a vector quantity, even in one dimension. Students often treat velocity as a scalar magnitude, ignoring its direction when applying the formula. They might also forget to establish a clear positive reference direction, leading to arbitrary sign assignments, or simply memorize VA - VB without grasping its vector implications.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always define a consistent positive direction (e.g., rightwards or east is positive). Then, assign signs to all velocities based on this chosen direction. The fundamental formula for the velocity of object A relative to object B is VAB = VA - VB. Here, VA and VB are the velocities of A and B with respect to a common ground (or stationary) frame, respectively, including their signs. Remember that VBA = VB - VA = -VAB.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Consider Car A moving East at 10 m/s and Car B moving West at 5 m/s.
Incorrect: A student might write VA = 10 and VB = 5 (ignoring direction for B) and calculate VAB = 10 - 5 = 5 m/s.
βœ… Correct:
Using the same scenario: Car A moves East at 10 m/s, Car B moves West at 5 m/s.
Let's set East as the positive direction.
Therefore, VA = +10 m/s (since it's East)
And VB = -5 m/s (since it's West)
Applying the formula: VAB = VA - VB = (+10) - (-5) = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s.
This means Car A appears to be moving at 15 m/s East relative to Car B. For CBSE and JEE, consistent sign convention is crucial.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Tip 1: Always Define a Positive Direction: Before solving, explicitly state which direction is positive.
  • Tip 2: Draw a Diagram: A simple diagram showing velocity vectors and the chosen positive direction can prevent errors.
  • Tip 3: Treat Velocity as a Vector: Assign appropriate signs to all velocities based on your chosen positive direction before plugging them into the formula.
  • Tip 4: Understand the Formula's Meaning: VAB means 'velocity of A as seen by B'. This 'subtraction' accounts for B's own motion.
JEE_Main
Critical Sign Error

❌ <strong>Critical Sign Error in Relative Velocity Calculation</strong>

Students frequently make errors in assigning correct positive or negative signs to velocities when calculating relative velocity in one dimension. This often leads to incorrect magnitudes and directions of relative velocity. This error is fundamental and can cascade, affecting subsequent calculations in kinematics problems, especially in CBSE 12th examinations where clear conceptual understanding is highly valued.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Inconsistent Sign Convention: Failure to establish and stick to a consistent positive direction (e.g., right is positive, left is negative) throughout the problem.
  • Confusing Magnitudes with Vectors: Treating velocity magnitudes directly in the relative velocity formula (e.g., `V_relative = |V_A| - |V_B|`) instead of their signed vector components.
  • Lack of Visualisation: Not drawing a simple diagram to visualize the directions of motion, which helps in assigning correct signs.
βœ… Correct Approach:
The correct approach involves a clear and consistent application of vector principles:
  1. Choose a Reference Direction: Explicitly define one direction as positive (e.g., 'towards the East is +ve' or 'rightward is +ve'). This is crucial for both CBSE and JEE.
  2. Assign Signs to Individual Velocities: Based on your chosen reference, assign a positive sign to velocities in that direction and a negative sign to velocities in the opposite direction.
  3. Apply the Relative Velocity Formula: Use the formula for relative velocity of object A with respect to B, `V_AB = V_A - V_B`, where `V_A` and `V_B` are the signed velocities.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
A car A is moving right at 10 m/s. A car B is moving left at 5 m/s.
Wrong Calculation: Student might calculate `V_AB = 10 - 5 = 5 m/s` (treating magnitudes), thinking car A is moving faster than B by 5 m/s.
βœ… Correct:
A car A is moving right at 10 m/s. A car B is moving left at 5 m/s.
Correct Calculation:
1. Choose 'right' as the positive direction.
2. `V_A = +10 m/s` (since it's moving right).
3. `V_B = -5 m/s` (since it's moving left, opposite to positive direction).
4. Apply formula: `V_AB = V_A - V_B = (+10) - (-5) = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s`.
This means car A appears to be moving at 15 m/s to the right (in the positive direction) relative to car B. This makes physical sense as they are approaching each other.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always Draw a Diagram: A simple arrow diagram helps visualize directions.
  • Write Down Convention: Explicitly state your chosen positive direction at the beginning of the problem.
  • Use Parentheses: When substituting negative values into equations, always use parentheses to avoid calculation errors, e.g., `V_A - (-V_B)`.
  • Check for Physical Sense: After calculating, mentally check if the result makes sense. If two objects are moving towards each other, their relative speed should generally be the sum of their individual speeds (magnitudes). If moving in the same direction, it's the difference.
CBSE_12th
Critical Approximation

❌ Misapplying Sign Conventions & Neglecting Vector Subtraction in 1D Relative Velocity

Students frequently make a critical error by incorrectly 'approximating' relative velocity as a simple sum or difference of speeds, rather than applying the precise vector subtraction principle with consistent sign conventions. This leads to an incorrect magnitude and/or direction for the relative velocity, treating it like a scalar quantity.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Conceptual Shortcut: Students often rely on oversimplified rules (e.g., 'add speeds if moving towards each other, subtract if moving in the same direction') without understanding their origin or the underlying vector formula, leading to an 'approximated' (and often wrong) mental calculation.
  • Inconsistent Sign Convention: Failure to consistently define and apply a positive direction for all velocities involved in the calculation.
  • Scalar vs. Vector Confusion: Mistaking relative speed for relative velocity, thereby ignoring the crucial directional aspect.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always use the fundamental vector subtraction formula for relative velocity: vAB = vA - vB, where vA and vB are the velocities of object A and object B, respectively, with respect to a common reference frame (usually the ground).
  • Step 1: Establish a consistent positive direction (e.g., rightward is +, leftward is -) for the entire problem.
  • Step 2: Assign the correct sign to each velocity (vA and vB) based on the chosen convention.
  • Step 3: Substitute these signed values into the formula. The sign of the result vAB indicates its direction relative to the chosen positive direction.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Problem: Train A moves East at 40 km/h. Train B moves West at 30 km/h. Find the relative velocity of A with respect to B.
Wrong Approach (Approximation): 'They are moving in opposite directions, so I should add their speeds. Relative velocity is 40 + 30 = 70 km/h.' This treats it as a scalar speed and ignores the specific frame (A w.r.t B) and its direction.
βœ… Correct:
Problem: Train A moves East at 40 km/h. Train B moves West at 30 km/h. Find the relative velocity of A with respect to B.
Solution:
1. Define East as the positive direction (+).
2. Velocity of A, vA = +40 km/h (East)
3. Velocity of B, vB = -30 km/h (West)
4. Using the formula vAB = vA - vB:
vAB = (+40) - (-30) = 40 + 30 = +70 km/h.
The positive sign indicates that the relative velocity of A with respect to B is 70 km/h East. This means from Train B's perspective, Train A is moving East at 70 km/h.
CBSE Relevance: Precise sign conventions are crucial for full marks in descriptive problems.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Visualize and Diagram: Always draw a simple diagram showing the directions of motion.
  • Explicitly State Convention: Write down your chosen positive direction at the start of the solution.
  • Always Use Formula: Stick to vAB = vA - vB. Don't rely on mental shortcuts.
  • Interpret the Result: The sign of your final answer is as important as its magnitude, indicating the relative direction.
CBSE_12th
Critical Other

❌ <span style='color: red;'>Inconsistent Sign Convention & Observer Identification</span>

Students frequently misapply sign conventions for direction and incorrectly identify the observer/observed in the relative velocity formula (VA/B = VA - VB). This leads to critical sign errors, fundamentally misrepresenting the direction of relative motion.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:

  • Weak conceptual grasp of vector subtraction.

  • Failure to establish a consistent positive direction.

  • Confusing VA/B with VB/A.

βœ… Correct Approach:

  1. Consistent Sign Convention: Define a fixed positive direction (e.g., right) for all velocities.

  2. Identify Observer and Observed: For "velocity of X relative to Y", X is observed, Y is observer. Use VXY = VX - VY.

  3. Substitute with Signs: Input VX and VY with their correct signs.

πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

  • Car A moves right (+10 m/s), Car B moves left (-5 m/s).

  • For VA/B: Incorrectly, students might calculate VA/B = 10 - 5 = 5 m/s (ignoring B's sign) or VA/B = 10 + 5 = 15 m/s (incorrectly adding magnitudes).

βœ… Correct:

  • Car A (VA = +10 m/s), Car B (VB = -5 m/s).

  • Velocity of A relative to B (VA/B):

    • VA/B = VA - VB = (+10) - (-5) = +15 m/s.

    • Interpretation: Car A appears to move right at 15 m/s from B's perspective.



πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:

  • Always draw a diagram, marking the positive direction.

  • Write individual velocities with correct signs first.

  • Internalize VXY = VX - VY (X seen by Y).

  • Verify VAB = -VBA.

  • This understanding is crucial for both CBSE and JEE relative motion problems.

CBSE_12th
Critical Unit Conversion

❌ Inconsistent Units in Relative Velocity Calculations

Students frequently make the critical error of performing calculations for relative velocity without ensuring all given velocities are expressed in consistent units. For instance, mixing velocities given in kilometers per hour (km/h) with those in meters per second (m/s) directly within the same equation without conversion.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake primarily stems from a lack of attention to detail, rushing through problems, or an incomplete understanding that all physical quantities involved in an arithmetic operation (addition, subtraction) must be in the same system of units. Sometimes, students forget the conversion factors or assume that the final answer will somehow 'correct' the unit discrepancy.
βœ… Correct Approach:
The correct approach is to always convert all given quantities to a single, consistent system of units before applying any formulas. The SI unit system (meters for distance, seconds for time) is highly recommended for physics problems unless specified otherwise. For relative velocity, ensure all velocities are either in m/s or km/h before adding or subtracting them.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Consider Car A moving at 54 km/h and Car B moving at 10 m/s in the same direction.
Wrong Calculation: Relative velocity = 54 km/h - 10 m/s = 44 (incorrect and meaningless value without consistent units).
βœ… Correct:
Using the same scenario:
Car A velocity = 54 km/h
Car B velocity = 10 m/s
Conversion: Convert 54 km/h to m/s:
54 km/h = 54 * (1000 m / 3600 s) = 54 * (5/18) m/s = 3 * 5 m/s = 15 m/s.
Correct Calculation: Relative velocity = Velocity of A (in m/s) - Velocity of B (in m/s)
= 15 m/s - 10 m/s = 5 m/s.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always check units first: Before starting any calculation, explicitly write down the units for each given quantity.
  • Convert immediately: If units are inconsistent, convert them to a common system (e.g., SI units) at the very beginning of the problem.
  • Memorize key conversion factors: Especially 1 km/h = 5/18 m/s and 1 m/s = 18/5 km/h.
  • Unit tracking: Carry units through your calculations to ensure the final answer has the expected unit. If it doesn't, you've likely made a mistake.
  • Practice: Solve numerous problems involving unit conversions to build confidence and accuracy.
CBSE_12th
Critical Formula

❌ Misinterpreting Sign Convention for Velocities in Relative Velocity Formula

A critical mistake students often make in problems involving relative velocity in one dimension is the incorrect application of sign conventions. They frequently treat the individual velocities (VA, VB) in the relative velocity formula (VAB = VA - VB) as scalar magnitudes rather than vector quantities. This oversight leads to erroneous results, especially when objects are moving in opposite directions.

πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Lack of Vector Understanding: Students might forget that velocity is a vector, and its direction is as crucial as its magnitude.
  • Arbitrary Sign Assignment: Failing to establish a consistent positive direction for the entire problem.
  • Confusion with Scalar Addition: Sometimes, students instinctively add or subtract magnitudes based on a superficial understanding (e.g., 'they are moving towards each other, so add speeds').
  • Rote Memorization: Applying the formula VAB = VA - VB without internalizing that VA and VB themselves carry signs based on direction.
βœ… Correct Approach:

To correctly apply the relative velocity formula, always follow these steps:

  1. Establish a Positive Direction: Clearly define a positive direction (e.g., rightward, upward, East) for your coordinate system. All velocities will be assigned signs relative to this chosen direction.
  2. Assign Signed Velocities: Determine the velocity of each object (VA, VB) as a vector, assigning a positive sign if it moves in the chosen positive direction and a negative sign if it moves in the opposite direction.
  3. Apply the Formula: Substitute these signed velocities into the relative velocity formula: VAB = VA - VB (velocity of A relative to B).
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Problem: Car A moves East at 20 m/s, and Car B moves West at 10 m/s. Find the velocity of Car A relative to Car B (VAB).

Wrong Approach:

  • VA = 20 m/s
  • VB = 10 m/s
  • VAB = VA - VB = 20 - 10 = 10 m/s (East).

This is incorrect because VB was treated as a positive scalar, ignoring its direction.

βœ… Correct:

Correct Approach:

  • Step 1: Define Positive Direction: Let East be the positive direction.
  • Step 2: Assign Signed Velocities:
    • Velocity of Car A (VA) = +20 m/s (since it moves East).
    • Velocity of Car B (VB) = -10 m/s (since it moves West, opposite to positive East).
  • Step 3: Apply Formula:
    • VAB = VA - VB
    • VAB = (+20) - (-10)
    • VAB = 20 + 10 = +30 m/s

Interpretation: Car A appears to move at 30 m/s in the positive (East) direction relative to Car B.

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always draw a simple diagram: This helps visualize directions and assign signs correctly.
  • Write down your chosen positive direction explicitly: 'Let East be +ve' or 'Let right be +ve'.
  • Treat VA and VB as signed numbers: Ensure they reflect their direction.
  • For CBSE and JEE: This concept is fundamental. Mastering sign conventions here prevents errors in more complex 2D and 3D relative motion problems later.
CBSE_12th
Critical Conceptual

❌ Ignoring Sign Conventions for Velocity Vectors

A critically common error is treating velocities as scalar quantities (speeds) and incorrectly adding or subtracting them without accounting for their directions. Students often fail to establish and consistently apply a sign convention, leading to fundamentally incorrect relative velocities.

πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Confusion between Speed and Velocity: Many students use 'velocity' interchangeably with 'speed' and thus neglect its vector nature.
  • Lack of Consistent Sign Convention: Not defining a positive direction (e.g., right as positive, left as negative) at the outset of a problem.
  • Conceptual Misunderstanding of Relative Velocity: Failing to grasp that relative velocity is a vector subtraction (vAB = vA - vB), not merely adding or subtracting magnitudes.
βœ… Correct Approach:

Always establish a clear sign convention for the chosen axis (e.g., positive for motion to the right/up, negative for motion to the left/down). Represent all velocities as vectors with their appropriate signs. Then, apply the vector subtraction formula for relative velocity consistently.

πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Scenario: Two cars, A and B, approach each other. Car A moves right at 20 m/s, Car B moves left at 20 m/s.
Common Wrong Approach: Students might say the relative velocity is 20 - 20 = 0 m/s (if they incorrectly think of difference in speeds when moving towards each other) or 20 + 20 = 40 m/s (if they simply add magnitudes without proper sign context). Both are conceptually flawed without using signs.

βœ… Correct:

Scenario: Two cars, A and B, approach each other. Car A moves right at 20 m/s, Car B moves left at 20 m/s.

Correct Approach:

  1. Define Sign Convention: Let motion to the right be positive (+) and motion to the left be negative (-).
  2. Assign Vector Velocities:
    • Velocity of Car A, vA = +20 m/s
    • Velocity of Car B, vB = -20 m/s
  3. Calculate Relative Velocity (e.g., vAB, velocity of A with respect to B):
    vAB = vA - vB
    vAB = (+20 m/s) - (-20 m/s)
    vAB = 20 + 20 = +40 m/s
    This means Car A appears to be moving away from Car B at 40 m/s, or Car A appears to approach Car B at 40 m/s if observed from B. The positive sign indicates its direction is to the right relative to B.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always Draw a Diagram: Visualize the scenario and direction of motion.
  • Establish a Clear Sign Convention: Write it down at the beginning of your solution.
  • Write Velocities with Signs: Explicitly assign positive or negative signs to all given velocities before substitution into formulas.
  • Remember Vector Subtraction: vrelative = vobserver - vreference. This is fundamental for both CBSE and JEE.
CBSE_12th
Critical Calculation

❌ Ignoring or Incorrectly Applying Sign Conventions for Directions in Relative Velocity Calculations

A critical calculation error students frequently make is to treat velocities as scalar magnitudes rather than vector quantities when calculating relative velocity in one dimension. This often leads to incorrect addition or subtraction, as the direction of motion (represented by a sign) is overlooked.

πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Lack of Vector Understanding: Students fail to grasp that velocity is a vector and its direction must be accounted for mathematically.
  • Rushing Calculations: In a hurry, students might instinctively add or subtract magnitudes without first establishing a consistent sign convention.
  • Conceptual Confusion: Difficulty distinguishing between 'speed' (scalar) and 'velocity' (vector) and how it impacts relative motion formulas.
βœ… Correct Approach:

To correctly calculate relative velocity (VAB = VA - VB), it is essential to:

  1. Define a Positive Direction: Establish a clear positive direction (e.g., rightwards or upwards) for your entire problem.
  2. Assign Signs Consistently: Assign a positive (+) sign to velocities in the chosen positive direction and a negative (-) sign to velocities in the opposite direction.
  3. Apply the Vector Formula: Substitute these signed velocities into the relative velocity formula.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Problem: Car A moves east at 20 m/s, Car B moves west at 10 m/s. Find the relative velocity of A with respect to B.
Wrong Calculation (assuming east is +): VA = +20 m/s, VB = +10 m/s (incorrectly treating west as positive, or just using magnitudes)
VAB = VA - VB = 20 - 10 = 10 m/s (East).
This ignores the fact that B is moving in the opposite direction.

βœ… Correct:

Problem: Car A moves east at 20 m/s, Car B moves west at 10 m/s. Find the relative velocity of A with respect to B.
Correct Approach:
1. Define positive direction: Let East be the positive direction.
2. Assign signs:
VA = +20 m/s (East)
VB = -10 m/s (West, opposite to positive direction)
3. Apply formula:
VAB = VA - VB = (+20) - (-10)
VAB = 20 + 10 = +30 m/s.
This means Car A appears to be moving at 30 m/s East relative to Car B.

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Draw a Diagram: Always sketch the directions of velocities. This visual aid helps in assigning correct signs.
  • Explicitly State Convention: Before solving, write down your chosen positive direction (e.g., 'Let right be positive').
  • Check Your Answer: Does the magnitude and direction of your relative velocity make sense intuitively? If two objects are moving towards each other, their relative speed should be the sum of their individual speeds.
  • Practice Varied Problems: Work through problems where objects move in the same direction, opposite directions, and where one is stationary.
CBSE_12th
Critical Other

❌ <strong>Inconsistent Sign Convention and Reference Frame Errors</strong>

Students frequently make critical errors by inconsistently applying sign conventions for velocities or by misinterpreting the specific reference frame from which relative velocity is to be calculated. This often leads to incorrect vector subtraction, yielding wrong magnitudes and directions of relative velocity in one-dimensional problems.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Lack of a clear, consistent positive direction established at the problem's outset.
  • Confusion when objects change their direction of motion.
  • Failure to understand that relative velocity is a vector subtraction ($vec{v}_{AB} = vec{v}_A - vec{v}_B$), where signs must accurately reflect the chosen positive direction.
  • Treating relative speeds as relative velocities directly without considering the vector nature and direction.
βœ… Correct Approach:
To avoid errors:
  • Always establish a clear positive direction (e.g., East or rightwards) at the beginning of the problem.
  • Represent all individual velocities as vectors with appropriate signs relative to this chosen direction.
  • Consistently apply the vector subtraction formula: $vec{v}_{AB} = vec{v}_A - vec{v}_B$.
  • Remember that 'relative velocity of A with respect to B' means finding the velocity of A as observed from B, which is precisely $vec{v}_A - vec{v}_B$.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Scenario: Car A moves East at 20 m/s, Car B moves West at 10 m/s.
Common Wrong Calculation: Relative velocity of A w.r.t B is (20 + 10) = 30 m/s (incorrectly adding magnitudes because they move towards each other, or simply ignoring signs).
βœ… Correct:
Scenario: Car A moves East at 20 m/s, Car B moves West at 10 m/s.
Correct Approach:
  1. Define positive direction: Let East be the positive direction.
  2. Assign signs:
    $vec{v}_A = +20 ext{ m/s}$ (East)
    $vec{v}_B = -10 ext{ m/s}$ (West)
  3. Calculate relative velocity:
    $vec{v}_{AB} = vec{v}_A - vec{v}_B = (+20) - (-10) = 20 + 10 = +30 ext{ m/s}$.
    The positive sign indicates that the relative velocity of A with respect to B is in the East direction.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Draw a Clear Diagram: Always visualize the directions of motion.
  • Explicitly State Sign Convention: Write down your chosen positive direction at the start of every problem.
  • Assign Signs Consistently: Apply the chosen convention to all velocities in the problem.
  • Use Vector Notation: Always use $vec{v}_{AB} = vec{v}_A - vec{v}_B$ as a vector equation.
  • Practice Varied Problems: Solve questions involving objects moving in the same, opposite, and changing directions.
JEE_Advanced
Critical Approximation

❌ Approximating Relative Velocity by Scalar Magnitude Operations

Students frequently make the critical error of treating velocity as a scalar quantity in relative velocity calculations, especially in 1D. Instead of performing proper vector subtraction (which simplifies to algebraic subtraction with signs in 1D), they often approximate the relative velocity by simply adding or subtracting the magnitudes of the individual velocities. This neglects the crucial role of direction (sign) and leads to incorrect results for both the magnitude and direction of the relative velocity.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of velocity as a vector. Students often confuse 'speed' with 'velocity' and forget that relative velocity is a vector operation. They might incorrectly apply rules like 'if objects move towards each other, add speeds; if away, subtract speeds' without a rigorous sign convention, leading to a faulty approximation of the actual relative velocity. Over-reliance on memorized rules without understanding the underlying vector principle is a key reason.
βœ… Correct Approach:
The correct approach for relative velocity in one dimension is to consistently define a positive direction and then apply the vector subtraction formula using signed velocities. For two objects A and B, the velocity of A relative to B is given by vAB = vA - vB, where vA and vB are the velocities of A and B with respect to a common reference frame (usually the ground), including their respective signs based on the chosen positive direction.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Problem: Car A moves East at 10 m/s, and Car B moves West at 5 m/s. What is the velocity of Car A with respect to Car B?

Incorrect Approximation:
Student incorrectly assumes relative speed = (10 - 5) m/s = 5 m/s (if thought to be 'separating') OR (10 + 5) m/s = 15 m/s (if thought to be 'approaching'). Both are approximations lacking vector rigor. The 'approaching' intuition might lead to 15 m/s, but without proper sign convention, the direction will be ambiguous or wrong.
βœ… Correct:

Problem: Car A moves East at 10 m/s, and Car B moves West at 5 m/s. What is the velocity of Car A with respect to Car B?

Correct Approach:
1. Define East as the positive (+) direction.
2. Velocity of Car A, vA = +10 m/s.
3. Velocity of Car B, vB = -5 m/s (since West is opposite to East).
4. Apply the relative velocity formula: vAB = vA - vB
vAB = (+10 m/s) - (-5 m/s)
vAB = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s.
This means Car A is moving at 15 m/s East with respect to Car B. The positive sign indicates the direction is East.
For JEE Advanced, this fundamental clarity is non-negotiable.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always Draw a Diagram: Visualizing the directions helps in assigning correct signs.
  • Define a Positive Direction: Explicitly state which direction is positive at the beginning of the problem.
  • Assign Signs to Velocities: Convert all speeds into velocities by giving them appropriate positive or negative signs.
  • Use the Vector Formula Consistently: Always use vAB = vA - vB. Do not try to guess by adding or subtracting magnitudes.
  • Check the Result's Sign: The sign of the final relative velocity tells you its direction relative to your chosen positive direction.
JEE_Advanced
Critical Sign Error

❌ Inconsistent Sign Convention in Relative Velocity

Students frequently make critical sign errors calculating relative velocity in one dimension. This arises from inconsistent sign conventions or treating velocities as scalar speeds instead of vectors, leading to incorrect magnitudes or directions.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
  • Inconsistent Sign Convention: Failing to define a fixed positive direction for the problem.
  • Confusing Speed with Velocity: Treating velocity as a scalar magnitude.
  • Incorrect Vector Subtraction: Arbitrarily adding/subtracting magnitudes instead of applying VA/B = VA - VB.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always establish a clear, consistent sign convention (e.g., right = positive). Assign appropriate signs to all object velocities. Then, apply VAB = VA - VB, where VA and VB are velocities with their respective signs.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Scenario: Car A moves east at 20 m/s. Car B moves west at 10 m/s. Calculate VA/B.
Wrong Approach: Student adds magnitudes, assuming 'relative' means sum for opposite directions: VA/B = 20 + 10 = 30 m/s. (Incorrect scalar addition).
βœ… Correct:
Scenario: Car A moves east at 20 m/s. Car B moves west at 10 m/s. Calculate VA/B.
Correct Approach:
1. Convention: Let East be positive (+); West is negative (-).
2. Signed Velocities: VA = +20 m/s, VB = -10 m/s.
3. Formula: VA/B = VA - VB = (+20) - (-10) = 20 + 10 = +30 m/s.
Result: +30 m/s (30 m/s East). From B's perspective, A moves 30 m/s East.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Draw Diagram: Sketch and indicate velocity directions.
  • State Convention: Define your positive direction explicitly.
  • Write Signed Velocities: List all velocities with correct signs.
  • Verify Direction: Check if the sign makes physical sense.
JEE_Advanced
Critical Unit Conversion

❌ <strong><span style='color: #FF0000;'>Critical Mistake: Inconsistent Units in Relative Velocity Calculations</span></strong>

Students frequently make the critical error of performing relative velocity calculations without ensuring that all given quantities are in a consistent system of units. This often involves mixing units like kilometers per hour (km/h) with meters per second (m/s) directly in the same equation, leading to fundamentally incorrect numerical answers. This oversight is particularly penalizing in JEE Advanced, where precision is paramount.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake stems from several factors:
  • Lack of Attention: Overlooking the units written alongside the numerical values.
  • Rushing: Attempting to solve problems quickly without a preliminary unit check.
  • Assumption: Assuming all values are already compatible or in the standard SI unit system.
  • Forgetting Conversion Factors: Not recalling or correctly applying common conversion factors (e.g., 1 km/h = 5/18 m/s).
  • Focus on Formula Only: Concentrating solely on the relative velocity formula (vAB = vA - vB) without considering the nature of the quantities involved.
βœ… Correct Approach:
To avoid this critical error, always follow these steps:
  1. Identify Units: Before any calculation, list all given quantities and their respective units.
  2. Choose a Consistent System: Select a standard system (e.g., SI units – meters, seconds) and convert all quantities to this chosen system.
  3. Apply Conversion Factors: Use accurate conversion factors (e.g., multiply km/h by 5/18 to get m/s; multiply km by 1000 to get meters).
  4. Perform Calculation: Once all units are consistent, then apply the relative velocity formula.
  5. Final Unit Check: Ensure the final answer is presented in the required unit, performing a reverse conversion if necessary.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Problem: Car A moves at 72 km/h and Car B moves at 15 m/s in the same direction. Find the relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B.
Wrong Calculation:
vAB = vA - vB = 72 - 15 = 57.
This answer (57) is numerically incorrect and unit-less, demonstrating the mistake of mixing km/h and m/s directly.
βœ… Correct:
Correct Calculation:
1. Convert vA to m/s: 72 km/h * (5/18 m/s per km/h) = 20 m/s.
2. vB is already 15 m/s.
3. Calculate relative velocity: vAB = vA - vB = 20 m/s - 15 m/s = 5 m/s.
This approach ensures all quantities are in SI units before calculation, yielding the correct result.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always Write Units: Make it a habit to write units alongside every numerical value throughout your solution.
  • Pre-Calculation Unit Check: Before starting any calculation, dedicate a moment to verify unit consistency for all given data.
  • Memorize Key Conversions: Be proficient with common conversion factors (e.g., km/h to m/s, cm to m, minutes to seconds).
  • JEE Advanced Tip: Examiners often include mixed units intentionally to test your vigilance on this fundamental aspect. Do not fall for this trap! Consistent units are non-negotiable for accurate answers.
JEE_Advanced
Critical Formula

❌ <span style='color: red;'>Ignoring Directional Signs for Velocities in Relative Motion Formulas</span>

A critical mistake in one-dimensional relative velocity problems is to treat velocities as scalar magnitudes rather than vector quantities. Students often apply the formula vAB = vA - vB without correctly assigning positive or negative signs to vA and vB based on a chosen coordinate system. This leads to incorrect relative velocities, especially when objects move in opposite directions.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This error frequently occurs due to several reasons:
  • Lack of a defined sign convention: Students start calculations without establishing a clear positive direction.
  • Confusing speed with velocity: Treating the given magnitudes directly as 'v' values without considering their vectorial nature.
  • Hasty application: Rushing to subtract magnitudes without careful analysis of motion directions.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always define a positive direction (e.g., rightward is positive) before starting the problem. Assign the appropriate positive or negative sign to each individual velocity (vA and vB) based on their direction relative to your chosen convention. Then, apply the relative velocity formula as a vector subtraction using these signed values. Remember, the formula is a vector operation.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Problem: Car A moves east at 20 m/s. Car B moves west at 10 m/s. Find the velocity of Car A relative to Car B (vAB).
Student's Incorrect Approach (ignoring signs):
Let vA = 20 m/s, vB = 10 m/s.
vAB = vA - vB = 20 - 10 = 10 m/s (incorrect magnitude and direction).
βœ… Correct:
Correct Approach:
1. Define East as the positive direction.
2. Assign signs: vA = +20 m/s (east), vB = -10 m/s (west).
3. Apply the formula: vAB = vA - vB
vAB = (+20) - (-10)
vAB = 20 + 10 = +30 m/s.
Interpretation: From Car B's perspective, Car A is moving eastward at 30 m/s. This makes intuitive sense as they are moving towards each other, and A appears to approach B at their combined speeds.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Draw a Diagram: Always sketch the scenario, showing the direction of motion for each object.
  • Establish Convention: Clearly state your chosen positive direction at the beginning of the solution.
  • Assign Signs Carefully: Convert speeds into signed velocities based on your convention.
  • JEE Advanced Tip: Always double-check your sign conventions. A small error in sign can lead to a completely wrong answer or choosing an incorrect option from multiple choices.
JEE_Advanced
Critical Calculation

❌ Incorrect Sign Convention in Relative Velocity Calculations

Students frequently make critical calculation errors by failing to consistently apply a sign convention for velocities when determining relative velocity in one dimension. This often leads to incorrect magnitudes or directions, particularly when objects are moving towards or away from each other, or in opposite directions.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake primarily stems from a lack of treating velocity as a vector quantity with both magnitude and direction. Students often instinctively subtract magnitudes, especially when objects are moving in opposite directions, instead of performing a vector subtraction which inherently includes the signs. The absence of a clear, predefined positive direction exacerbates this issue. For JEE Advanced, a robust understanding of vector signs is non-negotiable.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always define a clear positive direction (e.g., rightwards or upwards) at the start of the problem. Assign positive or negative signs to the velocities of all objects consistently based on this chosen direction. Then, apply the relative velocity formula: VAB = VA - VB, ensuring that VA and VB include their correct signs. The resulting sign of VAB will indicate its direction.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Two cars, A and B, are moving on a straight road. Car A moves right at 10 m/s. Car B moves left at 5 m/s.
Wrong Calculation: Velocity of A relative to B, VAB = 10 - 5 = 5 m/s (incorrectly subtracting magnitudes).
βœ… Correct:
Two cars, A and B, are moving on a straight road. Car A moves right at 10 m/s. Car B moves left at 5 m/s.
Correct Approach:
1. Define positive direction: Rightwards is positive (+).
2. Velocities with signs: VA = +10 m/s, VB = -5 m/s.
3. Apply formula: VAB = VA - VB = (+10) - (-5) = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s.
This means car A appears to be moving at 15 m/s to the right relative to car B. The magnitude is 15 m/s, and the direction is rightwards.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Establish a Coordinate System: Always define a positive direction at the very beginning of solving any relative velocity problem.
  • Treat Velocity as a Vector: Consistently assign appropriate positive or negative signs to all velocities based on your chosen coordinate system.
  • Use Standard Formula: Stick to the formula VAB = VA - VB. Do not try to intuitively add or subtract magnitudes.
  • Verify Direction: After calculation, interpret the sign of the relative velocity to ensure it makes physical sense in the context of the problem.
  • JEE Advanced Tip: Practice problems where objects change direction or encounter complex scenarios to solidify your sign convention understanding.
JEE_Advanced
Critical Conceptual

❌ Inconsistent Sign Convention & Relative Velocity Formula Misapplication

Students frequently make critical errors by:
  • Inconsistently using signs: Treating velocity as speed, thereby ignoring the crucial directional information represented by positive or negative signs.
  • Misapplying the formula: Incorrectly using VAB = VA - VB (velocity of A with respect to B), often reversing the subtraction (e.g., VB - VA) or confusing which velocity is being subtracted from which.
This leads to fundamentally incorrect relative velocities.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This critical conceptual error typically stems from:
  • A weak understanding of vectors in one dimension, where signs are paramount for denoting direction.
  • Lack of clarity on the precise meaning of 'relative to' or 'with respect to' another object/frame.
  • Failure to establish and adhere to a consistent coordinate system at the outset of a problem, leading to sign errors.
  • Rote memorization of formulas without grasping their underlying vector principles (especially for JEE Advanced preparation).
βœ… Correct Approach:
To avoid these mistakes, follow these steps systematically:
  1. Define Coordinate System: Explicitly choose a positive direction (e.g., right = +ve, left = -ve) at the start of every problem. Stick to this convention.
  2. Assign Signed Velocities: Write down all given velocities with their correct signs according to your chosen coordinate system (e.g., VA = +10 m/s, VB = -5 m/s).
  3. Apply Formula Consistently: Understand that for the velocity of object A relative to object B, the formula is always VAB = VA - VB.
  4. Substitute with Signs: Always substitute the velocities with their respective signs into the formula.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Consider Object A moving right at 10 m/s and Object B moving left at 5 m/s. A student might incorrectly calculate VAB as 10 - 5 = 5 m/s (ignoring B's direction) or even 10 + 5 = 15 m/s (confusing it with relative speed or misunderstanding the vector subtraction).
βœ… Correct:

Let Object A move right at 10 m/s and Object B move left at 5 m/s. Find VAB (velocity of A with respect to B).

  1. Coordinate System: Let right be +ve.
  2. Individual Velocities:
    • VA = +10 m/s
    • VB = -5 m/s
  3. Calculation (using VAB = VA - VB):
    • VAB = (+10) - (-5)
    • VAB = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s

This means A is moving at 15 m/s to the right relative to B. An observer on B would see A approaching them from their left at 15 m/s.

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always draw a diagram: Visually represent the objects and their directions, then clearly mark your chosen positive direction.
  • Explicitly write down velocities with signs: Force yourself to assign a sign to every velocity (e.g., Vcar = +20 m/s, Vbike = -10 m/s) before calculation.
  • Understand the formula's meaning: VAB means 'velocity of A MINUS velocity of B'.
  • Practice extensively: Solve a variety of problems to solidify your conceptual understanding and application of sign conventions.
JEE_Advanced
Critical Conceptual

❌ Incorrect Sign Convention in Relative Velocity Calculation

A common and critical error in JEE Main is the incorrect application of sign conventions when calculating relative velocity in one dimension. Students frequently treat velocity magnitudes directly or misapply addition/subtraction, especially when objects are moving in opposite directions, rather than consistently using vector signs.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of velocity as a vector quantity. Students often neglect to:
  • Establish a consistent positive direction: Without a clear reference, signs become arbitrary.
  • Assign signs to individual velocities: They might use only magnitudes or incorrectly assume that opposite directions always mean adding or subtracting magnitudes without a proper formula.
  • Apply the vector subtraction formula correctly: Forgetting that relative velocity VAB = VA - VB requires algebraic subtraction of signed velocities.
This leads to errors in both magnitude and direction of the relative velocity.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always treat velocity as a vector. Follow these steps consistently:
  1. Define a Positive Direction: Explicitly choose one direction (e.g., right, East, upwards) as positive.
  2. Assign Signs to Individual Velocities: Write down each object's velocity (VA, VB) with its appropriate sign based on the chosen positive direction.
  3. Apply the Relative Velocity Formula: Use the vector subtraction formula: VAB = VA - VB (relative velocity of A with respect to B). The resulting sign will indicate the direction of the relative velocity.
    Similarly, VBA = VB - VA.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Problem: Car A moves East at 20 m/s, and Car B moves West at 10 m/s. What is the relative velocity of A with respect to B?
Wrong Approach:
  • Student 1: 20 + 10 = 30 m/s (incorrectly adding magnitudes, assuming opposite directions always mean adding relative speeds).
  • Student 2: 20 - 10 = 10 m/s (incorrectly subtracting magnitudes, possibly confusing it with same direction motion or not applying signs).
βœ… Correct:
Problem: Car A moves East at 20 m/s, and Car B moves West at 10 m/s. What is the relative velocity of A with respect to B?
Correct Approach:
  1. Define Positive Direction: Let East be the positive direction.
  2. Assign Signs:
    • Velocity of Car A (VA) = +20 m/s (moving East)
    • Velocity of Car B (VB) = -10 m/s (moving West)
  3. Apply Formula:
    Relative velocity of A with respect to B (VAB) = VA - VB
    VAB = (+20 m/s) - (-10 m/s)
    VAB = 20 + 10 = +30 m/s
The positive sign indicates that Car A appears to move East at 30 m/s relative to Car B.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Draw Diagrams: Always sketch the scenario, clearly indicating directions.
  • Establish Coordinate System: Make it a habit to explicitly state 'Let right be positive' or 'Let North be positive'.
  • Write Signed Velocities: Before any calculation, write down VA = +x, VB = -y, etc.
  • Memorize the Formula: Understand that Vrelative = Vobject - Vobserver, where V represents signed velocities.
  • Practice with Varying Directions: Solve problems where both objects move in the same direction, opposite directions, and one is stationary.
JEE_Main
Critical Formula

❌ Ignoring Sign Convention (Vector Nature) in Relative Velocity Formulas

A critical mistake is failing to treat velocity as a vector quantity and not correctly applying sign conventions (e.g., positive for one direction, negative for the opposite) when calculating relative velocity in one dimension. Students often just subtract or add magnitudes directly, overlooking the crucial directional aspect inherent in the formula VAB = VA - VB.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This error stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of vector addition/subtraction, treating velocity as a scalar. It's often due to rote memorization of formulas without conceptual clarity or a hasty approach during problem-solving, leading to direct numerical operations on magnitudes rather than vector components.
βœ… Correct Approach:

To correctly apply the relative velocity formula:

  • Establish a clear sign convention: Designate one direction as positive (e.g., right, East, North) and the opposite as negative.
  • Assign signs to individual velocities: Based on the chosen convention, represent VA and VB with their correct signs.
  • Apply the formula strictly: Use VAB = VA - VB (or VBA = VB - VA) with the signed velocities. The resulting sign indicates the direction of relative velocity.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:

Scenario: Car A moves East at 20 m/s. Car B moves West at 10 m/s. Find the velocity of Car A with respect to Car B (VAB).

Wrong thought process: "They are moving towards each other, so their relative speed is 20 + 10 = 30 m/s." Or, "Just subtract them, 20 - 10 = 10 m/s."

Incorrect Calculation: VAB = 20 + 10 = 30 m/s (if adding magnitudes) or VAB = 20 - 10 = 10 m/s (if subtracting magnitudes directly without signs).

βœ… Correct:

Scenario: Car A moves East at 20 m/s. Car B moves West at 10 m/s. Find the velocity of Car A with respect to Car B (VAB).

Correct Approach:

  1. Sign Convention: Let East be positive (+ve) and West be negative (-ve).
  2. Individual Velocities:
    • VA = +20 m/s (East)
    • VB = -10 m/s (West)
  3. Applying Formula:VAB = VA - VB = (+20) - (-10) = 20 + 10 = +30 m/s

Result: VAB = +30 m/s. This means Car A appears to move East at 30 m/s relative to Car B.

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always define a coordinate system: Explicitly state which direction is positive. This is non-negotiable for vector problems.
  • Draw a simple diagram: Visualizing the directions of velocities helps in assigning correct signs.
  • Treat VAB = VA - VB as a vector equation: This means substituting the *signed* scalar components, not just magnitudes.
  • Practice diverse problems: Solve cases where objects move in the same direction, opposite directions, and where one object is stationary.
JEE_Main
Critical Unit Conversion

❌ <strong>Inconsistent Unit Usage in Relative Velocity Calculations</strong>

A common and critical error in JEE Main relative velocity problems is directly using quantities with inconsistent units (e.g., km/h and m/s) within the same calculation without proper conversion. This leads to fundamentally incorrect results.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This mistake primarily stems from:
  • Carelessness: Students often rush through problems and overlook unit details.
  • Lack of habit: Not consistently converting all values to a single system (like SI units) before starting calculations.
  • Forgetting Conversion Factors: Especially for km/h to m/s (5/18 or 18/5).
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always ensure all given physical quantities are expressed in a consistent system of units (preferably SI units – metres, seconds, kilograms) before performing any mathematical operations for relative velocity. Remember: 1 km/h = 5/18 m/s and 1 m/s = 18/5 km/h.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Consider two cars moving towards each other. Car A's speed is 54 km/h and Car B's speed is 10 m/s. Calculate their relative speed.
Wrong Calculation: Relative Speed = 54 km/h + 10 m/s = 64 (units undefined/incorrect). This direct addition is fundamentally flawed due to inconsistent units.
βœ… Correct:
Consider the same scenario: Car A's speed is 54 km/h and Car B's speed is 10 m/s. Calculate their relative speed.
Correct Approach:
  1. Convert Car A's speed to m/s:
    54 km/h = 54 Γ— (5/18) m/s = 3 Γ— 5 m/s = 15 m/s.
  2. Now, both speeds are in m/s.
  3. Relative Speed = Speed of Car A + Speed of Car B (since they are moving towards each other)
    Relative Speed = 15 m/s + 10 m/s = 25 m/s.
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Read Carefully: Always highlight or underline the units given in the problem statement.
  • Convert First: Make it a strict habit to convert all quantities to a standard system (e.g., SI units) at the very beginning of solving any numerical problem.
  • Write Units: Carry units throughout your calculations. This helps in identifying inconsistencies.
  • Practice Conversions: Regularly practice basic unit conversions to memorize common factors (like km/h to m/s).
JEE_Main
Critical Approximation

❌ Incorrect Sign Convention in Relative Velocity

Students frequently make the critical mistake of ignoring or inconsistently applying sign conventions when dealing with velocities in one dimension. This leads to incorrect magnitudes and directions for relative velocity. They often treat velocities as scalar speeds and simply add or subtract them based on an intuitive (and often wrong) understanding of 'moving towards' or 'moving away', instead of adhering to a rigorous vector approach.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
This error stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of velocity as a vector quantity. Students:
  • Fail to establish a consistent positive direction for the problem.
  • Confuse speed (a scalar) with velocity (a vector), applying scalar arithmetic inappropriately.
  • Attempt to 'approximate' the result by guessing whether velocities should add or subtract, rather than systematically applying the vector subtraction formula.
  • Skip drawing a clear diagram to visualize the directions of motion.
βœ… Correct Approach:
To correctly determine relative velocity, always:
  1. Define a positive direction: Clearly state which direction (e.g., right, East, upwards) is positive for the entire problem.
  2. Assign signs: Represent all given velocities with appropriate algebraic signs (+ or -) based on your defined positive direction.
  3. Apply the formula: Use the relative velocity formula VAB = VA - VB consistently, where VA and VB are the signed velocities of objects A and B, respectively.
  4. Interpret the result: The sign of the calculated VAB will indicate its direction relative to the chosen positive direction. Its magnitude is the relative speed.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Scenario: Car A moves to the right at 20 m/s. Car B moves to the left at 10 m/s. Calculate the relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B (VAB).
Wrong Calculation: A student might incorrectly assume VAB = 20 - 10 = 10 m/s, or simply sum speeds because they are moving in opposite directions, getting 30 m/s, without proper sign convention.
βœ… Correct:
Scenario: Car A moves to the right at 20 m/s. Car B moves to the left at 10 m/s. Calculate VAB.
Correct Approach:
  1. Define: Let the direction to the right be positive (+).
  2. Assign Signs:
    VA = +20 m/s (moving right)
    VB = -10 m/s (moving left)
  3. Apply Formula:
    VAB = VA - VB
    VAB = (+20 m/s) - (-10 m/s)
    VAB = 20 + 10 = +30 m/s
  4. Interpret: The relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B is 30 m/s to the right (positive direction).
πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:
  • Always Draw a Diagram: A simple diagram showing objects and their velocity vectors with arrows is invaluable.
  • Establish a Consistent Convention: Stick to one positive direction throughout the problem.
  • Treat Velocities as Vectors: Remember that velocity has both magnitude and direction, even in 1D.
  • Practice Systematically: Solve problems by explicitly writing down assigned signs before applying formulas.
JEE_Main
Critical Other

❌ Incorrect Sign Convention for Velocities in 1D Relative Motion

A common critical mistake is failing to assign correct positive or negative signs to the velocities of objects based on a defined coordinate system, treating speed as velocity, or applying formulas without considering the vector nature of velocity in one dimension.
πŸ’­ Why This Happens:
Students often treat all velocities as positive magnitudes (speeds) when performing calculations. This stems from an insufficient understanding that velocity is a vector quantity, and its direction (even in 1D) must be explicitly accounted for using signs. They might memorize the formula Vrel = VA - VB without internalizing the vector subtraction.
βœ… Correct Approach:
Always establish a clear positive direction (e.g., rightwards or upwards) for your coordinate system. Then, assign the appropriate sign (+ or -) to each object's velocity vector based on its direction relative to your chosen positive direction. Finally, apply the relative velocity formula VAB = VA - VB, ensuring VA and VB include their correct signs.
πŸ“ Examples:
❌ Wrong:
Two cars, A and B, are moving on a straight road. Car A moves right at 10 m/s, and Car B moves left at 5 m/s. A student might incorrectly calculate the relative velocity of A with respect to B as 10 - 5 = 5 m/s or even 10 + 5 = 15 m/s by just adding/subtracting magnitudes.
βœ… Correct:
Let's assume the right direction is positive (+ve).

  • Velocity of Car A, VA = +10 m/s (moving right)

  • Velocity of Car B, VB = -5 m/s (moving left)


Relative velocity of Car A with respect to Car B (VAB):


VAB = VA - VB = (+10) - (-5) = 10 + 5 = +15 m/s


This means Car A appears to move at 15 m/s in the positive (right) direction as observed from Car B.


Relative velocity of Car B with respect to Car A (VBA):


VBA = VB - VA = (-5) - (+10) = -5 - 10 = -15 m/s


This means Car B appears to move at 15 m/s in the negative (left) direction as observed from Car A.

πŸ’‘ Prevention Tips:

  • Always draw a simple diagram to visualize the motion and clearly mark your chosen positive direction.

  • Explicitly write down the velocities with their signs (e.g., VA = +10 m/s, VB = -5 m/s) before substituting them into any formula.

  • Remember: speed is the magnitude of velocity and does not inherently carry directional information; velocity does.

  • JEE Main Tip: Errors in sign convention are easily made under exam pressure. Practice with varied problems to solidify this fundamental concept.

JEE_Main

No summary available yet.

No educational resource available yet.

Relative velocity in one dimension

Subject: Physics
Unit: 2 - KINEMATICS
Sub-unit: 2.1 - Motion in a Straight Line
Complexity: Mid
Syllabus: JEE_Main

Content Completeness: 66.7%

66.7%
πŸ“š Explanations: 0
πŸ“ CBSE Problems: 19
🎯 JEE Problems: 12
πŸŽ₯ Videos: 0
πŸ–ΌοΈ Images: 0
πŸ“ Formulas: 3
πŸ“š References: 10
⚠️ Mistakes: 60
πŸ€– AI Explanation: Yes